I would go like so:
1. Monti- I hear great things, its a children's hospital, you'll get great training in the bronx
2. Mount Sinai- Best rep of all four, happy house staff
3. NYU- Best location in the city hands down, 2 golden weekends each month from what I hear
4. LIJ- Great hospital, there are rumblings of unhappiness among house staff but who really knows for sure
This is just my 2 cents, I only interviewed at one of these 4 places and do not intend on going there so yea
my husband and i are trying to get our rank list together...he has job offers in san diego and new haven...we are choosing between these and living separately btw new york/ new haven, choosing just yale or ucsd. any thoughts in the differences btw yale/ucsd...we'd really prefer to not live apart.