Congratulations to those of you who were accepted. Condolences to those who were not. And a warning to not dismiss the comments of a successful MS4 student (who has matched into his first choice of an extremely competitive specialty); there are multiple reasons that CU's alumni donations are pretty much the lowest of any med school in the country.
For those who were rejected, a little perspective.
Colorado has the second-lowest acceptance rate for its med school applicants at MD schools in the US (only Arizona has a lower acceptance rate for its applicants at any med school)
http://www.denverpost.com/search/ci_3609931
You have to get it together on time, apply to multiple schools where you have a realistic chance of being accepted, and suck it up to clean up any rough spots in your application. People who get accepted aren't just lucky; most of them work very hard for those acceptances.
The three people mentioned above, who got rejected with good MCATs, are all aware of the problems in their applications. MileHighCajn applied very, very late, to only 5 schools. RxnMan has a very low GPA. And so on. There are ways to get around all these issues, and people on these forums who have done it and are now successful doctors.
Here's what it sounds like when I listen to people on the adcom talking about interviewees: someone with a fantastic MCAT but no clinical experience. Or someone who got rejected the year before, but said they didn't know why (even though the Dean had talked to them in person). Or someone who got rejected for lack of clinical experience and did nothing to improve their clinical experience. Or someone who couldn't articulate why they wanted to be a doctor. Or someone who exaggerated their level of involvement in an EC. Or, most often, someone who didn't appear excited, enthusiastic, and genuinely passionate about medicine.
Please understand, the adcom eventually sees your brilliant MCAT score and the other facets of your application. The committee members are generally very diligent about really looking at your whole package after your interview. But when you go into the interview, they don't know your GPA and your MCAT score. You can shine, or you can come across as a smart person who lacks warmth and the ability to really connect with people. At that moment, you are being compared with the interviewer's personal experience of dozens of your fellow applicants, not some bizarre notion of what a future doctor should be. If you don't come across well in that interview, then that's where you should focus your attention. If it's some other aspect of the "total package" that is limiting you, then you must clean that up.
There are people in my class who were rejected anywhere from 1 to 5 times, and kept going, improving their application every year. That perseverance, and the willingness to accept criticism, now make them very successful medical students.
Good luck to all of you. And for those with a few years to go before applying and a lot of money, there is a new osteopathic school projected to open in Colorado in August 2008 (Rocky Vista, south Denver, class of 100, 50% in-state, a private for-profit school).