- Joined
- Jun 24, 2008
- Messages
- 508
- Reaction score
- 83
Anybody ever consider listing parenting as an "extra-curricular activity" on their AMCAS app?
Anybody ever consider listing parenting as an "extra-curricular activity" on their AMCAS app?
Anybody ever consider listing parenting as an "extra-curricular activity" on their AMCAS app?
Puh-lease... can I put down being a wife?
...Side question.... You can technically put down whatever you want, no? Are we asking what would be positively received by the admissions folks?
Of course you can put anything you want. It would certainly not be positively received.
If it is that much of a job for you, sure go right ahead.
...Side question.... You can technically put down whatever you want, no? Are we asking what would be positively received by the admissions folks?
I just said folks
Parents really need to get over themselves.
I spend a lot of time caring for my cats. Maybe I should include that.
Yeah, cats require a great amount of care, I would most definitely explain that in detail in throughout your application.
I don't think any parent here needs to "get over themselves," and I don't see how on Earth this thread could have offended you. But maybe that's because I'm not a cat person...
Chillax.
Your comment to include "wife" as an EC if it's "that much of a job" for me implied that parenting is such a large and important job that it should be included. Maybe that's not what you meant. But as someone else said, it's just life. It's not more important or better experience than what anyone else is doing, and most people do not include life as an EC. I mean, should someone include maintaining a household budget, maintaining a home, keeping pets alive, running errands, and all the rest? No... so probably parenting is also not something to be included.
Sorry, I admit to being touchy, as I know a few people who have recently been spreading their beliefs that you're not a "real" adult until you're a parent... so where does that leave people with fertility issues?
I completely agree.
And trust me, as a parent at 16, I have been called every name in the book and people still don't see me as a real "adult," so I get the parent = adult dilemma... As for my comment about it being a job, I was simply making a joke at what I though was a joke.. u were serious and for that mistake I apologize.
Oh no, my comment about including "wife" was a joke... I thought your response was a sarcastic comment, implying that parenthood is a huge job, wife isn't, but if it's that much of a job to me, go right ahead and include it... basically I thought you were scoffing at the idea of including "wife" which cannot possibly be the amount of work "parent" is... so basically, I thought you were making a serious but sarcastic comment to my joking comment. That's why I responded to it the way I did.
(For the record, I think "parent" is more of a job than "wife" but I think they're all just life so not something for an application.)
Even my religious life was changed by children. "Dear heavenly father, bless us this... (where are the children, what is that sound)...day and guide us ("Get down from there") in our endeavors ("Stop hitting your brother") so that we may bring glory ("Don't put that in your mouth") to your name, ("DON'T EAT YOUR BOOGERS") and make us be truly thankful. Amen.
Oh how I wish...Anybody ever consider listing parenting as an "extra-curricular activity" on their AMCAS app?
Parents really need to get over themselves.
I spend a lot of time caring for my cats. Maybe I should include that.
May I offer a loan of 2 or 3 (or make than half a dozen) kids for a few days and see if you still think it is easy Oh, and they have to survive the experience!
Anyone with the proper biological equipment can be a parent.
True, but being a parent is not the same as "parenting". (Note the wording I used in my original query.)
For the record, I did NOT list parenting on my own AMCAS application, precisely because I worried that an adcomm would respond just as negatively as many of you have here. That said, I think it SHOULD BE considered a valid activity. Extra-curricular to me means "beyond the school curriuculum," which is where we list many non-class activities... i.e. sports, clubs, volunteering, leadership, etc. Certainly, active parenting (not simply being a biological parent) takes up a large amount of time and energy and requires a tremendous amount of responsibility.
I know many people have listed serving as full-time care-givers for ill parents, etc. How is being the full-time parent for young people (i.e. one's children), and acting as the advocate in all aspects of their lives really any less important or worthy of mention on an application?
True, but being a parent is not the same as "parenting". (Note the wording I used in my original query.)
No, you are correct. It isn't. Have you, personally, ever met anyone who said they were a bad parent? Since parenting is ubiquitous, how, exactly, would bragging about your parenting skills make you a more attractive candidate. This is what the application is about. It is not about patting yourself on your back.
Finally, since very, very few (I'm the only one I know) parents who are applying to medical schools have actually completed raising their children, why are they so confident that they are doing a good job? My wife and I are less self-complementary about our parenting skills than we were 5 years ago.
Have you seen the show Teen Mom? They are broadcasting to the world what terrible parents they are.
And just because my daughter is three years old, I know I'm doing a good job. How? She's socially adjusted, well past every developmental milestone for her age group, is overall happy and extremely healthy. I'm 100% confident that there is nothing I could do "better", I'm sure in some opinions I should stay home with her until she's in college, but there is no outcome to that situation which would be better for my daughter than my pursuing a career that shows her the importance of working hard, helping others, and educating oneself. I hope you can agree that you do not become a good parent when your child grows up but throughout the journey.
I'm confident that you believe that you are a good parent, and you have a good chance of being right. But you could also be a disastrous parent. There is no way to tell from the short blurb in a application. All that the adcom can tell from your short blurb on an application is that your reproductive organs were once in working order.... No, they really can't tell that because you could have adopted. So all that the adcom can tell is that a child lives with you.... No, they really can't tell that, because you could be a non-custodial parent. All that they can tell is that you have a relationship with a young human that you consider parental in nature. This reveals nothing about what kind of student or doctor that you will be.
You question is whether parenting should be included as an EC on the application. Universally you have been told that your application will be laughed at if you do this. I have given you the reason why it's laughable.
You have been responding by telling us what a great parent you are. So what?
And, BTW, if your child is only 3, then you have a lot more parenting in front of you than behind you. So far, you have done just the easy part. I'm glad that you have such a superior rocking chair technique, but talk to us again after you have figured out the proper technique for helping with homework or guiding them in their social relationships without being controlling.
Finally, since very, very few (I'm the only one I know) parents who are applying to medical schools have actually completed raising their children, why are they so confident that they are doing a good job? My wife and I are less self-complementary about our parenting skills than we were 5 years ago.
And, BTW, if your child is only 3, then you have a lot more parenting in front of you than behind you. So far, you have done just the easy part. I'm glad that you have such a superior rocking chair technique, but talk to us again after you have figured out the proper technique for helping with homework or guiding them in their social relationships without being controlling.
Anybody ever consider listing parenting as an "extra-curricular activity" on their AMCAS app?
I understand the "parents need to get over themselves" comment. I feel the same way when I hear people preening about their children. However, I think that childless people don't understand the way that children own your life and occupy your mind.
Even my religious life was changed by children. "Dear heavenly father, bless us this... (where are the children, what is that sound)...day and guide us ("Get down from there") in our endeavors ("Stop hitting your brother") so that we may bring glory ("Don't put that in your mouth") to your name, ("DON'T EAT YOUR BOOGERS") and make us be truly thankful. Amen.
But these experiences are core - not extra - curricular activities. Your self-judged experiences as a parent are not interesting to other people - although your children's characters after they grow up might be revealing.
This was 1) Not my question, as I did not, and would never include such a thing on an application to graduate school, and 2) I not my point in the post that you are so arrogantly responding to.
There is no point providing a real response to your comments, as a person of your grandeur would never listen to someone like me.
You may have successfully raised your children, and you may have been parent of the year, my point is that you can be a good parent regardless of how old your children are.
a little arrogant dont you think? to call someone's competent parenting skills up to the preschool years simply just "rocking chair technique?" the point is the FOUNDATION. from the moment your child is born, your parenting is setting the foundation for their later years..
Anybody ever consider listing parenting as an "extra-curricular activity" on their AMCAS app?
To extend this question a bit, how do you list/deal with organized activities around your children?
Under the concept that an EC should help show a pattern of commitment, motivation, and achievement, I would assume that if you are active in the PTA, teach dance or yoga as a volunteer for preschoolers, or are a cub scout den parent, that would be a be a positive and worth while to list? While it needs to be balanced with what else you may have in the way of EC's, most parents I am sure have limited time.
What is the thread's thoughts on this?
For me, I had a high level of anxiety about not having "stuff" on my application to show for my years beyond school. That is, I didn't live my life with AMCAS in mind and, to make matters worse, I had little concrete evidence of what little I had done. I doubt any of us do.
The value of being of a nontrad in a serious relationship or being a parent can not be overstated in your application - but it shouldn't be included as an EC.
I was worried about this too. Especially reading the dumb SDN threads with people asking which of the 46 ECs they should include in their 15 EC limit on AMCAS.
VC says it best: Value? absolutely. Include on app? No way.
This is why there are interviews. Weave it into a story.
Somewhat related, and I wasn't sure where to ask about this...
Can I put babysitting and tutoring as an EC? Or do I list that as a job on the apps since I was getting paid? Thanks!
Edit:
Also where would I list helping out family, for example sister-in-laws children? should i even bother listing something like helping family (which obviously I was not getting paid for)?