Lots of great thoughts/input. OK, here is how I proceeded:
(1) Venue: Before discussing doing this case in the main hospital OR vs eye center with the attending ophthalmologist, I spoke with the attending anesthesiologist on call (and in house) for the main ORs re the local practice pattern about this (for those in practice, consider this comparable to running something past a senior partner). Despite my strong preference for doing this case in the main OR, he indicated that this isn't done due to specialized equipment needs of the ophtho folks. On the upside, he offered to be present during induction/intubation in case extra help was needed. Also, regardless of venue, the pt would recover in the main hospital PACU and could be admitted there if needed. I definitely would not have done this case at a free standing ASC.
(2) Hypoxemia: Certainly concerning. As far as I could tell, this was accurate (good waveform, same reading obtained with new sensor and also using a transport monitor). Interestingly, the pt wasn't dyspneic. Although PE (unlikely given that for him to have a PE large enough to cause this, he'd be in far worse shape), PTX (unlikely given negative CXR and mechanism of injury; when I said low speed I meant it: he was parked and hit by a car traveling at low speed in a parking lot), pulm contusion (no rib fx, inadequate mechanism of injury), etc... are all possible, I think that this was due to a combination of restrictive lung disease due to morbid obesity (this is likely what whomever told him about "small lungs" was referring to) exacerbated by supine positioning, OHS exacerbated by narcotics given in the ED (2 mg dilaudid), and untreated reactive airway disease (although the pt denied it, a previous ED record indicated a history of asthma). Reassuringly, his SpO2 improved to the low 90s (probably his baseline) with a bit of reverse T-berg and albuterol; 100% with supplemental oxygen.
(3) Airway management: Had glidescope, difficult airway cart (with fiberoptic scope set up, LMA, intubating LMA, etc...), and personnel (me, CRNA, main OR attending anesthesiologist, and anesthesia tech). Excellent pre-oxygenation (facemask with rubber strap and a bit of PEEP, ETO2 ~85%, etc...), modified RSI with lidocaine, propofol, defasciculating dose of rocuronium, and sux (sure, there's the theoretical possibility of increased IOP from sux but this is far outweighed by airway concerns; to those who advocated high dose rocuronium because this pt is unlikely to be extubated at the end of the case anyway, I'd posit that it's OK for certain pts to remain intubated/mechanically ventilated post-op but, barring pseudocholinesterase deficiency etc..., it shouldn't be due to excess paralysis). Able to ventilate with two people and an oral airway. Facile intubation with glidescope.
(4) Analgesia: No opiods or midazolam administered. At the end of the procedure, retrobulbar block done by opthalmologist. Also, IV tylenol. Pt was quite comfortable post-op.
(5) Disposition: At the conclusion of the procedure, pt positioned sitting upright and paralysis reversed fully. The trick here was to extubate this pt wide awake but still minimize bucking/increased IOP. I squirted lidocaine down the ETT while he was still deep and then gave a small bolus of propofol as the gas wore off (took a bit of time even using a low flow approach and desflurane); could have been smoother but worked OK. The nasal airway that was inserted after intubation came in handy here. We stayed in the OR for a bit following extubation to make sure that he was stable prior to the ~5 min transport from the eye center OR to the main hospital PACU. I had discussed the possibility of post-op admission with the pt and surgeon but ultimately this proved unnecessary. Within 1 hr post-op, he was off supplemental oxygen and the nasal airway was out. We watched him for another three hours during which he remained stable and then discharged him home (with follow-up the next day).
To be honest, this case went far better than I'd anticipated at the beginning; while I have no doubt that luck played a significant part, I think that my course of action was reasonable. In any case, it was a solid learning opportunity for me and, along those lines, I welcome your comments.