You know, you could actually just use the internet to look something like this up.
27 states where CRNAs can practice independently
There are literally 27 states as of 2017 that CRNAs can practice without supervision. That doesn't mean practice in a hospital without supervision. It means practice without supervision period.
You fail to mention what a DA can do that a CRNA can't.
And if patients/insurances/hospitals see DAs as being on par with MDs/DOs then why don't DAs typically work in hospitals and do general anesthesia cases for total knee replacements?
The argument stands, you don't do anything that others can already do. If you have 3 years of
hospital based training on anesthesia, then how are you superior to others in an ambulatory setting? If you can feel comfortable doing anesthesia in an ambulatory setting, then I would bet that someone with more medical training and more training overall would also feel comfortable doing so.
Furthermore, dentists doing IV sedation and/or oral sedation isn't the same as general anesthesia obviously. However, it is another option for anxiolysis for anxious patients. It is a different method to achieve similar results. And thus, in a very real way general dentists doing such are also competing with you for patients.
Jeez... Not sure why you are being so disrespectful to an entire profession you have no exposure towards? Either way, I will take the time to reply for the many generations of dental students/dentists who will read this forum.
1. I'm glad your google searching has gotten you this far in life, but you are again wrong. Your reference outlines 27 states where the National Council of State Boards of Nursing has stated where CRNAs have permission to practice independently. However, the
STATE BOARD OF NURSING does not ultimately regulate who can perform general anesthesia in a DENTAL OFFICE. This is determined by the respective state board of DENTISTRY.
For example, the state of Delaware is listed on that website. However if you look the legislative requirements for an unrestricted GA permit under section 7.3.2.1 of Title 24 legislated by the State Dental board of Delaware it says:
7.3.2.1 Has completed a minimum of two years of advanced training in anesthesiology and related academic subjects (or its equivalent) beyond the undergraduate dental school level in a training program as described in Part II of the Guidelines for Teaching the Comprehensive Control of Pain and Anxiety in Dentistry or, is a Diplomat of the American Board of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons, or has satisfactorily completed a residency in Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery at an institution approved by the Council of Dental Education, American Dental Association, or is a fellow of the American Dental Society of Anesthesiology. A certified registered nurse anesthetist may be utilized for deep sedation or general anesthesia only if the dentist also possesses an Unrestricted Permit.
Thus, there are much less than 27 states where a CRNAs can truly practice independently without being under another anesthesia provider's license.
2. With that being said, I do not mean to discredit CRNAs. I have met many very competent CRNAs, and in our program they are trained by Dental Anesthesiology attendings as well. Sure, you can hire a CRNA to do the same thing we do. However, some benefits of having a DA over a CRNA are:
a) depending on state, a CRNA can not work without supervision by a Dental or Medical Anesthesiologist/OMFS in dental offices
b) We can still perform dental procedures and sedate our own patients, as long as we have sufficient auxillary personnel.
d) We receive months of off-service training with full-time Dental Anesthesiologists to learn how to set-up and run cases in a mobile provider setting.
d) Our dental background allows us to understand the procedures being performed, and helps you as the provider more than you would think.
e) Insurance: Easier to bill dental insurance/medicaid for anesthesia procedures as Dentists
3. You said
"if patients/insurances/hospitals see DAs as being on par with MDs/DOs then why don't DAs typically work in hospitals and do general anesthesia cases for total knee replacements?"
- How about you go ask your OMFS program director why he/she isn't running anesthesia cases for knee replacements... Both OMFS and DAs get experience in all types of anesthesia cases (including knee replacements), but thats not our specialty and not our game once out in practice. Lastly, I never said we are trying to do everything MDs do in a hospital once in practice. Yes, MDs have more medical knowledge that helps them for what they need to do in a hospital. Our 3 years of training prepares us well for what we need to do in a dental office.
4. You said
"If you have 3 years of hospital based training on anesthesia, then how are you superior to others in an ambulatory setting?
- We also have months of off-service rotations within the 3 year training period where we get trained in providing mobile dental anesthesia
5. You said "
I would bet that someone with more medical training and more training overall would also feel comfortable doing so."
- You'd be surprised..ask an average Anesthesiologist to intubate, paralyze, manage a ventilator, manage intra-operative vitals, all in a crammed dental office, and then discharge a patient within 20 minutes after the procedure, with no PACU and no one to help them out...you'd be hard pressed to find one willing to do so outside of a hospital lol. Again, I highly recommend shadowing a DA to really learn what we do.
6. "
It is a different method to achieve similar results. And thus, in a very real way general dentists doing such are also competing with you for patients."
- Wrong, wrong, wrong. The patients we treat are usually not candidates for IV moderate sedation. IV moderate sedation isn't a magical thing that works for everyone, and it definitely does not produce 'similar results' as general anesthesia. If we get called in, the dentist has already considered and excluded it as an option. And I can guarantee you there aren't any DAs struggling to find work because of dentists doing IV sedation...