Back to Breadsticks WW - Sign Ups & Game Thread

[Animal Midwife]

---

Members do not see this ad.

I was not thinking spew villager, just slight village lean because it could have been sun trying to start painting Kras as either suspicious or starting the scaffolding that Kras might just be to difficult to deal with and might be more helpful to the village to just remove before Kras mixes in more chaos. Just a hunch though

Well, I don't disagree with the assessment because I also have no read on her despite everything I combed through from yesterday. Seems more NAI to me atm but thanks for clarifying.

 

[alleycat03]

Remember this is a basics game. That means minimal mechanics/PRs.

Valid point. I was mainly joking because Sunny was very clear about her hatred of pumpernickel, and then Alissa/pumpernickel ended up dead and Sunny was revealed to be a wolf.

I’m kinda confused on how a basics game even has a vigilante? Is that not considered a 3P or PR? Based on Genny’s role last game, she was a vig villager, but I thought a basics game would be more simplified than that.

 

[PhiloslothicalStudent]

Valid point. I was mainly joking because Sunny was very clear about her hatred of pumpernickel, and then Alissa/pumpernickel ended up dead and Sunny was revealed to be a wolf.

I’m kinda confused on how a basics game even has a vigilante? Is that not considered a 3P or PR? Based on Genny’s role last game, she was a vig villager, but I thought a basics game would be more simplified than that.

I was wondering this as well. I didn’t think a basics game would have a vig

 

[Animal Midwife]

Valid point. I was mainly joking because Sunny was very clear about her hatred of pumpernickel, and then Alissa/pumpernickel ended up dead and Sunny was revealed to be a wolf.

I’m kinda confused on how a basics game even has a vigilante? Is that not considered a 3P or PR? Based on Genny’s role last game, she was a vig villager, but I thought a basics game would be more simplified than that.

A vig is a PR and dubz already confirmed there are no 3p in this game. I mean minimal rather than none (otherwise it'd fall into mountainous). Vigs are a very simple role that only requires the basic strategy of analyzing the thread. Something complex would be like night cancel, item making, or converter.

 

[SportPonies]

Oof I can’t decide if I’m offended or not that sourdough was a wolf

sourdough is best bread. But I also made my favorite horses the wolves in HoWWrses, so maybe I’m a hypocrite

 

[alleycat03]

What is JOAT? I checked the terminology list and couldn’t find it.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Unofficial D2 Tally
Sporty () -
Cray (1) - AM

1/12
yeet close in ~8 hours

 

[The_Breadmann]

I am kind of suspicious of Cray and Visc because they were both drawing attention to Sloth for being flat and wolfy before sloth really made any content posts besides wanting to hear from people or inquiring about votes.

 

[The_Breadmann]

Oof I can’t decide if I’m offended or not that sourdough was a wolf

sourdough is best bread. But I also made my favorite horses the wolves in HoWWrses, so maybe I’m a hypocrite

Wrong, I am the best Bread

 

[Animal Midwife]

What is JOAT? I checked the terminology list and couldn’t find it.

Jack Of All Trades. It means she had multiple abilities. Typically, each ability is 1x or each one of the set must be used evenly before repeats are allowed. Usually, it's simple abilities like seering, protecting, and killing.

 

[alleycat03]

A vig is a PR and dubz already confirmed there are no 3p in this game. I mean minimal rather than none (otherwise it'd fall into mountainous). Vigs are a very simple role that only requires the basic strategy of analyzing the thread. Something complex would be like night cancel, item making, or converter.

Jack Of All Trades. It means she had multiple abilities. Typically, each ability is 1x or each one of the set must be used evenly before repeats are allowed. Usually, it's simple abilities like seering, protecting, and killing.

Thank you AM for the explanations!

As a general note, I do wonder if there are any other power roles left to be discovered in the game. We’ve already discovered 2 power roles and it’s only day 2. Maybe there is a seer or another “simple” PR ability remaining?

 

[The_Breadmann]

I’d be happy moving to Barks (I mean, not happy... I have no strong wolf reads. But there’s no other player I feel better about voting for yet.)

unvote Sloth
Vote Barks

This makes me kind of suspicious of Visc since they were leaning sloth on comment 271. But Visc did also change votes right before the wagon on Bark took off

 

[Viscernable]

This makes me kind of suspicious of Visc since they were leaning sloth on comment 271. But Visc did also change votes right before the wagon on Bark took off

But I like this post. Getting into more solid vote-based analysis as soon as there are enough non-joke votes to do so would be solid village play. Rethinking my vote.

 

[The_Breadmann]

Sloth did not accuse you, only voted to hear more

 

[PhiloslothicalStudent]

Sloth did not accuse you, only voted to hear more

EXACTLY.

 

[The_Breadmann]

Think i am going to
###vote Visc###
for now. Will probably change votes later

 

[PhiloslothicalStudent]

Barks (6) - alissa, Sporty, visc, sunny, Mayo, kras

Thinking there is definitely something going on here with the quick bandwagon on Barks from last night

Village:
Alissa
??Mayo??

Village-Lean
Kras

Neutral:
Sporty

Wolf-Lean
Visc: they came at very aggressively when I really just asked a simple straight forward question, not very helpful for the village

Wolf:
Sunshine

 

[SportPonies]

yeet genny

I wanna see what happens

 

[kaydubs]

Unofficial D2 bread Tally
Sporty () -
Cray (1) - AM
Viscernable (1) - Bread
genny (1) - Sporty

3/12
yeet close in ~4 hours

@WildZoo

 

[WildZoo]

Oof I can’t decide if I’m offended or not that sourdough was a wolf

sourdough is best bread. But I also made my favorite horses the wolves in HoWWrses, so maybe I’m a hypocrite

All breads were RNG. In case anyone was tempted to game solve this way 😛

 

[SportPonies]

All breads were RNG. In case anyone was tempted to game solve this way 😛

I was not gamesolving, I was just commenting on my hurt feelings haha

 

[genny]

Yeet vis

 

[genny]

yeet genny

I wanna see what happens

Have fun with that

 

[SportPonies]

Unofficial D2 bread Tally
Sporty () -
Cray (1) - AM
Viscernable (1) - Bread
genny (1) - Sporty

3/12
yeet close in ~4 hours

@WildZoo

tallies even when not modding

 

[WildZoo]

I was not gamesolving, I was just commenting on my hurt feelings haha

It wasn't really directed at you in terms of game solving, I was just reminded of the fact that I forgot to mention it earlier because of your comment.

 

[genny]

tallies even when not modding

She’s more addicted than I am 😱

 

[genny]

All breads were RNG. In case anyone was tempted to game solve this way 😛

This can’t be true, otherwise you never would have been right about my broad, flat shape. 😉

 

[genny]

I have doubts that @Crayola227 will show up before yeet close. Sending hugs!

 

[Animal Midwife]

I have doubts that @Crayola227 will show up before yeet close. Sending hugs!

Do you have any read on her?

 

[SportPonies]

I think I missed a couple pages in here somewhere but I'm not sure where, and I haven't eaten a real meal today so I gotta do that before I go sit at school for hours.

Actually, gonna ISO Cray because AM reminded me.

 

[SportPonies]

ISO complete. AM, why are you voting for Cray?

I don't get any distinct wolfy vibes but it's also true there's a lack of my village feels from her from what I've seen so far.

 

[genny]

Do you have any read on her?

Not really. She flagged Mayo’s posts as sketchy, and that’s about it for interaction.

 

[Animal Midwife]

ISO complete. AM, why are you voting for Cray?

I don't get any distinct wolfy vibes but it's also true there's a lack of my village feels from her from what I've seen so far.

Simply because I don't have anything village for her.

 

[Crayola227]

Just woke up and going to get caught up.

 

[kraskadva]

I'm back... catching up

 

[The_Breadmann]

Just woke up and going to get caught up.

Was just about to tag you since you have not posted today. Since I had a hand in your demise last game I hope you can stick around if you are a villager

 

[Crayola227]

Anyone wanna fess up to killing sun?? Good shot!

This reads so fishy to me. April's posts have felt fluffier and different from past games. Wolfy lean.

 

[Crayola227]

It’s creeping me out that the two of the three breads suggested as wolfy (one by a wolf!) are the first two village role reveals. What kind of topsy turvy prognostication is going on here? 🤨

This feels a little fishy too.

I've got my eye on visc, sloth, and mayo from yesterday.

 

[Animal Midwife]

This reads so fishy to me. April's posts have felt fluffier and different from past games. Wolfy lean.

Can you elaborate? What type of things did you see in her prior games that aren't here?

 

[Aprilthearab]

Nothing useful to offer at the moment, just gathering my thoughts -

Leaning Sporty village because I think it would be stupid for Sun to call out a fellow wolf D1.
Leaning Mayo village because Sun was also throwing her vote around there.
Still reading AM as village
Would like to see more from nas since they sat on the mayo vote all of yesterday.

Gonna get some real life stuff done and revisit later.

 

[The_Breadmann]

This reads so fishy to me. April's posts have felt fluffier and different from past games. Wolfy lean.

I would have felt fishy about this if she had not commented immediately afterward

 

[Crayola227]

Spoiler: Day 1

Sporty (1) - AM
AM (1) - genny
Barks (1) - alissa
Bread (1) - Vis
AM (2) - genny, mayo
AM (3) - genny, mayo, kras
Vis (1) - April
kras (1) - sloth
mayo (1) - Nas
mayo (2) - Nas, sunshine
sloth (1) - alley
mayo (3) - Nas, sunshine, Sporty
sloth (2) - alley, Barks
Sporty () -
mayo (4) - Nas, sunshine, Sporty, AM
mayo (3) - Nas, sunshine, AM
Barks (2) - alissa, Sporty
AM (4) - genny, mayo, kras, Bread
kras () -
Vis (2) - April, sloth
sloth (3) - alley, Barks, Cray
AM (3) - mayo, kras, Bread
Bread () -
sloth (4) - alley, Barks, Cray, Vis
Vis (1) - April
mayo (4) - Nas, sunshine, AM, genny
Barks (3) - alissa, Sporty, sloth
Vis () -
sloth (5) - alley, Barks, Cray, Vis, April
Barks (2) - alissa, Sporty
mayo (5) - Nas, sunshine, AM, genny, sloth
AM (2) - kras, Bread
sloth (4) - alley, Barks, Cray, April
Barks (4) - alissa, Sporty, sloth, Vis
sloth (5) - alley, Barks, Cray, April, mayo
sloth (4) - alley, Barks, April, mayo
mayo (6) - Nas, sunshine, AM, genny, sloth, Cray
AM (1) - Bread
sloth (5) - alley, Barks, April, mayo, kras
mayo (5) - Nas, AM, genny, sloth, Cray
Barks (4) - alissa, Sporty, Vis, sunshine
sloth (4) - alley, Barks, April, kras
Barks (5) - alissa, Sporty, Vis, sunshine, mayo
Barks (4) - alissa, Sporty, sunshine, mayo
mayo (5) - Nas, AM, genny, sloth, Vis
mayo (4) - Nas, AM, genny, sloth
Barks (5) - alissa, Sporty, sunshine, mayo, Vis
sloth (3) - alley, Barks, April
Barks (6) - alissa, Sporty, sunshine, mayo, Vis, kras

Feeling like Barks/mayo/sloth could be v/v/v given sunshine's movement. The one I'm least sure about is sloth, but hopefully today can provide more clarification.

I'm awful at VCA, but agree in light of this, mayo looks slightly less wolfy.

Although sunny is a nooby wolf, and some of this could read as noob wolf wolf on wolf interaction. Like maybe sunny thought they could early on make it look like they were voting a fellow wolf to try to make the fellow wolf look less sus, like a preemptive aborted bus or something. That could be tinfoily but I always try to consider all scenarios of w/v vs w/w.

 

[Aprilthearab]

This reads so fishy to me. April's posts have felt fluffier and different from past games. Wolfy lean.

Real explanation: I was taking off my gloves in 15 degree weather to check the thread today, posted faster than my brain could catch up.

Simple explanation: I'm a dumb dumb.

 

[Crayola227]

I would have felt fishy about this if she had not commented immediately afterward

Eh, that could easily read as preemptive defensiveness from a wolf. Like she realized after posting it sounded fishy (which she basically admits to) and is trying to recover the mistake.

 

[The_Breadmann]

Leaning Sporty village because I think it would be stupid for Sun to call out a fellow wolf D1.

I kinda had villager vibes about sport last game too until the 2 packs were united. Hope she is a villager but I am still unsure

 

[Animal Midwife]

I'm awful at VCA, but agree in light of this, mayo looks slightly less wolfy.

Although sunny is a nooby wolf, and some of this could read as noob wolf wolf on wolf interaction. Like maybe sunny thought they could early on make it look like they were voting a fellow wolf to try to make the fellow wolf look less sus, like a preemptive aborted bus or something. That could be tinfoily but I always try to consider all scenarios of w/v vs w/w.

Well, she actually has more wolf experience than village experience at this point.

 

[Crayola227]

This makes me think Kras might be a villager since I don't think that Sun has played to many games with Kras. Since the first game that I was in with both of them Sun got voted out as a villager on the first day and in the second game Sun was a wolf.

Not following the logic here. You're reading this must be w/v why?

 

[Crayola227]

Well, she actually has more wolf experience than village experience at this point.

True. But the vote movements in hindsight seem like noob wolf. She's still a noob no matter how you cut it.

 

[alleycat03]

Vis is giving me vibes from when he was wolfing during the noob game. I don’t know if he’s busier during this game, but he’s not really doing the wolf hunting he did during last game when he was a solid villager.

Yeet vis

 

[The_Breadmann]

Not following the logic here. You're reading this must be w/v why?

Not must but a little more of a gut feeling. Don't really have strong feelings about anyone yet. Just muddling through slight village and slight wolfy