HoWWrses: Game Thread

[Melchizedek]

Um I voted today - if were trying to vote in a block i think the options should be Weim, Cubs or Genny



Cubs is sketching me out. Lets not lynch me. What's making you think Dina this game?

Edit- typo

Because if I were to convert someone, which based on how this lynch is going I'm starting to see it as more and more of a possibility, I'd probably pick her or KL, but more so Dina. She made it pretty far into the game last game as a wolf, and likely would have been fine if DocE hadn't bussed her out of the blue for no reason. She's been minimally active, just enough to stay above everyone's suspicions. She's not a stupid obvious choice like coffee or a rez.

---

Members don't see this ad.

 

[genny]

Village, we need to get our ish together. This is silly. Let's lynch a wolf. I know it's not me, it's not cubs, not likely to be caiter/vmh, coffee, ski, killer, or weim. So if the rest of you could just die in a giant tie, I'd feel so much better about how today is going.

 

[cubsrule4e]

Village, we need to get our ish together. This is silly. Let's lynch a wolf. I know it's not me, it's not cubs, not likely to be caiter/vmh, coffee, ski, killer, or weim. So if the rest of you could just die in a giant tie, I'd feel so much better about how today is going.

I could go for that...5 votes to go though

 

[Crayola227]

I think Snowy is a bad lynch

Mel could be a total liar, of course, although when he's wolf he often still makes good points on players

He pointed out in an earlier post evidence of good independent thought and wolf hunting integration that is just more distinctive of village Snowy

Also, I would say that she's not in her wolf meta. Her wolf meta, she asks a lot of questions in a way that is a really pointed, almost attack-y interrogation way.

Village Snowy still asks questions, but the tone is different. It's more laidback and general. I imagine this difference reflects a true desire to cooperate with villagers to hunt wolves and a lack of being informed, so therefore more general and less accusatory. The more pointed questions, are actually more "leading" like how you see a cross-examining attorney try to make someone look bad. The agenda of her questions is fundamentally different as wolf vs village and it shows in the tone of her questions. A wolf knows where they are going with any given question. Villagers are a bit more clueless, the questions can be much more open-ended.

I find wolfy Snowy is usually "getting" at something.

 

[Melchizedek]

screw it. AM's going to kill me for convert hunting but

Unlynch Cubs
Lynch Dina.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

screw it. AM's going to kill me for convert hunting but

Unlynch Cubs
Lynch Dina.

do you not think Dina is original?

 

[Crayola227]

Because if I were to convert someone, which based on how this lynch is going I'm starting to see it as more and more of a possibility, I'd probably pick her or KL, but more so Dina. She made it pretty far into the game last game as a wolf, and likely would have been fine if DocE hadn't bussed her out of the blue for no reason. She's been minimally active, just enough to stay above everyone's suspicions. She's not a stupid obvious choice like coffee or a rez.

So much WIFOM in this

your points on Dina are well taken. The bit about Coffee as a convert... I find much less convincing. And I absolutely would not put it past you or any wolf, really.

 

[Melchizedek]

do you not think Dina is original?

Based on PM interactions, no.

 

[muttmanager]

Lynch mutt

Retalitory much. Wanna share an independent thought ?

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Based on PM interactions, no.

so the point is trying to NOT convert hunt.
Looking for the other blocker. If you don't believe she is the other blocker, shouldn't vote there.

 

[muttmanager]

Village, we need to get our ish together. This is silly. Let's lynch a wolf. I know it's not me, it's not cubs, not likely to be caiter/vmh, coffee, ski, killer, or weim. So if the rest of you could just die in a giant tie, I'd feel so much better about how today is going.

Why is weim not likely?

 

[Crayola227]

What do you think of him claiming village blocker and having no counter claim yet?

did any of the flipped wolves have something similar?

did the confusion about night results get cleared up yesterday? I didn't see where the chips fell on that

like I said, I'm not sold on Mel as a wolf, nor am I dismissing the possibility, I probably need to read more to really know. I think given that he was a top contender and now we have vote switching and other wagons, while either/or is a bad way to go, regardless I am weighing his lynch vs the other contenders like Snowy and Dina.

At this point I'd like to know more about the votes for Dina. Mel does make a good case about her that stands independent of his affiliation, in that his observations about her play are true. So it takes a bit more for me to come down on that side of things, wolfy Mel usually makes good points. So I like to see more than his points for myself or from others to go there. I won't go anywhere based on Mel's word alone. Not to say others aren't going there. Just explaining my thought process.

 

[SkiOtter]

What if the village blocker blocked cheez and just hasn’t been on today

 

[Crayola227]

so the point is trying to NOT convert hunt.
Looking for the other blocker. If you don't believe she is the other blocker, shouldn't vote there.

shoot how do we know there is another blocker?

if there are two, in my mind that just increases the likelihood one is wolf, which actually in my mind makes it more likely it could be Mel

 

[Animal Midwife]

****************************************************
Day 8 Mustang Sally Monday Lynch Tally

Snowy (2) - MJ, cubs
Mel (2) - Ski, Snowy
Weim (1) - mutts
Dina (3) - killer, Coffee?, Mel
Cray () -
cubs () -
MJ (1) - genny
mutts (1) - Weim

10/14 voting
@Dinashadow you are in lead!

Missing: Dina, Cray, Cait, MSU

Lynch close at 9pm CST (35 minutes)

all you wanna do is ride
****************************************************

 

[SkiOtter]

shoot how do we know there is another blocker?

if there are two, in my mind that just increases the likelihood one is wolf, which actually in my mind makes it more likely it could be Mel

Two different blocking messages.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

did any of the flipped wolves have something similar?

did the confusion about night results get cleared up yesterday? I didn't see where the chips fell on that

like I said, I'm not sold on Mel as a wolf, nor am I dismissing the possibility, I probably need to read more to really know. I think given that he was a top contender and now we have vote switching and other wagons, while either/or is a bad way to go, regardless I am weighing his lynch vs the other contenders like Snowy and Dina.

At this point I'd like to know more about the votes for Dina. Mel does make a good case about her that stands independent of his affiliation, in that his observations about her play are true. So it takes a bit more for me to come down on that side of things, wolfy Mel usually makes good points. So I like to see more than his points for myself or from others to go there. I won't go anywhere based on Mel's word alone. Not to say others aren't going there. Just explaining my thought process.

No, no wolfy blocker roles yet.

 

[SkiOtter]

shoot how do we know there is another blocker?

if there are two, in my mind that just increases the likelihood one is wolf, which actually in my mind makes it more likely it could be Mel

Two different blocking messages.

One seems like it could be a pony. Which is the message cheez is claiming. See my posts from today on why I feel like that is the sketchier one.

 

[Melchizedek]

so the point is trying to NOT convert hunt.
Looking for the other blocker. If you don't believe she is the other blocker, shouldn't vote there.

Then I've got nothing because everyone and their mother seem to have soft vouches or something that clears them. Besides I guess MJ. Might as well go join genny there lol

 

[Caiter92]

I think it makes him less likely to be wolf and I wouldn't be thrilled to vote there but guess I could

So add cray - vouch from Cait
And I'm also going to put Mutts - SOFT vouch from Coffee - if the group wants to vote there I would want to talk to her first

I will put unlynch Mel Lynch Dina for now

But why does it make MJ less likely a wolf? We have nothing to go on with him, and skirting by is his thing these days. If he got on, and saw a wolf was up for lynch, it would make sense for him to vote there.

I’m not saying we have to go there right now, but him voting for wolves in all three lynches is moot to me when it’s not like he’s been around to develop his own theories.

 

[WeimMama]

Retalitory much. Wanna share an independent thought ?

Do you?

 

[Crayola227]

Lynch snowy

opportunistic as usual, just vote a rando or whoever's name is being thrown around

I haven't forgot you were playing, but too many players not giving data points to justify lynching them all, if we did that at this point we'd just lose

 

[Dinashadow]

screw it. AM's going to kill me for convert hunting but

Unlynch Cubs
Lynch Dina.

😱

I mean you make good points about me possibly being a convert. My role would make me a stupid wolf but other wolves wouldn't know that.

I'm not a wolf though but role revealing isn't going to help prove that if you guys think I'm a convert which we don't even know if that's happened

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

But why does it make MJ less likely a wolf? We have nothing to go on with him, and skirting by is his thing these days. If he got on, and saw a wolf was up for lynch, it would make sense for him to vote there.

I’m not saying we have to go there right now, but him voting for wolves in all three lynches is moot to me when it’s not like he’s been around to develop his own theories.

I saw him wolf twice last year and IMO he was pretty obvious as a wolf those times.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

But why does it make MJ less likely a wolf? We have nothing to go on with him, and skirting by is his thing these days. If he got on, and saw a wolf was up for lynch, it would make sense for him to vote there.

I’m not saying we have to go there right now, but him voting for wolves in all three lynches is moot to me when it’s not like he’s been around to develop his own theories.

I saw him wolf twice last year and IMO he was pretty obvious as a wolf those times.

 

[Dinashadow]

I had a long day and I need to drive home

Lynch MJ

A lot of people on my sketch list have a vouch or some other reasoning. This is mostly based on feels and not wanting a possible MJ wolf slipping through the cracks.

 

[Melchizedek]

shoot how do we know there is another blocker?

if there are two, in my mind that just increases the likelihood one is wolf, which actually in my mind makes it more likely it could be Mel

Come off it. There's no blocker counter claim with the ****show thats going on on thread and somehow that makes me MORE wolfy?

😱

I mean you make good points about me possibly being a convert. My role would make me a stupid wolf but other wolves wouldn't know that.

I'm not a wolf though but role revealing isn't going to help prove that if you guys think I'm a convert which we don't even know if that's happened

the fact that you didn' tjust come on an autolynch me reinforces my village read of you, but hell IDK anymore man. My two explanations for last night are either I blocked the wolf kill, in which case, back to cubs we go, or that there was a conversion, which seems possible seeing how this is playing out, in which case I'm on you.

 

[muttmanager]

Do you?

Sorry spending the weekend with my family & going bowling in a bit - quote/tag me for questions please

Wolf leans
Weim - increased activity once 3 wolves died = last OG wolf standing?
Cubs - confused noob or wolf playing noob?

Neutral = possibly wolfy
Genny - can't read her
vetmedhead/Caiter92 - based on vmh's play
Cray - previous feels
Snowy - believe claim, could be convert

Lurky = leaning village
Dinashadow
MSUcvmHOPE
Killerleaf
Mad Jack - he still playing?

Village leans
Coffee - village confirmed?
Melchizedek - small and formidable & visited twice = confused
Ski - shared info exposing Skim

Your turn.

 

[Melchizedek]

Unlynch Dina
Lynch MJ

its about that time in the game he starts answering questions or dies.

 

[Caiter92]

I saw him wolf twice last year and IMO he was pretty obvious as a wolf those times.

He literally just skirted by in Dog’s until the end.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

unlynch dina
lynch MJ

guess we'll find out something

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

He literally just skirted by in Dog’s until the end.

oh I didn't tot it very well

 

[Caiter92]

***lynch MJ***

 

[genny]

unlynch mj
lynch mel

 

[Crayola227]

I was on cray and no one liked that. None of the other 3 have struck me as particularly wolfy. capri/bryndi were all over MSU so she is least wolfy on that list for me

please be so careful how much you use what wolves have said or done to clear someone

there's a difference between looking at interactions with wolves to look for evidence of w/w or w/v as part of a bigger picture

and the phrasing "no one liked that" - be careful with that. It sounds like a wolfy agenda. You vote who you think are wolves, not what lynches you think will be liked. Wolves care about the latter, not the former. If the game goes in a direction where villagers are being mislynched, the ratio of wolf:village can go up in a way where you find that correctly identifying a wolf for lynch will become less and less popular.

 

[Melchizedek]

@Mad Jack you're up for lynch

tagging you because you got pissy with us last time lynch flipped your way last minute and you weren't notified 🙄

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

unlynch mj
lynch mel

😱😱😱

 

[genny]

I just made a giant pile of strawberry/blackberry jam. I was going to make strawberry danishes, but I suddenly have this craving for waffles.....

 

[Caiter92]

oh I didn't tot it very well

Maybe he’s just super busy right now, but I’ve seen him do this as a wolf.

Plus we can’t come to a consensus at all about the other remaining unknowns. I’m fine lynching him when literally we know nothing about him. If he is village then he’s not exactly being helpful right now

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

I just made a giant pile of strawberry/blackberry jam. I was going to make strawberry danishes, but I suddenly have this craving for waffles.....

what are you thnking right now?

 

[Animal Midwife]

****************************************************
Day 8 Mustang Sally Monday Lynch Tally

Snowy (2) - MJ, cubs
Mel (3) - Ski, Snowy, genny
Weim (1) - mutts
Dina (1) - killer
Cray () -
cubs () -
MJ (4) - Dina, Mel, Coffee?, Cait
mutts (1) - Weim

12/14 voting
@Mad Jack you are in lead!

Missing: Cray, MSU

Lynch close at 9pm CST (15 minutes)

all you wanna do is ride
****************************************************

 

[genny]

what are you thnking right now?

why didn't i buy whipped cream at the store?

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

why didn't i buy whipped cream at the store?

good question

 

[genny]

that's probably not very helpful.

I'm still sketched out by mel, and it's weird how everyone piled on MJ so easily. It makes me nervous.

 

[cubsrule4e]

updated tally?

 

[cubsrule4e]

Ninja'd easily on that one

 

[Crayola227]

Jeebus Crab guys.

I'm against Snowy, and I'm interested in Mel, but yeah, MJ is too quiet. I don't know where to go to try to cinch the lynch (cwidt) on a more favoured candidate.

 

[Lawpy]

why didn't i buy whipped cream at the store?

good question

***************

***************

 

[Crayola227]

lynch Mel

I'm trying something out

 

[genny]

Jeebus Crab guys.

I'm against Snowy, and I'm interested in Mel, but yeah, MJ is too quiet. I don't know where to go to try to cinch the lynch (cwidt) on a more favoured candidate.

Why were you in Lupin's stall the night she died? Granted, bryndi was there too, but you've been avoiding my questions through Cubs and it's starting to grate on me.