- Joined
- Apr 6, 2014
- Messages
- 14,146
- Reaction score
- 22,778
yep, the real question is why the DO programs signed up for the merger when it seems like the result will be a lot more DOs struggling or failing to matchThats good if you're a md candidate
yep, the real question is why the DO programs signed up for the merger when it seems like the result will be a lot more DOs struggling or failing to matchThats good if you're a md candidate
Because there are an inadequate number of DO residencies to begin with.yep, the real question is why the DO programs signed up for the merger when it seems like the result will be a lot more DOs struggling or failing to match
Quick, I need someone with a PhD to tell me what the origins and insertions of the vastus lateralis are!
I just had a course taught by a PhD candidate; he taught a 100-level math course (at a respectable public school).
can you explain thatBecause there are an inadequate number of DO residencies to begin with.
The whole system relies on an abundance of MD residencies that go unmatched.
To have been shut out of those (and fellowships) would have been far worse.
How is there an abundance of unmatched slots if there's an excess of med students? Do people just walk away from medicine loaded with debt if they don't get their choice of residencies?Because there are an inadequate number of DO residencies to begin with.
The whole system relies on an abundance of MD residencies that go unmatched.
To have been shut out of those (and fellowships) would have been far worse.
How is there an abundance of unmatched slots if there's an excess of med students? Do people just walk away from medicine loaded with debt if they don't get their choice of residencies?
Thats good if you're a md candidate
can you explain that
There is no excess of US medical students (MD or DO). There are thousands of "leftover" residency positions that go to IMG's even now. http://www.nrmp.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/ADT2015_final.pdfHow is there an abundance of unmatched slots if there's an excess of med students? Do people just walk away from medicine loaded with debt if they don't get their choice of residencies?
so it will be even harder for caribs to come here? good news
I would imagine it means DOs would take up many of the residency spots that caribs would otherwise takeso it will be even harder for caribs to come here? good news
I would imagine it means DOs would take up many of the residency spots that caribs would otherwise take
yep, the real question is why the DO programs signed up for the merger when it seems like the result will be a lot more DOs struggling or failing to match
Oh please, here's the Cliff's Notes version: O: trocanter. I: top of the knee.
Now you tell me what happens if a bullet transects it in a 19 year old soldier?
Whether it's system's based or classic Flexner-style, to teach at the med school level you need people who know what they're doing and more importantly, be able to teach in a medical context (as I have asked) and even more importantly, know what they're doing.
Look we get it, you're happy that a med school is opening in your backyard, but really, don't shill for them. You should be looking at this eyes open.
Two veteran medical educators are looking at this and the alarm bells are going off all over the place. CNU won't compete with my school, I don't have a dog in the fight; I'm just appalled.
Their curriculum is systems-based (e.g. renal, cardiovascular, etc.) and courses like "medical school physiology" aren't taught, there. As far as I know, they conduct classes by having professors rotate through on a daily-weekly basis according to their research area.
Most DO students from schools like Touro or Western attempt to get into md residencies rather than DO residencies which are viewed as less prestigious and lead to worse job prospects. Schools like Touro even boast that half their class goes to acgme (have no idea if this is true) residencies so they kind of view do residencies as second rate residencies and want to move DO schools into a kind of parity with allopathic schools by offering equivilant residency and thus trainin
US MD/DO schools (Except CNSU) >>> CNSU >>> Carib
Is this about right based on what I have read in this thread?
eh I would still put CNUCOM above any Osteopathic school in my opinion
I have a question. Have you applied to this school?Are you going to really say a for-profit rushed money grab with severely under-qualified faculty and a clunky confusing contradictory curriculum is better than Osteopathic schools, most of which have very good faculty, positive learning environments, with tried and tried education methods, and great educational outcomes? I understand thinking a MD is better than a DO, but Caribbean schools offer MDs too and if you dropped CNUCOM into the Caribbean you'd probably struggle to tell the difference between it and the rest of the Caribbean.
What's your reasoning? I really wish people would recognize overvaluing the importance of a MD over a DO degree, when both can get you to the same places, and places like CNUCOM are preying off the desperation of applicants such as yourself. If CNUCOM turns out to be great or improves more power to you, but this place is seriously sketch, not very professional, and a total rush job. As nitpicky as it sounds the fact that the site is littered with typos and the faculty and administration I emailed have "California Nortstate Univesity College of Medicine" as their pre-printed signature, shows how little attention to detail they pay. Normally, I'd say this is overly nit-picky, but in the case of CNUCOM it speaks volumes.
I wish I could find a paper on the LCME accreditation, see what the LCME's comments were on this place, because I bet CNUCOM had some seriously professional lobbyists seal the deal.
Are you going to really say a for-profit rushed money grab with severely under-qualified faculty and a clunky confusing contradictory curriculum is better than Osteopathic schools, most of which have very good faculty, positive learning environments, with tried and tried education methods, and great educational outcomes? I understand thinking a MD is better than a DO, but Caribbean schools offer MDs too and if you dropped CNUCOM into the Caribbean you'd probably struggle to tell the difference between it and the rest of the Caribbean.
Many residency directors are disgusted by DO and will pick a US MD graduate over them. Some programs don't even take DO applications. This school has LCME accreditation and is a US MD school. This school is under more stringent requirements than carribean schools. This school will be required to match nearly 100% of the class, unlike carribean schools. Historically, carrib schools match terribly. Historically, new US MD schools match better than any DO school. Can anyone really say that your residency opportunities aren't better at this school than any DO school?I think this thread is over because it's just going around in circles. I know some people will never be convinced, for the same reason Caribbean schools continue to fill their classes. However, residency directors aren't stupid. When you have two adcoms on this site disgusted about this school, it honestly doesn't matter WHAT else CNU has going for it because residency directors will probably have the same feeling. This school isn't going to get a free pass just for being an M.D. Vs D.O. because residency directors aren't stupid. They aren't going to stick their fingers in their ears and chant "M.D. M.D. M.D.!!!" without knowing the deal with this school like some people wish they would.
This whole thread reminds me of:
"But other than that Mrs. Lincoln, how was the play?"
I'd love Goro to chime in on this if possible. As far as I've heard, LCME accreditation is far from easy to obtain and barring this school bribing it's way in it has passed the test. Isn't it also possible they have modifiers to their accreditation task list such as bringing in more faculty and rotate in skilled physicians? I would think (hopefully not naively) that for profit means a larger pool of resources that could be used to recruit some quality professors.
their for profit status is concerning,
Why is for profit status such a concern? Is it because of the recent Corinthian scandal? To establish a new med school from scratch, it takes a lot of $, i.e. private investor $. Yes investors want a return on their $ but otoh one could also see that as an incentive to have the med school flourish long term. A for profit med school might might get very good applicants especially from states like California or New York. And if they shorten the curriculum to be 3 years with no negative effect on Step scores, they'll have applicants banging on their doors. I don't think investors in CNCUM are expecting a huge profit immediately. If it's anything like Rocky Vista "according to Dr. Martin, the school's auditing firm projected that there will be no return on the $100 million investment for the first two to three years. The firm predicts that it will take 17 years to break even." I'm not saying CNCUM will eventually be a great school. But to be hung up on its for profit status seems a bit short-sighted.
Thanks for the explanation.It's not really a secret that across the board for-profit colleges have questionable morals and very little regard for their students. That's why you see most of the student loan default rate being attributed to for profit colleges in this country by a WIDE margin, and why you'll hear about them having call centers dedicated to recruiting former military veterans for their sweet sweet GI bill money (a disgusting and widespread practice). The federal government as recently as a week ago has started cracking down on them big time.
Even among current for profit medical schools, pretty much all of them in the Caribbean screw over a large majority of their matriculants in the quest to put federal loan dollars in their pockets. The few for profit med schools in the U.S. that do exist and do alright by their students, do so out of circumstance I suspect. If the situation changes, and they have to resort to questionable means to keep the dollars flowing, they will. Bottom line is for-profit schools don't really care about the well being of their students, only that the loan money keeps flowing in. That's not a good starting place for any education, let alone a medical education.
It doesn't leave me surprised why the school was forced to recruit international faculty as it seems like some U.S. trained faculty in CA have the problem with this school solely based on its for-profit status.
I don't even think that many people know of CNU outside of California, and will probably see their students as just someone who graduated from an LCME accredited school.
Hi I like your cat.
This school isn't going to get a free pass just for being an M.D. Vs D.O. because residency directors aren't stupid. They aren't going to stick their fingers in their ears and chant "M.D. M.D. M.D.!!!" without knowing the deal with this school like some people wish they would.
I feel like the reasons for concern have been outlined clearly: unprofessionalism (grammar errors galore on website, no response to calls or emails, the decision to fill a class in 3 months, ect), poor faculty (grad students and foreign MD's), lack of federal aid.
The only people who are making the thread circular are those who choose to disregard or try to explain away these glaring issues. Which is fine for you, but most of the community will not agree with you.
Hello fellow Pusheen!I feel like the reasons for concern have been outlined clearly: unprofessionalism (grammar errors galore on website, no response to calls or emails, the decision to fill a class in 3 months, ect), poor faculty (grad students and foreign MD's), lack of federal aid.
The only people who are making the thread circular are those who choose to disregard or try to explain away these glaring issues. Which is fine for you, but most of the community will not agree with you.
Let's be gentle everyone!
I don't think this should turn into a MD vs. DO debate, I'm sure that has been beat to death on SDN already lol.
I think this school provides a very good opportunity for many people. Even if someone chooses this over a DO school, that is, in the end, their decision! There are plenty of valid reasons to do so IMO.
To those who are interested in this school (for various reasons, not limited to MD degree, location, etc.), I think it's important to recognize that the wise SDN members (such as Goro or gyngyn) are merely warning us from things that are actually worth thinking about. Like any new school, this school has risks and it's important to recognize them as such! You don't have to be discouraged by what they say, and definitely don't be offended, but definitely listen. This ability to listen will be important in all of our professional lives one day.
Finally, I think it's also important to recognize that a lot of the success of this school, like many new schools, will be dependent on the students. How motivated are the students to do exceptionally well? The resources will be available, even if they are the minimum required by LCME, but it ultimately comes down to the students to initiate student run programs, and the other things @OutInSacramento spoke of in his/her post. (note- this is just my opinion that students can make a difference in these ways).
Btw, @OutInSacramento I would be interested to hear more about what you learned about practice interest groups and hope you would share! (if you have time outside of writing your paper).
This is something I've been thinking about actually. These loan forgiveness programs is what a lot of places are using to attract PCPs into rural towns (I know of some in Upstate NY), but does loan forgiveness apply to private loans? I was under the assumption is was for federal loans only, but I could be totally wrong, I have to do more research on these types of programs.I even found out about the competitiveness of rural loan repayment programs insofar as how much doing the above has helped students applying for loan forgiveness
This is something I've been thinking about actually. These loan forgiveness programs is what a lot of places are using to attract PCPs into rural towns (I know of some in Upstate NY), but does loan forgiveness apply to private loans? I was under the assumption is was for federal loans only, but I could be totally wrong, I have to do more research on these types of programs.
I'm actually glad to see all the negative comments about this school and post from weary applicants. If you feel so unsure about the ability of this program and their faculty, don't waste anyone's time in applying. I on the other hand feel very positive about this school and have confidence that they will produce competent MD's and I have no shame in saying that I hope to be one of them. So continue to talk down about CNUCOM, but at the end of the day there will be many qualified applicants accepted into this program and will go on to match and practice alongside other US MD graduates. On a brighter note, I hope you all enjoyed your 4th of July weekend.
I'm actually glad to see all the negative comments about this school and post from weary applicants.
I'd certainly describe myself as wearyWary not weary. Unless you mean they are actually tired applicants. Sorry that mistake bothers me a lot.