Nov 13, 2012
37
0
Status
Pre-Medical
At a MD school interview last week, the interviewer asked me:

"how much do you think primary care docs earn?"

followed by

"how much do you think a cardiothoracic surgeon earns?"

Any guesses on why he would ask me this? Perhaps I came across as a money-grubbing/ in it for the benjamins-type applicant. But still so weird...

I was pretty confident with my answers, which I'm now thinking might have hurt me.

Is physician salary not a fairly well-known topic among pre-meds who have spent the past 4 years working toward medical school? I'm not saying we're doing it for the money, but like any other opportunity cost we're making a decision about our future where salary must factor in at some level...
 
Last edited:

PreMedOrDead

I'm sure you'll get in...
5+ Year Member
May 19, 2012
2,377
240
A dark, dark cave
Status
Actually sounds like a pretty good question. Judges both your understanding of the career (necessary to know what you're getting yourself into) and your motivation for the career.

Depends, did you say $150,000 and $300,000 or did you say $176,690 and $407,539?

Former is a reasonable understanding of the career and why you're going into it (stability and compensation ought to be at least a small part of choosing the career), the latter is $.$
 
OP
slothster
Nov 13, 2012
37
0
Status
Pre-Medical
Actually sounds like a pretty good question. Judges both your understanding of the career (necessary to know what you're getting yourself into) and your motivation for the career.

Depends, did you say $150,000 and $300,000 or did you say $176,690 and $407,539?

Former is a reasonable understanding of the career and why you're going into it (stability and compensation ought to be at least a small part of choosing the career), the latter is $.$
Ha!

I think I said "$100-150K" for primary care and "$350-400K" for the surgeon.

Maybe it was my lack of accuracy that led to the rejection.
 

steackncheese

Removed
Dec 26, 2012
19
0
Status
A lot of people pretend to be interested in primary care for application season. If I am ever a student interviewer in the future, I am going to ask this question with the follow-up question "Now why would anybody want to be a primary care doctor?" I'm sure most people would have a prepared answer triumphing the merits of primary care, but hopefully it could get a few people to squirm :smuggrin:

Primary care docs should make more money and get more kudos for how uniquely difficult their job is. A lot of the blame falls on the 'top' schools for the negative stigma they attach to primary care.
 

PreMedOrDead

I'm sure you'll get in...
5+ Year Member
May 19, 2012
2,377
240
A dark, dark cave
Status
Ha!

I think I said "$100-150K" for primary care and "$350-400K" for the surgeon.

Maybe it was my lack of accuracy that led to the rejection.
Rarely, I would assume, does a rejection come down to a single response in an interview...
 

MedPR

Removed
Dec 1, 2011
18,581
44
Status
Pre-Podiatry
Ha!

I think I said "$100-150K" for primary care and "$350-400K" for the surgeon.

Maybe it was my lack of accuracy that led to the rejection.
Nah, the correct answer is "it depends on how many patients they see" :)
 

MedPR

Removed
Dec 1, 2011
18,581
44
Status
Pre-Podiatry
Rarely, I would assume, does a rejection come down to a single response in an interview...
Definitely. At one of the schools I was accepted to I answered the "why should we pick you?" question like this:

I've never been able to come up with a good answer for this question, but I guess it's because blah blah blah cliche cliche cliche.
 

BABSstudent

Established Member
7+ Year Member
Oct 29, 2011
3,576
539
Seattle
Status
Resident [Any Field]
My answer would have been that it depends on the area of the country, having their own practice versus being employed by someone else, etc.

But to be honest, one answer is not likely going to do you in unless you say your hobby is torturing babies.
 

gasblaster

ASA Member
5+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Feb 24, 2012
542
14
Status
Resident [Any Field]
Agree with the others. Depends on a lot of factors. One of the biggest would be academic vs private practice. Location of the country. Urban versus rural. Family practice, general internal medicine, peds, ob-gyn? But I think your answer isn't far off the mark as a generalization.
 

Cuongoff

7+ Year Member
Dec 28, 2011
636
60
Status
Resident [Any Field]
Agree with the others. Depends on a lot of factors. One of the biggest would be academic vs private practice. Location of the country. Urban versus rural. Family practice, general internal medicine, peds, ob-gyn? But I think your answer isn't far off the mark as a generalization.

This. Maybe it wasn't a question asking specifically for the salaries but a question aimed how your thought process works? Maybe I dig too deep into my interview questions but maybe they were looking for you to ask these questions. Rural or urban? Hospital or private? etc.
 
OP
slothster
Nov 13, 2012
37
0
Status
Pre-Medical
Thanks for the input, all. I guess I'm overanalyzing everything given the quick post-interview rejection.

I emailed admissions asking for feedback and got the generic "blah blah blah you're not a perfect fit with our mission," which leaves me wondering why I was deemed a fit pre-interview but not post...

I guess it's time to move on.

Thanks again.
 

mcloaf

7+ Year Member
Jan 21, 2012
5,176
4,648
Status
Resident [Any Field]
Thanks for the input, all. I guess I'm overanalyzing everything given the quick post-interview rejection.

I emailed admissions asking for feedback and got the generic "blah blah blah you're not a perfect fit with our mission," which leaves me wondering why I was deemed a fit pre-interview but not post...

I guess it's time to move on.

Thanks again.
Eh, just because somebody reviewing files for interview invites thought you might fit their mission doesn't mean the whole committee will necessarily agree.

Their loss. :oops:
 

Guero

2QT2Bcis Plaidapus
Moderator
7+ Year Member
Jan 20, 2010
5,303
456
Tropical Tropicana
forums.studentdoctor.net
Status
Resident [Any Field]