Anyone Else want to go into Family Practice?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

ocean11

Senior Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2002
Messages
1,322
Reaction score
6
Hello all....... I'm seriously thinking of going into family practice, but many of my friends who are in meds/going next year don't want to do it because its not 'as profitable' as other specialities.

I feel that one should go into medicine to help others, not for financial gain.... but anyhow.....

...... out of curiosity... anyone else here thinking of pursuing family practice?
 
im a people person so I'm definately considering it. I also had a great experience with a family doctor when all my other doctors couldn't give a rat's ass...that's what's missing from medicine, compassion and caring...doctors focus too much on treating the illness and not the patient...i understand not wanting to get emotionally attached but a smile and a few words of encouragement can go far when people hear dreaded words.

so for me, i'm considering FP, ER, and nephrology. My cousin is a fellow at Mayo for nephrology and it seems fascinating. I had never even heard of it but now it seems very interesting.
 
awfully scary that hilikus posted as her three considerations fp, er, and nephrology. i am thinking of the exact 3, though i heard about nephrology after spending some time this summer with my grandmother who is on dialysis.
 
Hey ocean11... I am definitely considering FP, as I want to go into primary care. I am also considering Med/Peds as an option as well. If I were to specialize, I would keep it pretty close and go into ER since people in many underserved populations use the ED as their primary point of health care. At the same time, it is important to be realistic and understand that you have to be aware of how you will survive financially. Unless your finances are tight and you are graduating without debt (which is a fabulous thought), you're going to have to be able to live. You want to be happy serving your population of interest, but at the same time, you need to remain happy and healthy (which will indeed entail some degree of financial security).
 
Originally posted by CliffC911
awfully scary that hilikus posted as her three considerations fp, er, and nephrology. i am thinking of the exact 3, though i heard about nephrology after spending some time this summer with my grandmother who is on dialysis.

im a dude, man...hehe

anyway, yeah those seem to be the three that interest me the most...
 
I am planning on it, but to be honest, have had concerns. What if half way through residency, I get an interest in a IM subspecialty? I've also heard that it can be harder to get on as an attending with FP. Who knows; I'm not going to worry until 3rd year.
 
I'm a hardcore FP wannabe. I will accept nothing less or more. I've shadowed several family physicians and would not want to do anything different.
 
it's kind of bass-ackwards that a family practice physician can take care of 85% of the medical and surgical [stitches and such] problems out there but they don't get paid for $HIT. i'm more of a interventional cards guy myself.
 
There is a tremendous amount of overlap between outpatient FP and IM in most non-rural communities. What I like about IM is that you don't use part of your training dealing with obgyn and very small children.

I plan to practice in a fairly small community, but unless you plan to practice in literally the middle of nowhere, I wouldn't plan on doing any obstetrics as an FP. In a recent interview one attending told me that the real shortage in many small to medium size underserved communities is not the lack of primary care physicians(IM, FP, peds, obgyn), but the lack of IM subspecialists. Having trained in IM there would be more time to get exposure to cardiology and GI cases which would later prove beneficial if there weren't abundant referral sources.

And of course there is always the option of doing a fellowship later if I changed my mind.
 
FP has got to be the most boring clinical field for doctors. Oh little Tommy has a rash from poison ivy? Here, put on some cream and don't scratch. Repeat this like 20 times a day. 🙄
 
Originally posted by holden73
FP has got to be the most boring clinical field for doctors. Oh little Tommy has a rash from poison ivy? Here, put on some cream and don't scratch. Repeat this like 20 times a day. 🙄

It's only a matter of time before they're replaced by nurse practitioners anyway. It's a waste to pay a physician's salary to someone doing a job that a well trained chimp can carry out. It's only a matter of time before the HMO's get wise to it in all regions.
 
Originally posted by Squat n Squeeze
It's only a matter of time before they're replaced by nurse practitioners anyway. It's a waste to pay a physician's salary to someone doing a job that a well trained chimp can carry out. It's only a matter of time before the HMO's get wise to it in all regions.
indeed
 
Don't you people want to at least start school before deciding on a career path? Chances are, your views will change

Mine are simple: no IM or any of its derivatives👍
 
Family docs are a dying breed in urban centers because of the significant overlap among family practice and three other specialties--general internal medicine, ob/gyn, and pediatrics. Some people (including my friend who is a resident at Duke) claim that FP's lack adequate training to compete against specialists in the other primary care fields. Internists are more qualified than FP's to treat illnesses pertinent to internal medicine; likewise, a gynecologist/obstetrician receives superior training in the areas of female health and delivery of babies; and, of course, pediatricians receive more thorough training in children's health. These disparities in training between FP and other primary care specialties are incontrovertible; since FP's have to be able to do everything (surgery, obstetrics, etc.) their training during residency lacks depth.

Thus, if you're planning to start a career as a family doc, your best bet is to practice in a rural setting. In small towns, the sheer variety that is often touted as a big plus of family practice is a reality; small town FP's perform surgery, deliver babies, treat all age groups, etc. However, given the hyperlitigious atmosphere of America today, I would seriously reconsider your career aspirations, should you want to become an FP in an urban center. "Variety" for an urban FP is a lawsuit waiting to happen, unless, of course, the FP is an extraordinarily gifted physician (they do exist).
 
family practice is pretty flexible --

u can bank in family practice if u have ur own clinic and large number of loyal patients. Also, if ur not happy w ur financial situatuon, family doctors can moonlight as ER docs on teh weekends or whenever, and make 5 Gs a weekend, so what im trying to say is that u can bank as any doctor, and u can do as much as u want and make ur job as fun as u want.

Family doctors can do ER, obgyn, and other things to if they are not satisfied on just family practice.

there is huge overlap in medicine, for example:
psychiatrists, anesthesiologists, neurologists and rehab docs can all go into pain management. so im sure family docs can do similar types of things (not pain) but things associated w primary care.

peace



Omar
 
Originally posted by omarsaleh66
Family doctors can do ER, obgyn, and other things to if they are not satisfied on just family practice.

Yep - case in point: my brother is finishing up his residency this year in FP and scouting job offers... we live in a pretty rural area, and the hospitals around here all staff their ERs with FP guys full-time.
 
Originally posted by manna
Yep - case in point: my brother is finishing up his residency this year in FP and scouting job offers... we live in a pretty rural area, and the hospitals around here all staff their ERs with FP guys full-time.

But EM residency programs are graduating more and more attendings. Over the next ten years, the % of shifts worked by FP's in ED's(even community eD's) will continue to decrease.
 
Originally posted by omarsaleh66
Family doctors can do ER, obgyn, and other things to if they are not satisfied on just family practice.

But could you just get up and say, join a peds or OBGYN practice? I know that once you are liscensed, you can do whatever you want (legally), but could you bill insurance/medicare in these specialties?
 
Originally posted by meanderson
But EM residency programs are graduating more and more attendings. Over the next ten years, the % of shifts worked by FP's in ED's(even community eD's) will continue to decrease.

Perhaps - but these ERs are saying to begin with that they don't want the EM guys, they are specifically recruiting FPs. So it's not a shortage issue. 🙂
 
Why would a hospital want to staff ED's with less qualified people? Just because the FP's will work for less?
 
Originally posted by Supadupafly
But could you just get up and say, join a peds or OBGYN practice? I know that once you are liscensed, you can do whatever you want (legally), but could you bill insurance/medicare in these specialties?

It does get a bit scary when you think that one of the neurosurgeons couldn't pass his boards..
 
Originally posted by meanderson
Why would a hospital want to staff ED's with less qualified people? Just because the FP's will work for less?

Nah, they're still offering VERY handsome salaries. I think it probably has to do with that this is a rural area and they're small ERs - any big trauma gets shifted off to a specialist or flighted out - they see lots of the ER abuser types, those who come in with a cold and no health insurance because they can't be refused treatment.
 
Top