nobody will argue with the quality of training but there is a lot more to picking a residency program.
Agreed. And, pedigree helps a lot. But, being at another "PA/NJ/DE" area program (and having the ability to occassionally moonlight and work with a large variety of other grads from area programs), I can tell you firsthand that most of the Pennwee's I've worked with have an air about them. That's all I'm going to say. Not always the most laid back of the group.
You see, attendings don't often work with or know the capabilities/practices of the other attendings in their practice. So, when you tell them what "so-and-so" did during another case, they will either look at you quizzically, roll their eyes, and/or chuckle when they hear what their colleagues did. It's great for me because, as a resident, I get to see a variety of different techniques not often taught at my home program. I also get to see how to be truly efficient and do what's "slickest" for a case.
Based on this experience and what I've seen (especially with the newer attendings), I can definitively tell you there are things, for whatever reason, that are not routinely taught in residency... to our detriment. I'm not excluding my program either. We get taught some silly stuff that only gets done in the academic centers, often perhaps with good intentions (e.g. the "academic pace" of some cases as alluded to by dr doze). Point is, some of these practices probably aren't going to help you in the real world. That's the real shame. And, even the puportedly "best" programs are not immune to this phenomenon.
To all residents just remember that you are going to be a consultant. You can probably get by in this field just being an extremely good technician. But, everytime you do a technique or learn something knew, never for get to ask yourself "why" you're doing it that way. Ask your attendings that too. You'll learn when you get to the real world that there are a lot of different ways to climb a tree, and unless you're really clever or get the opportunity to get more experience (like I have) working with different attendings out there, some of whom took years to "unlearn" what they were taught in residency, you may take a lot of time figuring this out. Because, once you're in the real world you'll be on your own. And, no one is going to teach you different and possible slicker ways to do things unless you figure them out on your own. Hell, a lot of the attendings in academia probably couldn't do a case on their own anymore at this point.
So, I personally don't care where you train. This is the way it is. Again, I've seen it firsthand. Quick, efficient, and safe anesthesiologists are the true studs of our profession. And, no, not all of them came from the "best of the best" programs. Keep that in mind as you choose a program and go through your training.
-copro