- Joined
- Jul 11, 2013
- Messages
- 1,978
- Reaction score
- 4,685
It's interesting. My first thought is that they don't really care too too much, as long as they fill with good/qualified candidates. On the other hand, I've always heard about surgical sub PDs/chairs bragging about how they filled so high on their rank list. Of course, these are the same individuals that engage in those stupid PIC shenanigans. I figured it was just an ego thing.
So many students say stuff like "Yeah, I'm definitely ranking this institution low or not at all" because of their malignancy, or for whatever legitimate reason. Apparently some programs actually make changes based on applicant feedback. Of course, this is because filling high on their rank list is extremely important to them, not because they actually care about being a good program, lol.
Of course, programs want who they want, but at the end of the day, I reckon that, especially at the most competitive of specialties/programs, everyone on the rank list is more or less equally qualified to do the job well.
The answer to this question can help give us a sense of how much power (though obviously still little compared to programs) we have. If enough people decide to low-rank/DNR a certain program, they may end up with an disappointing match or even unfilled. Of course, this already happens at some malignant programs, but what about other programs?
So many students say stuff like "Yeah, I'm definitely ranking this institution low or not at all" because of their malignancy, or for whatever legitimate reason. Apparently some programs actually make changes based on applicant feedback. Of course, this is because filling high on their rank list is extremely important to them, not because they actually care about being a good program, lol.
Of course, programs want who they want, but at the end of the day, I reckon that, especially at the most competitive of specialties/programs, everyone on the rank list is more or less equally qualified to do the job well.
The answer to this question can help give us a sense of how much power (though obviously still little compared to programs) we have. If enough people decide to low-rank/DNR a certain program, they may end up with an disappointing match or even unfilled. Of course, this already happens at some malignant programs, but what about other programs?