I am also a D1 at UCSF and feel like I need to make a couple of comments and clarifications. This one got real long but bear with me
First at OP's original post: I'm sorry to hear that you had to go through that phase. I have to say that I can see your frustration with the hardness of the material, but disagree with multiple other things you said. I hope whatever was the reason for your apology, you're doing ok now and will approach us for help whenever you need it. Whether or not our class has gunners will depend on how you define that, but I have not been denied help or material by anyone in the class and have not seen anyone trying to "screw" others either. As far as Sci Meth goes, I have to say there are quite a few students in the class who agree with you about why we even need to learn this stuff. I have to say I have a mixed feeling about this class. I think it's important for us to learn the material, but I think it could be taught better. I think it's part of dentistry that may not be so obvious but something we should definitely be able to tackle down the road when some product promoter comes knocking down on the office door and tries to sell us a product. How can we tell BS from the good stuff if we can't understand the research they've done?
To the predent students who are reading this forum and would like to know more about the D1 environment. If you think dental school will be easy, you're up for a (not-so-)sweet surprise. No one said it was going to be easy, and if they did they had no idea what they were talking about. Our first year is also infamous for being the harder year of the 4 years at UCSF, although I'm sure whatever the reason for that is, it's not to "weed out" students. The school looses about 60-70k pear year for a student who drops out. So weeding students out besides being the wrong thing to do, would be a dumb economical decision. In fact, the whole application and interview process is to make sure that you don't drop out. That being said, we have had extremely well support from our upperclassmen with notes, mock exams, review sessions, etc. The notes taken by upperclassmen along with many other review materials and more are on a dropbox folder which every student in the class has access to. There are many times that people email out review sheets that they've made before quizzes or exams without even being asked to do so. And I think we owe a good portion of this collaborative environment to the fact that the curriculum is P/F. I cannot recommend a P/F system highly enough. I never realized how good it is until being in one. In my opinion, because of that, there are no students trying to screw others and it makes for a much better learning environment where everyone is trying to help each other. I have friends in other dental programs still going by the ABC system (which you may think of as less competitive) and can see the stress level that they have. They are extremely stressed and some have already given up on specializing because they can't get all As to rank so high. I can't even think of the amount of stress I would have if I had to have that "I need an A" mindset. One last thing, UCSF has this name of being a "research school," and I remember being a pre-dent there were many misunderstandings of that. There are ABSOLUTELY ZERO research requirements. If you don't like research, you can go on the 4 years without doing a second of it. The school merely provides many opportunities for you to be able to do research considering that it receives the most research funding every year, but if you don't want it, don't touch it. Bottom line, I feel extremely lucky to have such great classmates and faculty and to be at a great program like UCSF. There's no other dental school I'd rather be at.
To some of the posts above, as far as I know, the students in the class don't even know who the OP is to be able to pressure him/her to apologize or anything of that matter. So maybe you should seek some more facts before you point your fingers and call us idealists or say that we even pressured the OP in the first place.
Lastly to our fellow D2, "playa....", I don't see how the two D1s that posted before me blamed anyone for their beliefs. They also have the right to their own opinion just like the OP. They mentioned why they disagree with the OP's post and offered him/her help, which is really all that can be done on this forum anyway.