- Joined
- Feb 5, 2009
- Messages
- 1,358
- Reaction score
- 6
Working for yourself is a lot harder than working for the government.
But working for yourself is much more rewarding and profitable.
Working for yourself is a lot harder than working for the government.
So why the hostility?And yes, these can be perceived as some of the cons of military dentistry. I will say as a military dental provider, you are VERY involved in the ordering of supplies, but as you stated, you are NOT involved in the billing.
The two biggest negatives I have observed is your lack of controlling who your assistants are, and as you pointed out, the lack of control you have on the bottom line (until you are running the clinic as a senior officer). In the civilian world, if you assistants are not up to snuff, you fire them. In the military world, you have to deal with it.
Absolutely.But working for yourself is much more rewarding and profitable.
joonkim, welcome to the club...I put myself through undergrad and grad school with no help from my parents. Every loan is in my name...whats a few 100K more?
Take out loans, be financially responsible, and you'll be fine.
What about the Navy? Air Force?...if her reason is that she doesn't want you to get shipped.
What about Indian Health Services or National Health Service Corp scholarships?
i was in the military.
dont just go in for the loan payback. lets say thats 200k over four years. the difference between your very low military salary and what you could be making with your own practice (lets say 150k here for low end for illustration vs 70k salary in the army as a captain), thats 80x3 plus , 100k for your first year as an associate , so 30k dif, thats 270k more money youre making by not going in the army. so weve proven the financial aspect.
i was in the military.
dont just go in for the loan payback. lets say thats 200k over four years. the difference between your very low military salary and what you could be making with your own practice (lets say 150k here for low end for illustration vs 70k salary in the army as a captain), thats 80x3 plus , 100k for your first year as an associate , so 30k dif, thats 270k more money youre making by not going in the army. so weve proven the financial aspect. And thats using a low estimate of your private practice income, IMO youd make more depending on locale.
however, a few reasons you should. one, you get to join the military, its truly a rewarding experience. Two, youll def have the experience and speed to open your own private practice once you exit (however it can be argued that you would have this with one year of associating.).
another is you dont have to actually deal with the loans. this is a poor excuse though, you shouldnt be afraid of debt. d school debt is good debt.
Id suggest talking with a few military dentists before making your decision.
I think the military might be more financially lucrative if you only stay for 3-4 years, especially if you go to a high tuition private school. Correct me if I'm wrong, but one of the keys is you will have to pay income tax on what you make in private practice but not on the loan reimbursement. So if you say go to USC and the military pays $280K for your tuition loans, but in private practice that would really be like paying 35% more than that when you account for income tax which is close to $400K in income value. Plus you won't accrue interest on the loans you took out, and you'll make a modest salary too.
Exactly.It's the whole tangible vs. intangible aspect of civilian vs. military NET income and benefits. It's really difficult to actually compare the exact numbers.
It's the whole tangible vs. intangible aspect of civilian vs. military NET income and benefits. It's really difficult to actually compare the exact numbers.
Also, for an earlier post by cmcner...NO WAY will you do only 3-4 years. 4 years MINIMUM is what you owe. You can probably bank of 5 years active service and a few more on the books as IRR.
Like I keep saying, look up the references on your own and get your information from the source document(s.) Trying to get gather quick answers from comments on a message board from people you don't know leads to poor decision-making.
It's a year of tuition for a year of service with a minimum of 3 years of service, please look up your references.
your numbers and math seem to randomly be picked from the sky, which is besides the fact that your 200K estimate for school is way off.
I have the scholarship:
-tuition covered will roughly equal 300K
-instruments and required materials will be maybe another 30K
-stipend and bonus will be another 120K
-for your 4 years of work your base salary may be 70K but with allowances and raises it is proportionally a lot more
by the time you have finished your 4 years of service you will have potentially received 750-800K
Have you applied? were did you get all your numbers from? I am basing these on one of the many expensive private schools (where the scholarship is most lucrative).
There are downsides: a more narrow scope of procedures, reduced business management and some others.....but i come from a navy family and am proud to join for many reasons
do it for the right reasons though
ok, if youre going to the most expensive school in the US, ill take your word for it that it will be a 450k scholarship so lets start with that. I do question the 120k in bonus and stipend though, theyre going to give you 30k per year in addition to your tuition? Thats great - you wont be as poor as the average student. But lets all agree this amount for four years of d school is on the high side.
as a captain youre paid 4500 a month, so 48k a year. Lets bump it up to 70k because of intangibles like insurance, free barracks etc (i dont remember if officers get free barracks like enlisted, but lets overstate military income to prove the example.)
ok, if youre going to the most expensive school in the US, ill take your word for it that it will be a 450k scholarship so lets start with that. I do question the 120k in bonus and stipend though, theyre going to give you 30k per year in addition to your tuition?
It's a year of tuition for a year of service with a minimum of 3 years of service, please look up your references.
30K comes from other expenses which if you identify as a school requirement the military reimburses you (may be on the high side)
we can debate money all day...........but no one should go into it for that sole reason
ok, if youre going to the most expensive school in the US, ill take your word for it that it will be a 450k scholarship so lets start with that. I do question the 120k in bonus and stipend though, theyre going to give you 30k per year in addition to your tuition? Thats great - you wont be as poor as the average student. But lets all agree this amount for four years of d school is on the high side.
as a captain youre paid 4500 a month, so 48k a year. Lets bump it up to 70k because of intangibles like insurance, free barracks etc (i dont remember if officers get free barracks like enlisted, but lets overstate military income to prove the example.)
so, my number from the skies you refer to are my estimated associate salary, as well as private practice salary. Check the forums and the web, as well as a few dental friends to come up with your own. Through my research im comfy using 100k and 150k respectively (and im using lower amounts than i really think for illustration). ill break down the math that follows so its less cryptic.
so by going in the army, you give up 80x3 (this is the dif between your military and private practice salaries) + 30 (difference between your associateship salary and army salary), which is 270k. Using your numbers you gain 450k through scholarship, which nets you 180k. This looks like a good deal for you.
This number changes based on what you think you will pull in in private practice, as well as your total DS cost. With the collosal cost of your school (450k) id say go for it. The average D student pays 200k total though so if you have a dif choice thats a bit cheaper you may want to look into it.
cmcner makes a good point, the scholarship money should be multiplied by your income tax rate, which makes it more valuable (it equates the scholarship amount to what you would have to make from a salary in those years pretax) which skews the numbers more in favor of the scholarship.
also be careful (as an above poster mentioned) .. once you sign into the military, you cant get out until they let you. If something major in the world happens you could be looking at years more of service.
Subdoc, I don't know why you got pissed on but stop loss and other BS you probably went through sucks but happens less to commissioned officers. 3 years AD and 5 years IRR is the contract and any lawyer will happily take on your case.
1. Didn't get pissed on. I am getting out to go to school on my terms. "Stop loss" is a term RARELY heard in Navy circles.
2. I am a commissioned officer, have been for quite some time. Resignation is a MUCH more difficult and arduous process for officers than enlisted. The only real easy ways out are to pop positive on a drug test, be really overweight, or be a homosexual. 9-12 months otherwise.
3. Sure, you can ALWAYS find a lawyer to take any case, but the million dollar question is, "Can he win?" More specifically, can he win in a short period of time.
4. A good rule of thumb is the more expensive the training, the more difficult it is to get out. Also, the more undermanned the specialty, the more difficult it is to get out.
adrift - this is vs what you quote of 150k a year, unless youre saying that with your military pay plus what youre making in loan paybacks per year youre doing 150kish, in which case i agree.
1. Didn't get pissed on. I am getting out to go to school on my terms. "Stop loss" is a term RARELY heard in Navy circles.
2. I am a commissioned officer, have been for quite some time. Resignation is a MUCH more difficult and arduous process for officers than enlisted. The only real easy ways out are to pop positive on a drug test, be really overweight, or be a homosexual. 9-12 months otherwise.
3. Sure, you can ALWAYS find a lawyer to take any case, but the million dollar question is, "Can he win?" More specifically, can he win in a short period of time.
4. A good rule of thumb is the more expensive the training, the more difficult it is to get out. Also, the more undermanned the specialty, the more difficult it is to get out.
to be honest i can speak from personal experience. i don't agree with what everyone is saying. i have been with girlfriend for six years of which we spent the last 4 long distance.
Well, I think subdoc has nailed down most of the salient points, so I dont have much to add except in the way of personal experience.
I am at UOP and all of us in my year group have 3 year commitments. Will we do 36 months and then get out without getting extended? I dunno, we'll see.
One thing to keep in mind is that ever present interest on student loans. Sure the scholarship covers tuition (220+ at Pacific) but it also rules out paying 10 to 30 years of accrued interest on that 220. Factor that in and the numbers change substantially. Over 30 years that 220 could easily become 440 or more.
To me it is so obvious that the scholarship should not be done for purely monetary reasons as to not need stating. I have a friend in Afghanistan who missed the birth of his first born. He aint all that happy right now and I cannot blame him. In years to come when people tell their "war stories" and what they have sacrificed he will have something to say in that regards. Much more than most of the sorry sacks who live in this country, complain about it, and have never lifted a finger for it one way or another. Thats my schpiel/rationale for dealing with deployments by the way. You just suck it up like the patriots of old and drive on.
Back to the money argument. On the flip side I wish that you predents could see the stress on my soon-to-be-graduating comrades faces. It all seems so theoretical before school kicks off. It is just numbers on some sheet of paper somewhere. And then you are going to graduate soon and the job market is tight and those student loans are looming like Everest. Most of my classmates don't know where they are going to work and a few are seriously entertaining working at Western Dental or something for the first few years until they get their speed up. Do they care they aren't "building patient base/business acumen/community goodwill"?
Frankly, most don't care, they just want a job and want to learn how real dentistry works outside of school. If you asked them now if they would go back and take the scholarship if they could, or if they would join if the military would pay off their loans, as sizable portion of them would jump at it. 3 or 4 years of seeing 1 fully financially approved patient an hour? Doesn't sound that bad to me.
I tell you a week doesn't go by that I don't tell my wife how good the Army has been to us.
Everyone thinks they'll make 120k-150K straight out of school and 200K in private practice. Keep dreaming, as a newbie dentist, you will have to agree to work in rural Wyoming to earn those numbers. More realistically, if you can land a decent associate position, think about $400-$500 a day part time 2-3 days/per week. There aren't very many "good" full time 40-45/hour a week jobs out there except for Western Dental type places. Sure they pay decently but you definitely work for it.
Where are you getting this information from? move to Wyoming? What? Maybe if you are practicing in a super saturated state, like California
seems to be, but anywhere else you should be fine.
All of the publications are showing $100,000-$120,000 average for new dentists graduating today working as associates, and an average of $200,000 for owners. Yes you need to build up speed, but that will happen over the first year or two out of school.
Furthermore, regardless of the "economy" there will be more dentists retiring than dentists coming out of dental school within the next decade.
Plus anyone entering for the class of 2014 and 2015 next year will ride out the worst of the bad economy.
This has been discussed ad nasuem in other threads. As long as you have a DDS/DMD after your name and you are competant, there will be plenty of opportunties to make money in the next decades.
If you are only able to find part time work, you can work for two separate dentists, and fill up your week that way.
i sure hope you mean competent
Sure, UoP is three years, but there is virtually no way you would qualify to separate at the 3 year point. If you think so, I have some ocean-front property in Arizona ready to sell you. No detailer would let your request slip through the cracks. Your orders would be cut for a PRD well after the 3 year point. Plus, PER THE REFERENCE, your resignation letter/request must be in 9-12 months before your requested date. (I know this as a 9 year active duty Naval officer going through the resignation process before I enter dental school this Sept.) If you think your CO will endorse your letter (another requirement) at the 2 1/4 year point of your obligation, you are fooling yourself. To add insult to injury, fully expect a PCS before you are eligible to separate which obligates you to further time in service. Like I said, 4 years MIN, and more than likely 5 years.
Hey Joon
If you go and login in to the portal at Midwestern (where you saw your accepted student checklist) you can click on the financial services tab, then click on "Apply for Aid" then "Apply for 2010-11." There are five steps listed, the first being a walk through video tutorial that explains the various options that we, as soon to be ridiculously poor dental students, have. Check out the video, fill out your FAFSA, and apply for your loans! Et voila!
Does 1 loan pay for everything or should I apply for several loans?
do some dental schools give full rides for low income students like a lot of top colleges do?
I just got into a dental school but I am from a poor family and don't know how to pay the tuition.
At first, I was gonna join the army because they would pay for me and all the benefits I can get after graduating from DS, but I have a girlfriend and she doesn't want me to join the army. I am already feeling extremely sorry to my gf for planning a long distance relationship for next 4 years so her opinion means alot to me.
Where should I begin first?