Ok now that you guys seem to have a really good grasp of what goes into a good yellow pages ad I'll just briefly touch on a newspaper ad.
The exact same rules that apply to yellow page ads also apply to newsprint ads. But there are some important differences between the two that you need to consider:
1. Newspaper ads are stumbled upon while seeking something else in the paper. Yellow page ads are found because someone is deliberately seeking the service that you provide.
2. Newspaper ads are one shot. You may put the same ad in every day of the week but you still have one shot to catch the eye of the consumer who is not looking for you.
As I said before the fundamental difference between yellow page ad and newspaper ads is that newsprint ads are "stumbled upon" while someone is looking for someone else. It is important to remember that and to gear your ad to capitalize on this moment.
In the yellow pages you do not have to tell someone you are a dentist because they are in need of a dentist and therefore are looking in the "dentist" portion of the book. They know what you are because they need your services. So you let them know the things that make you the best choice for them.
With a newspaper ad what you are trying to get across is this "Hey my name is Dr. Hammer and I"m a DENTIST. I want your business so here's what I'm going to do for you!!
If is a very very subtle difference but with the phone book you are advertising the services that make you the best choice for someone seeking a dentist. With a newspaper ad you are letting people know that even though they might not need a dentist, they should come and see you anyway because you have something very special to give them. And that very special something is usually the two things that I like to call:
1. The Gift
2. The Hug
The Gift is when you run an ad because you are offering up something special like a free exam or bleaching at a reduced price. Or that you offer a very unique service like Invisalign or Saturday hours. You are wanting to let the people who are looking at your ad know that it is their lucky day and you are letting them in on a special deal that not everyone will be getting. You always need to present the "gift" as "hey I got something very nice to give you, just hop on down and pick it up" and not "hey I need patients so if you'll come to my office I'll give you something for nothing."
The Hug is basically taking the Gift out on the road. One year I gave the local High School a really really nice Mascot outfit (the were the Tigers). So the week leading up to the Friday night that I was to present it to the High School at a football game I ran an ad that said something like "Tiger Power" talked very briefly that I was giving the high school a Mascot outfit and made a big deal that I was going to shoot t-shirts out of a gun into the crowd like they do at the big sporting events.
The night came and I showed up in scrubs and a white coat. I strapped on a t-shirt cannon and any time there was a lull in the game I walked around shooting t-shirts at people. I had a bunch of cheap t-shirts printed up with a cool logo for their high school on the front and my office logo and info on the back. People loved it and for years after that people would always ask me about it.
When I open my new office in two weeks I am going to run an ad that invites everyone to my new office in Oak Ridge. What it is really saying however is "Hey any of you who were my patients and want to see me again, come on down" without violating my restrictive covenant.
Lastly here are just a few other considerations for print ads
1. Color is a must! Use bright colors like orange, yellow or pink for the best results. Also be sure to use a nice photo like one of a young person with perfect teeth smiling or a really good photo of you. When people are browsing through a hometown newspaper their eyes will be automatically drawn to any photos of people. Why? They are looking to see if it is anyone that they know. Don't believe me? Take a newspaper with some ads on it that also has photographs of people. Just give it to someone and say "Look at this page and tell me what the first two things that you look at are" The first two things will always be whatever is headlined on the page and the photos. Always.
2. If you are doing "the gift" make sure that you follow the name, map, contact information, we take insurance stuff that I talked about in the yellow page posts
3. If you are doing "the hug" emphasize the event more and if you are donating something you can't really play that up too much without looking like a scheming DB so be sure to do something in addition like giving away t-shirts so that you can really pound that message home.
4. Community specific newspapers (like papers in small towns or counties) are great and you will get maximum bang for your buck. Major city newspapers are at best a crapshoot and one that I would probably avoid.
5. Most importantly- make sure that if you are advertising in a small town or county newspaper that they put your ad IN THE SPORTS SECTION!! This is where everyone looks to see how the hometown team did. Everyone looks in that section to see if their little Johnny had his photo taking running in the winning touchdown and they will also see your ad. Run your ad on Monday and Friday. If you can only do one day make it Monday because that is when the Friday sports will be featured.
6. If you are going to run an ad that isn't during the school year I would run it only on Monday in the front page section and do it for at least 6 weeks.
Next post the all important and often overlooked "Internal Marketing"