I've seen a lot of these posts about ER not featuring an osteopathic physician. Personally, it doesn't bother me. In my opinion, for osteopathic medicine to become more known, it has to do it the hard way, by showing the public that they are capable physicians, one patient at a time. The fact that the field has been growing over the last 30 years or so tells me that's exactly what is happening.
One of the good things about medicine is that word of mouth packs a hell of a punch. If you're a great physician, people will come to you, DO or MD it doesn't matter. It's a slow process but it's tried and true.
It would be nice to have a DO on ER for some recognition, but it's not all that important, in my opinion. Let's face it, when has ER ever cared about being all that realistic? I don't remember seeing any volunteers on the show but we know that most ER's have 'em. ER is more concerned with dramatic love triangles than breaking new ground.
As far as this academic performance nonsense, from what I've been told by several physicians (you know, the guys with real world experience) that they personally witnessed bottom-of-the-class students become outstanding physicians. Some ranked on the bottom make great doctors, some on the top do as well. Obviously there must not be any magic formula to predict the future success of any one student. In my own case, when I see a doctor, I'm concerned with how much experience he or she has, and with how much respect they treat me. That they were able to perform well on a standardized biochemistry test 20 years couldn't mean any less to me.
In a side note, it's nice to see that this thread hasn't turned into an all out flame war. That says a lot about the kinds of people who contribute to this forum, and maybe a little about the kinds of people going to osteopathic schools.