I see what your saying, some brands of AICD don't reactivate automatically when you take the magnet off though so I would feel more comfortable proceeding with pads in place
The other caveat to magnet use is they will NOT put an AICD's pacing function in asynchronous mode. If that's important, the only option is reprogramming.
More broadly speaking, unpredictable behavior with magnets is - I am assured by device reps, though always off the record
- essentially a thing of the past. While St Jude and Boston Scientific devices have the capability of being programmed to ignore a magnet, there's really no reason to do so and their device reps say (quietly) it's totally safe to just assume the device will revert to its prior state when a magnet is removed. Medtronic devices don't have the magnet-off capability. The really old devices that had persistent on/off switches controlled by a magnet don't exist any more, those patients are long dead and if they're not the devices are long since replaced by now.
Anyway - AICD management is easy, even at 2 AM for an urgent case. Call the company and ask what the magnet does. Then use a magnet. Place pads if you like ... but honestly, you can probably deliver a faster shock just by grabbing the magnet and letting the device do it. Postop: monitored bed, the device can get interrogated later before leaving telemetry. Easy.
The only hitch to that is that if they're pacer dependent, and it's an AICD, and the surgical site is close to the device, it should be reprogrammed to therapy off + asynchronous pacing for the duration of surgery.
To answer the original question (AICD, not pacer dependent, normal EF, surgicenter, electrocautery isn't a factor), I'd just do the case and leave the device alone IF (per the guidelines) the device had been interrogated within the previous 12 months (pacer) or 6 months (AICD). If not, it gets interrogated first, then the case gets done like any other. Postop, no interrogation necessary.