Do you need to join (competitive) pre-med clubs to get into a top medical school?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

astrelin

New Member
Joined
Nov 11, 2023
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Let me start by saying that I know I'd be lucky to get into medical school at all, let alone a T20.

I'm a second-year at a top 20 undergraduate institution in the US, and my school has a lot of competitive pre-med clubs that offer a lot of "prestigious" opportunities like shadowing, clinical research, etc. at our top hospital/medical school. These clubs are extremely competitive and have a very low acceptance rate, which is even worse because the average undergraduate here is already cracked. Many of these students go onto top medical schools.

I would say that I'm in a pretty good spot - I have a 4.0, a publication during my freshman year (from research I did in high school), am a research assistant in a non-clinical lab in the med school, hold officer positions in both a volunteer program affiliated with our hospital as well as a more "minor" hobby club, work part-time (not medicine related though), and have both clinical and non-clinical volunteer opportunities. Eventually, I hope to get a job as a scribe or EMT, try getting involved in clinical research, and find shadowing opportunities.

From my POV, I have all the opportunities available to me to create a "competitive" application, but the hype at my school about these competitive pre-med clubs is making me doubt myself. I'm pretty sure most of the people who go to T20 medical schools from my undergrad are part of these clubs. Is it worth joining one of these clubs just for the extra opportunities, and is it really that hard to come across those opportunities on my own? I really don't want to write 50 200-word essays and go through 16 rounds of interviews just to get rejected because I'm not friends with the board members...

Members don't see this ad.
 
It definitely does help just due to the connections and opportunities you can obtain from joining these clubs. However, they are absolutely not needed to go into a "top medical school." I was not in any premed club or organization and I think I'm doing pretty well in the cycle so far.
 
Welcome to the forums.

"Competitive"/Selective premed clubs???
1727265690098.png


There are going to be two schools of thought with this:
1) Networking and resource convenience. Sure! That's why a lot of people join fraternities or sororities! Test banks! Community!
party college GIF by South Park


2) Student culture (cutthroat? or fake mutualism?). For your mental health...
Mean Girls GIF by filmeditor


Get used to the fact that cliques happen. Plenty of people get into top medical schools without having to be "bootcamped", but at some point, you have to decide whether this is a group you want to join. Many clubs are likely more toxic and perpetuate more disinformation/myths than our online forums or reddit (which is why they have Discord groups).

Find strong mentors who will support you and keep you real.
 
Last edited:
Members don't see this ad :)
If I am reviewing an application, participation in premed clubs will not impress me ONE IOTA, unless what you have done in that club constitutes significant service to people in need.
 
As a first year med student, I am living proof of someone who wasn't involved in a "pre-med" specific club. Yes, I still did shadowing and clinical work as well, but at no point did I join my school's "competitive" EMT program or ski patrol group, those being the one that were "competitive."

You seem to have your niche going and you're hitting the right bases. Keep your GPA up, continue some research and especially continue your clinical and service-oriented work/volunteering, and you'll be miles ahead of many of those folks.
 
Let me start by saying that I know I'd be lucky to get into medical school at all, let alone a T20.

I'm a second-year at a top 20 undergraduate institution in the US, and my school has a lot of competitive pre-med clubs that offer a lot of "prestigious" opportunities like shadowing, clinical research, etc. at our top hospital/medical school. These clubs are extremely competitive and have a very low acceptance rate, which is even worse because the average undergraduate here is already cracked. Many of these students go onto top medical schools.

I would say that I'm in a pretty good spot - I have a 4.0, a publication during my freshman year (from research I did in high school), am a research assistant in a non-clinical lab in the med school, hold officer positions in both a volunteer program affiliated with our hospital as well as a more "minor" hobby club, work part-time (not medicine related though), and have both clinical and non-clinical volunteer opportunities. Eventually, I hope to get a job as a scribe or EMT, try getting involved in clinical research, and find shadowing opportunities.

From my POV, I have all the opportunities available to me to create a "competitive" application, but the hype at my school about these competitive pre-med clubs is making me doubt myself. I'm pretty sure most of the people who go to T20 medical schools from my undergrad are part of these clubs. Is it worth joining one of these clubs just for the extra opportunities, and is it really that hard to come across those opportunities on my own? I really don't want to write 50 200-word essays and go through 16 rounds of interviews just to get rejected because I'm not friends with the board members...
Great question, I feel that it can definitely get you more attention at first which can be valuable in getting you a step ahead out of curiosity, but then it is all about you. Overall, no one cares about the clubs they are more interested in you and your capabilities. In my opinion, no one should judge you negatively for doing everything you can to be successful as long as you are honest with your actions.
 
I've never heard of "competitive" pre-med clubs, especially any that would be involved in barring access to opportunities for students. This sounds like a student group with an over-inflated sense of self-importance.

I can see interviews and personal statements to apply to competitive programs at a medical school for shadowing or clinical experience, but... a CLUB?!

This seems like the height of gate-keeping, and if it were me I'd avoid it on principle.
 
Top