- Joined
- May 26, 2006
- Messages
- 1,404
- Reaction score
- 11
I was peeking at the official PS readers list over in the Pre-Allo forum and it occurred to me that it'd be nice if we had our own list.
What do you guys think? Would more of you volunteer to be readers if it were limited to reading personal statements from non-traditionals?
ETA: OK, it looks like there's enough interest to build a list. Can haz!
Here's what I've got so far based on the replies in this thread. Let me know if you want to be taken off or have other comments to add!
General guidelines:
1. Give your readers plenty of time. This is universal to all PS readers, but is even more relevant for non-traditionals who tend to have busier and complex lives.
2. It's good practice to PM them first to see if they have time/bandwidth to read your PS and give you feedback. Don't just pick someone off this list and send a PM bomb.
3. It's very helpful if you can tell someone what kind of feedback you are seeking: i.e. general commentary, grammar/spelling/structure, thematic advice, etc.
QofQuimica: Need I say more? We all know she's fabulous. Although, her fabulousness is limited in its time and scope of availability to us. Currently not accepting PS read requests but may again in the future.
riverjib: Has a journalism background and would happily help read/critique PS.
familyaerospace: "I've published several journal articles and presented at several conferences. Currently, I make my living as a copy editor for a science non-profit organization. I've copy edited probably 100 personal statements ranging from college to graduate school, several essays, grant proposals, and also for journals. Actually that should be updated. I read an ADDITIONAL 100 personal statements for medical school, so my eyes have been on something like 200 statements. (Feel sorry for me.)" Please, help save familyaerospace from having to read hundreds of insipid traditional statements!
Dianyla: I'm non-traditional myself and would happily give feedback. I am known for being brutally honest, if that's your bag.
MSmentor018: "taught medical/nursing students for years. frequently advise PS for non trads, esp those with military background. just completed and read 481 LOR's for a research project on their influence and descriptions on ERAS applications. feel free to PM, I'll help out you need it."
ArkansasRanger: will "read your PS and let you know if it seems like you're just spreading the cheese. " If you're lucky, he'll even turn it into a limerick!
LeFauconPelerin: "I'd be willing to read and critique a few PSs. I've got chops in re: writing and editing -- background as newspaper columnist and editor while in school; now in charge of workplace's newsletter; a handful of PSs of my own (not for med school) that earned me nationally competitive scholarships -- although I should also provide the caveat that I've no particular expertise in medschool PSs. i.e., think of me as a useful set of eyes, but not necessarily authoritative."
knightstale: "If there is still a need for personal statement readers for non-trads, I would be more than happy to offer my services . As for qualifications, I have been a writing consultant for four and a half years, and have Master Level III Certification. I have also taken a workshop on personal statements. I take a multi-dimensional approach to writing, so will be looking at everything from grammar to content and impact .
As a side note, I am also applying to medical school this year, but will be available throughout the year for consultations. PM me for my e-mail address."
Excelsius: "This is an excellent way to give back to the SDN community (other than donating, of course!). After I finish my exams and if my research is going well, I will also volunteer some time to read PSs. At such a time I will also post my credentials, but not before. I too think that this will be much safer to do in this forum than in pre-allo "
vc7777: "I'm free for the next week or so in June (2010) to read a couple more PSes for this cycle. I take a particular interest in nontrads with children, and would prefer to work with these SDN members in particular."
What do you guys think? Would more of you volunteer to be readers if it were limited to reading personal statements from non-traditionals?
ETA: OK, it looks like there's enough interest to build a list. Can haz!
Here's what I've got so far based on the replies in this thread. Let me know if you want to be taken off or have other comments to add!
General guidelines:
1. Give your readers plenty of time. This is universal to all PS readers, but is even more relevant for non-traditionals who tend to have busier and complex lives.
2. It's good practice to PM them first to see if they have time/bandwidth to read your PS and give you feedback. Don't just pick someone off this list and send a PM bomb.
3. It's very helpful if you can tell someone what kind of feedback you are seeking: i.e. general commentary, grammar/spelling/structure, thematic advice, etc.
QofQuimica: Need I say more? We all know she's fabulous. Although, her fabulousness is limited in its time and scope of availability to us. Currently not accepting PS read requests but may again in the future.
riverjib: Has a journalism background and would happily help read/critique PS.
familyaerospace: "I've published several journal articles and presented at several conferences. Currently, I make my living as a copy editor for a science non-profit organization. I've copy edited probably 100 personal statements ranging from college to graduate school, several essays, grant proposals, and also for journals. Actually that should be updated. I read an ADDITIONAL 100 personal statements for medical school, so my eyes have been on something like 200 statements. (Feel sorry for me.)" Please, help save familyaerospace from having to read hundreds of insipid traditional statements!
Dianyla: I'm non-traditional myself and would happily give feedback. I am known for being brutally honest, if that's your bag.
MSmentor018: "taught medical/nursing students for years. frequently advise PS for non trads, esp those with military background. just completed and read 481 LOR's for a research project on their influence and descriptions on ERAS applications. feel free to PM, I'll help out you need it."
ArkansasRanger: will "read your PS and let you know if it seems like you're just spreading the cheese. " If you're lucky, he'll even turn it into a limerick!
LeFauconPelerin: "I'd be willing to read and critique a few PSs. I've got chops in re: writing and editing -- background as newspaper columnist and editor while in school; now in charge of workplace's newsletter; a handful of PSs of my own (not for med school) that earned me nationally competitive scholarships -- although I should also provide the caveat that I've no particular expertise in medschool PSs. i.e., think of me as a useful set of eyes, but not necessarily authoritative."
knightstale: "If there is still a need for personal statement readers for non-trads, I would be more than happy to offer my services . As for qualifications, I have been a writing consultant for four and a half years, and have Master Level III Certification. I have also taken a workshop on personal statements. I take a multi-dimensional approach to writing, so will be looking at everything from grammar to content and impact .
As a side note, I am also applying to medical school this year, but will be available throughout the year for consultations. PM me for my e-mail address."
Excelsius: "This is an excellent way to give back to the SDN community (other than donating, of course!). After I finish my exams and if my research is going well, I will also volunteer some time to read PSs. At such a time I will also post my credentials, but not before. I too think that this will be much safer to do in this forum than in pre-allo "
vc7777: "I'm free for the next week or so in June (2010) to read a couple more PSes for this cycle. I take a particular interest in nontrads with children, and would prefer to work with these SDN members in particular."
Last edited: