Feb 8, 2013
4
0
Status
Medical Student
You can have a change of heart after a bad reply to a "you're my #1" email.

I know derm is competitive but I wasn't expecting such a response.... Would've rather had no response so my hopes wouldn't be shattered
 

Miss Alyssa

Member
10+ Year Member
Mar 10, 2005
620
7
Status
You can have a change of heart after a bad reply to a "you're my #1" email.

I know derm is competitive but I wasn't expecting such a response.... Would've rather had no response so my hopes wouldn't be shattered
yikes, what was the response?

I haven't sent my #1 an email
 
Feb 8, 2013
4
0
Status
Medical Student
"we'll see how the match turns out." lovely. I'm debating re applying next year or just back up matching into medicine
 

dozitgetchahi

10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Oct 21, 2008
1,583
611
Status
Fellow [Any Field]
"we'll see how the match turns out." lovely. I'm debating re applying next year or just back up matching into medicine
Um, most of my email responses have been noncommittal along these lines. Not everyone gets the overenthusiastic 'we love you and you're ranked to match' emails. Some programs just don't do that.
 
Feb 8, 2013
4
0
Status
Medical Student
I'm definitely ranking derm first, just on the fence about putting medicine at the bottom. Vs not at all to try again next year
 

smq123

John William Waterhouse
Staff member
Administrator
10+ Year Member
Jan 9, 2006
13,945
3,580
Status
Attending Physician
"we'll see how the match turns out." lovely. I'm debating re applying next year or just back up matching into medicine
My boyfriend went back for a 2nd look at a program he had applied to; the program director told him, point blank, that my boyfriend was not going to end up at that program, based on the likely rank list.

Guess where my boyfriend matched? :laugh:

So don't lose hope. You don't know how the match is going to turn out.
 

Miss Alyssa

Member
10+ Year Member
Mar 10, 2005
620
7
Status
yah... :(

What's better/worse? getting a lack luster response and thus not getting your hopes up, or getting back a love letter, getting excited, then getting crushed on Match day.

I know its probably hard, but you have to *try* not to let their response change your rank list or your excitement level.
 
OP
K

kindasorta

Carrot
Dec 17, 2012
279
10
Status
I didn't get a bad response. I got the typical "thanks, glad you liked us" nonsense. I just reconsidered my priorities and lifestyle issues, etc.

How gnarly would it be to pick a new #1? For the record, I wouldn't send out the #1 email to them. I feel like I've used that card already and would want to limit any negative karma.
 

GoSpursGo

Allons-y!
Staff member
Administrator
10+ Year Member
Sep 30, 2008
28,879
1,972
32
Status
Fellow [Any Field]
It's obviously not NICE, but what can you do? PDs know how this thing works, and nothing is binding until the match happens--you would hardly be the first person to change their mind.

At this point I would just do nothing. You might still wind up at that program, in which case as far as anyone need be concerned it was "always" your number 1. If you wind up matching higher on your list, you can send them a short, simple email after the match explaining that circumstances changed and you wound up switching your match list at the last minute--or not, as it's entirely possible you might not have matched there anyways. In any case, it's doubtful they will lose much sleep over not getting one particular candidate :shrug:
 

aProgDirector

Pastafarians Unite!
Moderator
10+ Year Member
Oct 11, 2006
8,213
6,942
Status
Attending Physician
I didn't get a bad response. I got the typical "thanks, glad you liked us" nonsense. I just reconsidered my priorities and lifestyle issues, etc.

How gnarly would it be to pick a new #1? For the record, I wouldn't send out the #1 email to them. I feel like I've used that card already and would want to limit any negative karma.
Why in the world would you do that? If you still want to go there, leave it your #1. If you don't get in there, the match will work just as hard at putting you into your #2 slot. You don't gain anything by changing the order, other than losing the chance of being at your original #1.

To everyone else on this thread, let's recap:

1. Your #1 emails mean nothing to me. I've been "lied" to too many times (or, "Circumstances changed and I had a change of heart", your choice).

2. Our emails to you mean nothing. I want my top and bottom matches (i.e. my highest and lowest ranked candidates) to be equally happy. Since I have no idea where that will be, I'm generic with everyone.

3. Changing anything based upon what was said, or not said, in post interview communication, is foolish. Even if I tell you that I hated your guts and would rather go empty than have you, and then not rank you at all, you do not get hurt, in any way, if you rank me #1. You'll just match somewhere lower on your list.

Honestly, this thread should be closed to stop the insanity.
 

gutonc

No Meat, No Treat
Staff member
Administrator
10+ Year Member
Mar 6, 2005
18,225
11,105
Status
Attending Physician
Why in the world would you do that? If you still want to go there, leave it your #1. If you don't get in there, the match will work just as hard at putting you into your #2 slot. You don't gain anything by changing the order, other than losing the chance of being at your original #1.

To everyone else on this thread, let's recap:

1. Your #1 emails mean nothing to me. I've been "lied" to too many times (or, "Circumstances changed and I had a change of heart", your choice).

2. Our emails to you mean nothing. I want my top and bottom matches (i.e. my highest and lowest ranked candidates) to be equally happy. Since I have no idea where that will be, I'm generic with everyone.

3. Changing anything based upon what was said, or not said, in post interview communication, is foolish. Even if I tell you that I hated your guts and would rather go empty than have you, and then not rank you at all, you do not get hurt, in any way, if you rank me #1. You'll just match somewhere lower on your list.

Honestly, this thread should be closed to stop the insanity.
This is the only part I disagree with. If we close this one, they'll just start another one. Better to keep the crazy people who don't understand the Match algorithm quarantined in one place.
 
OP
K

kindasorta

Carrot
Dec 17, 2012
279
10
Status
Why in the world would you do that? If you still want to go there, leave it your #1. If you don't get in there, the match will work just as hard at putting you into your #2 slot. You don't gain anything by changing the order, other than losing the chance of being at your original #1.

To everyone else on this thread, let's recap:

1. Your #1 emails mean nothing to me. I've been "lied" to too many times (or, "Circumstances changed and I had a change of heart", your choice).

2. Our emails to you mean nothing. I want my top and bottom matches (i.e. my highest and lowest ranked candidates) to be equally happy. Since I have no idea where that will be, I'm generic with everyone.

3. Changing anything based upon what was said, or not said, in post interview communication, is foolish. Even if I tell you that I hated your guts and would rather go empty than have you, and then not rank you at all, you do not get hurt, in any way, if you rank me #1. You'll just match somewhere lower on your list.

Honestly, this thread should be closed to stop the insanity.
You're completely misunderstanding this thread. It's not about changing my #1 based on the email reply I got. I understand with clarity how the match works. It's about changing my #1 because I actually want to choose a different program as #1 for other reasons. The thread is about how that may be received. I'm gathering that PDs don't really care (if they even notice). And even if they do care, it's probably best to look out for good 'ole me rather than worrying about ruffling the feathers of a stranger.
 
Last edited:

gutonc

No Meat, No Treat
Staff member
Administrator
10+ Year Member
Mar 6, 2005
18,225
11,105
Status
Attending Physician
I think you misunderstood me. I have a new #1.
No...I think you misunderstood us.

Nobody cares. Not the program you pledged your undying love to last week. Not your new BFF. Not the third one you're going to kill yourself if you don't match to next week. Nobody. Make your list and move on. As aPD said...programs are lied to repeatedly. They get over it.
 
OP
K

kindasorta

Carrot
Dec 17, 2012
279
10
Status
No...I think you misunderstood us.

Nobody cares. Not the program you pledged your undying love to last week. Not your new BFF. Not the third one you're going to kill yourself if you don't match to next week. Nobody. Make your list and move on. As aPD said...programs are lied to repeatedly. They get over it.
Fine and I'll take that heart. But I wasn't the one misunderstanding things here. A whole bunch of words were written about how stupid it would be to change my #1 based on email correspondence and how the match works.

This thread was never about that. At all.
 

gutonc

No Meat, No Treat
Staff member
Administrator
10+ Year Member
Mar 6, 2005
18,225
11,105
Status
Attending Physician
Fine and I'll take that heart. But I wasn't the one misunderstanding things here. A whole bunch of words were written about how stupid it would be to change my #1 based on email correspondence and how the match works.

This thread was never about that. At all.
Actually if you re-read what a lot of other people wrote, it was completely about that. Once you put it out here you no longer control it. And everybody else who followed on to your post were all "I didn't get a good response after my mash note to my #1 so now I'm not even going to rank it." Which is just straight up dumb.

I will grant you that aPD responded directly to you but I think (and I don't speak for him...he's a PD after all, I'm just a simple country oncologist) he was mostly responding to madness you spawned. As was I.
 
OP
K

kindasorta

Carrot
Dec 17, 2012
279
10
Status
Actually if you re-read what a lot of other people wrote, it was completely about that. Once you put it out here you no longer control it. And everybody else who followed on to your post were all "I didn't get a good response after my mash note to my #1 so now I'm not even going to rank it." Which is just straight up dumb.

I will grant you that aPD responded directly to you but I think (and I don't speak for him...he's a PD after all, I'm just a simple country oncologist) he was mostly responding to madness you spawned. As was I.
i will accept this
 

inmyslumber

ASA Member
10+ Year Member
Jan 8, 2007
173
46
Status
Attending Physician
This was a quick resolution!

Agree with aPD completely. Wish the PD in my own department (Anesthesiology) was as sensible and/or knowledgeable.

-ims
 

medking

The time will come...
10+ Year Member
Apr 16, 2006
902
2
Status
Resident [Any Field]
what if you had a very positive reply but still changed your mind..
Lame, unless it changed due to "family issues" or something of that nature where you couldn't predict or know about beforehand.
 

GoSpursGo

Allons-y!
Staff member
Administrator
10+ Year Member
Sep 30, 2008
28,879
1,972
32
Status
Fellow [Any Field]
what if you had a very positive reply but still changed your mind..
Again, what exactly are you going to do about it now? It's not nice, but you have to do what's best for you, and PDs know this. You will hardly be the first or last person to disappoint them.
 

Random Anesthesiologist

Random Anesthesiologist
10+ Year Member
Mar 16, 2008
1,543
304
Why in the world would you do that? If you still want to go there, leave it your #1. If you don't get in there, the match will work just as hard at putting you into your #2 slot. You don't gain anything by changing the order, other than losing the chance of being at your original #1.

To everyone else on this thread, let's recap:

1. Your #1 emails mean nothing to me. I've been "lied" to too many times (or, "Circumstances changed and I had a change of heart", your choice).


2. Our emails to you mean nothing. I want my top and bottom matches (i.e. my highest and lowest ranked candidates) to be equally happy. Since I have no idea where that will be, I'm generic with everyone.

3. Changing anything based upon what was said, or not said, in post interview communication, is foolish. Even if I tell you that I hated your guts and would rather go empty than have you, and then not rank you at all, you do not get hurt, in any way, if you rank me #1. You'll just match somewhere lower on your list.

Honestly, this thread should be closed to stop the insanity.
This makes me sad. I sent a very sincere email to my #1 to indicate they were my #1, all other programs I was interested in matching were "very very highly ranked" or "very highly ranked". Rank list certified and I'm never looking at it again. Ok, I'm never changing it again ;)

Even though I'm not applying to your specialty, there are a few of us out there with integrity. :oops: