- Joined
- Mar 20, 2016
- Messages
- 587
- Reaction score
- 1,102
Congratulations everyone.
Hope some of you nerds matched at my program.
Hope some of you nerds matched at my program.
Matched at my number 8, would have been happy anywhere above that but feel miserable now. Was told I was extremely competitive the entire time and would likely match to my number 1. I'm convinced no one knows anything and just spouts random BS. I feel sick. Might not accept my position. Have been feeling conflicted about medicine and residency for a while now and maybe this seals it. Happy for you guys who matched where you wanted to go and grateful for those of you who still want to practice medicine. I'm just not sure if its for me.
Happens unfortunately. Make the best of it, you may be surprised how much you like your program.I matched at my 11th out of 13 program. I think I must have been in a similar situation with a late, negative SLOE. Top 25% of my class, board scores in the 250s, waitlisted for interviews at prestigious programs like Highland and UCLA-Harbor. Would have been thrilled to match anywhere in my top 5, and simply was not prepared to match so low. I’m devastated, but also just very confused as to how this happened. There was no hint from anywhere that I had any red flags in my application until today
Because, year after year, students with little to no real world experience make decisions that they deem best, despite there being literal hundreds or thousands of us that have gone through it (even last year), and freely give their advice, most of which is "do not rank a place you don't want to go". Now, this "throwaway" account has a person that states they might not take it. I wonder what was the med school that this person attended. I certainly didn't take a class in med school that educated me on being massively shortsighted. As far as bad decisions go, this one has 8 years behind it, and zero years ahead of it, if this person does this.While I understand your disappointment, why did you even rank somewhere you didn't want to go? If you preferred going unmatched (ie not taking the spot you got) to matching there, why rank it?
Because, year after year, students with little to no real world experience make decisions that they deem best, despite there being literal hundreds or thousands of us that have gone through it (even last year), and freely give their advice, most of which is "do not rank a place you don't want to go". Now, this "throwaway" account has a person that states they might not take it. I wonder what was the med school that this person attended. I certainly didn't take a class in med school that educated me on being massively shortsighted. As far as bad decisions go, this one has 8 years behind it, and zero years ahead of it, if this person does this.
I matched at my #6. One even told me I would match wherever I wanted, them included. Just wasn't expecting this at all. Bad location, reputation is okay. 3 years of hell.
It’s easy to say it will get better in residency, get better after intern year, get better when you’re an attending, etc.
Because, year after year, students with little to no real world experience make decisions that they deem best, despite there being literal hundreds or thousands of us that have gone through it (even last year), and freely give their advice, most of which is "do not rank a place you don't want to go". Now, this "throwaway" account has a person that states they might not take it. I wonder what was the med school that this person attended. I certainly didn't take a class in med school that educated me on being massively shortsighted. As far as bad decisions go, this one has 8 years behind it, and zero years ahead of it, if this person does this.
Because the world is a different place from even a few years ago. You can deny all you want, but every year the match is harder than the year before. Depending on when you started your residency journey, it could have been as simple as just applying and walking through the door.
You know where the people from my class who followed the "do not rank a place you wouldn't want to go" are? They ended up in the SOAP. If you're applying to residency, you need to take every interview you can afford and rank every place you interview. It's very simple.
Once residency starts your mental health is almost certainly going to take a hit. It's hard for everyone, more so for people who deal with the added burden of mental illness. Take the remainder of 4th year to get a solid plan for your depression because once July 1 hits, your ability to make adjustments is going to be much more limited.I just think the “don’t rank if you don’t want to go” is easier said than done. I definitely didn’t want to go there, but would it be worse than not matching? I don’t know, it’s a hard decision to make. I have been struggling with depression since my first AI and have been trying not to make permanent decisions based on this mental state. But at what point am I depressed because I don’t want to do what I’m doing and at what point do I not enjoy what I’m doing because I’m depressed? I’ve been trying to figure it out (seeing a therapist) but it’s no light switch and deadlines and match day keep coming. It’s easy to say it will get better in residency, get better after intern year, get better when you’re an attending, etc. Which is why I’ve just kept moving forward. It’s certainly true for some people that it gets better, but personally I’ve been saying that with each AI, BS 4th year rotations, and match day so when match day wasn’t what I hoped it hit extra hard. Not trying to make excuses, I hate that I might take a spot from someone else, and I understand it could get better/could work out for the best (I’m definitely a big believer in this) but it’s a hard call to make at what point do I prioritize my own day to day happiness? For some people that might be doing something else and maybe I’m one of them. Sure would hate to waste more time being miserable. The pressure of “if you don’t go or leave or take a break you are screwed forever” doesn’t help but I understand with the competition. I do appreciate all the honest feedback and just letting me express my thoughts by all those on here.
The programs didn't fill are:
1) Palm Beach Florida (4/6)
2) Genesys Reg (5/7)
3) Henry Ford Allegiance Health (5/8)
4) Henry Ford Macomb (7/8) - btw, they sent out the 'highly unlikely" to match emails
5) McLaren Health Malcom (2/6)
6) McLaren Health Oakland (5/6)
7) Rowan University (7/11)
8) SUNY Upstate Syracuse (9/11)
9) Adena Health (2/6)
10) Memorial Health (4/6)
11) St. Elizabeth Boardman (6/7)
12) Aria Jefferson Health (3/4)
13) Lincoln Med military spot (0/1)
The programs didn't fill are:
1) Palm Beach Florida (4/6)
2) Genesys Reg (5/7)
3) Henry Ford Allegiance Health (5/8)
4) Henry Ford Macomb (7/8) - btw, they sent out the 'highly unlikely" to match emails
5) McLaren Health Malcom (2/6)
6) McLaren Health Oakland (5/6)
7) Rowan University (7/11)
8) SUNY Upstate Syracuse (9/11)
9) Adena Health (2/6)
10) Memorial Health (4/6)
11) St. Elizabeth Boardman (6/7)
12) Aria Jefferson Health (3/4)
13) Lincoln Med military spot (0/1)
I did feel some disadvantage, since reapplicants seem to be frowned upon. EM programs that have either taken TY's, attached to TRI's, or had had one at the institution previously seemed to be ok with me. Realistically, you can go on 4-5. I had 2 outside, 1 at my home program and 1 at ACOEP. My TY holds 5 vacation days in reserve for us for interview, plus I was able to work my schedule around interview season. Also, programs that get accredited in January may do phone interviews (they did this year), that could increase your interview numbers
The programs didn't fill are:
1) Palm Beach Florida (4/6)
2) Genesys Reg (5/7)
3) Henry Ford Allegiance Health (5/8)
4) Henry Ford Macomb (7/8) - btw, they sent out the 'highly unlikely" to match emails
5) McLaren Health Malcom (2/6)
6) McLaren Health Oakland (5/6)
7) Rowan University (7/11)
8) SUNY Upstate Syracuse (9/11)
9) Adena Health (2/6)
10) Memorial Health (4/6)
11) St. Elizabeth Boardman (6/7)
12) Aria Jefferson Health (3/4)
13) Lincoln Med military spot (0/1)
I don't know what to make of this: exactly one of those programs (SUNY-Upstate) was, prior to this match, an MD program, only. Every other one was, prior, a DO program.
As I say, I do not know what to make of this. (And, likewise, I am not sure of the grammar of the prior sentence.)
Edit: Well, I forgot - Lincoln is an MD program, too, but, as stated, it was a military spot, anyhow.
So many Michigan programs. Is that typical?
My friend is at a surgery pgy1 (not a prelim) wanting to transfer into EM. Have these places filled yet? How would he go about contacting these programs to fill their spots?
I did an away in Detroit and as soon as I had enough interviews I cancelled all my Michigan offers. No idea why anyone would ever want to live there. Not surprising. Also I'm pretty sure a couple of these places SOAP all the time.
The programs didn't fill are:
1) Palm Beach Florida (4/6)
2) Genesys Reg (5/7)
3) Henry Ford Allegiance Health (5/8)
4) Henry Ford Macomb (7/8) - btw, they sent out the 'highly unlikely" to match emails
5) McLaren Health Malcom (2/6)
6) McLaren Health Oakland (5/6)
7) Rowan University (7/11)
8) SUNY Upstate Syracuse (9/11)
9) Adena Health (2/6)
10) Memorial Health (4/6)
11) St. Elizabeth Boardman (6/7)
12) Aria Jefferson Health (3/4)
13) Lincoln Med military spot (0/1)
To be quite blunt, you want to train in really poor areas, because, unfortunately, the poor have worse problems, or let the natural course of disease progress further before presentation for help. Subsequently, there are better opportunities for trainees to do procedures, and perform more complex management. And, because one is a trainee, they are time-limited. There is a finite opportunity, and, then, when time is up, the person can "get out of Dodge on the first train".I trained there, but it was far from my first choice. And I left as soon as I could.
Matched IM. My application was ruined because of a SLOE that ended up being a red flag on my application, despite being a good candidate. I did not know of this until November. Oh well, life happens :/This happened to me. I matched but I applied to IM as a backup and now I am really dreading the possibility on ending up in IM
Once residency starts your mental health is almost certainly going to take a hit. It's hard for everyone, more so for people who deal with the added burden of mental illness. Take the remainder of 4th year to get a solid plan for your depression because once July 1 hits, your ability to make adjustments is going to be much more limited.
It'll tell you each program whether they fill up or not
I didn't see this document on the NRMP website--was it released somewhere else?
Honestly can anyone here comment on how bad this hit is going to be? I'm starting to get scared of how residency is going to fair. Granted I'm going to a 3 year program, 20 mins from home, with lots of friends nearby. But whats the best way to prepare for this? I don't have any active issues, but I know multiple people who looked like they had the life sucked out of them at times during their training. Don't want to experience that, and if its inevitable - would like to tackle it head on before it hits.
Honestly can anyone here comment on how bad this hit is going to be? I'm starting to get scared of how residency is going to fair. Granted I'm going to a 3 year program, 20 mins from home, with lots of friends nearby. But whats the best way to prepare for this? I don't have any active issues, but I know multiple people who looked like they had the life sucked out of them at times during their training. Don't want to experience that, and if its inevitable - would like to tackle it head on before it hits.
Honestly can anyone here comment on how bad this hit is going to be? I'm starting to get scared of how residency is going to fair. Granted I'm going to a 3 year program, 20 mins from home, with lots of friends nearby. But whats the best way to prepare for this? I don't have any active issues, but I know multiple people who looked like they had the life sucked out of them at times during their training. Don't want to experience that, and if its inevitable - would like to tackle it head on before it hits.
As @gamerEMdoc and @alpinism have said residency is certainly more rewarding than med school. Your knowledge base and decision-making ability expand incredibly quickly. In the first 12 months you will run resuscitations, manage airways -- basically start to be the physician you want to be.You will go through periods of self doubt and insecurity, especially as your learning procedures and trying to get better and faster at medicine. You will take some abuse from consultants, nurses, and attendings. You will be paid less than a first year nurse or a first year midlevel who have almost no education or training compared to you. You will have shift work sleep dysphoria. You will miss holidays and social events.
As @gamerEMdoc and @alpinism have said residency is certainly more rewarding than med school. Your knowledge base and decision-making ability expand incredibly quickly. In the first 12 months you will run resuscitations, manage airways -- basically start to be the physician you want to be.
My comment was meant to encourage soon to be interns to identify and potentially build their support structures. For those with anxiety or depression most programs will have some sort of anonymous, and free, counseling service. Identify these outlets early and use them. Fortunately you have a built in system with your future classmates, co-residents, and faculty. The competition of med school is over. You will have unique strengths that can serve to buoy your co-interns, and weaknesses that will benefit from their help. Obviously having nearby family and friends is a bonus, but as you may have already recognized, non-medical folks may have a hard time relating to the challenges you face.
I know third year residents who arguably struggle juggling 6 patients at a time. Some people are just faster than others. You will get faster as you see more and don’t have to spend time thinking about what you need to order, when you can admit someone, etc. Mentally dispoing someone in your mind is a huge mental offload and allows you to focus on the rest of your board.Any advice on how to get faster at seeing patients? I feel really slow and struggle to juggle even 5-6 patients while keeping up with documentation. Meanwhile attending a are carrying 15-20 patients at a time sometimes! How?!?!
Matched at my number 8, would have been happy anywhere above that but feel miserable now. Was told I was extremely competitive the entire time and would likely match to my number 1. I'm convinced no one knows anything and just spouts random BS. I feel sick. Might not accept my position. Have been feeling conflicted about medicine and residency for a while now and maybe this seals it. Happy for you guys who matched where you wanted to go and grateful for those of you who still want to practice medicine. I'm just not sure if its for me.
Man I went down to my #6 and was also super depressed on match day. So I get the feeling. All I can say is it worked out for me.
I matched at my 11th out of 13 program. I think I must have been in a similar situation with a late, negative SLOE. Top 25% of my class, board scores in the 250s, waitlisted for interviews at prestigious programs like Highland and UCLA-Harbor. My first 2 SLoEs were top 1/3. Would have been thrilled to match anywhere in my top 5, and simply was not prepared to match so low. I’m devastated, but also just very confused as to how this happened. There was no hint from anywhere that I had any red flags in my application until today
I matched at my #6. One even told me I would match wherever I wanted, them included. Just wasn't expecting this at all. Bad location, reputation is okay. 3 years of hell.
How are all of you THIS upset and ungrateful about matching? I'll trade places with any of you in a heartbeat after not matching 7 days ago despite 12 interviews.
Any location. Any program. Let's set up the trade for my TRI year. Tonight.
How are all of you THIS upset and ungrateful about matching? I'll trade places with any of you in a heartbeat after not matching 7 days ago despite 12 interviews.
Any location. Any program. Let's set up the trade for my TRI year. Tonight.
That's because the sloe is a ****ing piece of subjective **** as you have just demonstrated.
You are 100% right. My partner and I were excited to move closer to my family and friends and get a fresh start for her away from her alcoholic mother; now we are literally on the other side of the country than we were expecting. I had a very strong application and apparently got burned by a late, bad SLOE that nobody bothered to tell me about. It stung a lot and still does. Mostly, it was the shock at falling so far down my list after being repeatedly told I was an outstanding candidate that made me disappointed.
But it's only taken 3 days for me to feel much better and realize that I'm still lucky to end up where I am. One of my oldest and closest friends also did not match and I am heartbroken for him. I know we'll probably never cross paths (and if we do, I'll never know) but if we do I'd be proud to call you a colleague. Best wishes in your career and I'm rooting for you in next year's match.
For me it was literally 20 years ago. I was upset at the time cuz I thought I was hot **** and would get a great spot wherever I wanted. I was also 23 and didn’t know crap about life at that point. EM was also vastly less competitive then, that cannot be overstated. I was just trying to provide some comfort/perspective to those who weren’t thrilled with their match outcome.
Things worked out fine for me. I had great training. You are 100% right that things could’ve been worse for me and the others you quoted.
I have been rooting for cajun and smurfette all year and was thrilled for them with their match. I will now be rooting for you. I think you are going to crush it.
You graduated med school at 23? Started at 19? Did you go to college? Are you 1 out of 2million brilliant?I was also 23 and didn’t know crap about life at that point.
You graduated med school at 23? Started at 19? Did you go to college? Are you 1 out of 2million brilliant?
I am applying next year. Will I be able to apply to EM without a single SLOE, being that I have 2 auditions scheduled in July & August to be from places rumored to send in SLOEs in the timeline which you describe? If that's the case I'll only have 1 non-EM letter of rec from a 3rd year rotation by the Sept application deadline.Correct. The majority of programs write "group SLOEs" and decide as a group how all the students rank against eachother. Generally that process means waiting until either the beginning of Sept or beginning of October, and comparing all the students thus far as one big group, then writing all the SLOEs after that.