Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.
I mean Fluff. Speculating about PRs like that invites others to respond in a way that may give away whether the speculated pattern fits for them or not, or to start a conversation about PRs which could similarly lead to info getting revealed.
That's the point I'm making lol
That would depend on how it was presented
At least on my end it was 100% serious.
She hasn't answered. WOLF CONFIRMED!
It goes something like
shorty's one of the few that manages to do both well.
What were the villager points on genny?Ok here is where I am at, because I haven't had any strong wolf pings yet.
Nooblets are a mystery to me entirely, and I find voting them out D1 both harmful for morale and not overall helpful for identifying their packmates. So, y'all get a D1 pass from me, this game at least.
I won't be voting lawpy, kal, or meats out today since they haven't played in a while, unless they literally come in here howling.
I have tentative village points for Mel, AM, and genny. Vis always pings me D1 so I'm marinating on that. April hasn't pinged me but I also don't have village points for her yet, so I'm going to read back through her posts. Alley is off-limits d1.
I think that leaves sporty
So I might just reread and see what I find. In the meantime...
unyeet Mel
Oh yeah I was just poking fun at shorty for “vomiting village” over on MU while she was wolfing. I agree with your post and I do think that long posts =/= villager. Wolves can write novels too.
I reply to posts sequentially. If I’m replying to a post before yours, then I haven’t read yours yet, except sometimes if I’m tagged/quoted.
Everyone else has shared some thoughts at this point. @WorthlessOxygen has mentioned they have work, and I accept that as an excuse. For @IvyMoose I don't know. I only saw that she was trying hard to catch up. I tend to forgive players that put in the effort but can't keep up. Vetmedhead made a lot of comments about bowling and nothing about the game yet.
I'm very curious about your placement of stoat and mel
Off to a solid start on my reads
I’m more busy with school this semester and simply asking felt more efficient than trying to follow the Pippy quote thread trying to figure out how it related
Ah okay
Why is stoat that red?
Mel just feels exactly the same as he has for every game I've played with him in the last year. His interactions with AM struck me as in line with how I expect village!Mel to approach her. Other little things here and there. And I haven't gotten any wolfy pings from him yet.
Think of it more as a medium orange. It's not me saying "woah stoat is HOWLING"
She does howl sometimes, but usually just to get the attention of our husky 🐺
Well that's very hedgey, so I'm afraid I can't give you any village points for it 😉
Well, you definitely have at least one of those things, seeing as stoats have fuzzy tails.
I'm offended
I know you said you haven't caught up but it feels odd that you're fairly confident on some players who have barely been around but hedge other relatively active players into insufficient data. At this point I feel like I'd put EVERYONE except myself under insufficient data.
That's why I'm letting your read sit to the side for now
Maybe, but be careful with that. Chronically inactive players might be mod-killed anyway so you don't want to waste your vote. In my opinion it's better to pick someone you could reasonably see being a wolf rather than targeting an inactive player just because you don't have a good read on them yet.
It's actually interesting to me that it pings you so hard for me to be blunt, considering you've seen me openly be sarcastic about being a wolf before. Could you elaborate on this? I think that an "I'm going to ask you this safe question, in the context of assuming we're village and pursuing mutual goals" approach may be hamfisted, but also pretty in-character for me. As long as I got the answer I wanted around your voting choices, it didn't matter to me one way or another if you're a villager or a wolf, and I got information and moved on.
Huh? Why bother even bringing up that you're assuming Dubz is village then? Why not just ask your questions? Also, it sure as heck matters to me who is a villager and who is a wolf.
It will change-- and it's not confident! I said village-leaning neutral. The greener side of grey. I don't know who is a wolf so I'm focused on finding out friendlies. That's just easier to do right now.
On the other hand, being very busy or unengaged in the game looks just like flying under the radar so inactivity is usually a blind shot at whether or not you'll hit a wolf
Please expand on this
Sure, but you also have to consider that you have to follow your feels and firm things up as you go. Yes, the only affiliation you can be 100% confident on is your own (with some few exceptions) but a single player does not a village make.
She's salty she's only read me right twice in 5 years.
I was die-hard confident on the villagerness of some of the wolves in the noob game, so if anything I should NOT follow my feels.
Still gonna want some deets.
There's a difference between just asking me the question, and adding on the "I'm assuming you're village" part. Adding on the latter feels slightly manipulative. "Hey, I'm trusting you" even though you had no reason to, and by your own admission my affiliation did not matter for the purposes of the question you asked.
And is that all of it, or is there more?
Just follow em off the edge of a cliff like I do
That was the ping. Otherwise it's just a lack of things to give you village points for.
it was already addressed by other players after I continued reading. I think the line of thinking is a dangerous way to validate reading AM, though I'm not necessarily awarding either of you wolf points for it*. It's just not something I'm condoning either lol
how about we don't start off the game with me being pissy at you? Don't put words in my mouth.
