Now that everything is all said and done I can post my stats. They're pretty humble compared to what other people have posted here, but they did the job...
(1st time applicant)
Age: 22
Undergraduate Institution: Northwestern University
Major: chemistry
Minor: environmental policy and culture
GPA: 3.50
Science GPA: ~3.4
Last 45 hour GPA: 3.50
GRE: 800Q 660V 5.0A
Vet/Animal Experience:
100 shelter
200 pet shop (don't remind me)
250 SA hospital (my only real vet experience)
400 zoo (husbandry, large african mammals)
800 research (independent, with cat, dog, and sheep ovaries, writing a thesis)
Other Medical Experience:
400 coroner
400 medical examiner intern
Extracurriculars:
Peer teacher (which led into senior peer teacher and then managing the whole program, which was a paid job)
Martial Arts instructor
Some other minor stuff
Recommendations:
1) SA vet that I worked with
2) Lead zookeeper
3) Research PI (also one of my bio pre-req professors)
Applied: Penn, Tufts, Illinois, CSU
Accepted: Penn, Tufts, Illinois
Rejected: CSU
Final Decision: Penn
What I think helped my application:
(reasoning in parentheses)
1) GRE (confirmed by Penn admissions staff)
2) Research experience (In the interviews I was asked extensively about my research more than anything else)
3) I think my essays were really good (confirmed by Tufts interviewer)
4) I interview well (notice the school that rejected me doesn't interview)
5) I have some human med experience to compare my vet med experience to and say for sure that I wanted vet med over human med (I was asked a surprising amount of questions about my medical examiner experience)
6) Quality of my undergraduate institution (confirmed by Penn admissions staff)
7) Chemistry is apparently a hard major (confirmed by Penn admissions staff)
What I think hurt my application:
(These were confirmed by CSU admissions staff)
1) GPA was a little low, and I got a C in quantum
2) Could have used more SA experience hours