I am interested in epi and have been admitted to the MPH Epidemiology w Global Health Certificate in Columbia and the MSPH Global Disease Epi Control in Johns Hopkins. Although we're in different departments, I have been having the exact same thoughts/conflicts as you! I would also like to get into industry, especially right after graduating(will consider PHD later) and definitely would rather be/work in NYC than Baltimore. I unfortunately can't make it to admitted students day so please let me know what you think! I have visited the area and it's wonderful and diverse. I've also heard back from a professor regarding research opp. in Columbia, which is great(NYC has many research opportunities). But, as you said, it's difficult turning down Hopkins the #1 name in public health. I know it's incredible for research and the professors and students are doing amazing projects(esp globally). I've also heard Hopkins is very aggressive and rigorous(as expected), although I don't expect Columbia to be much different... Decisions, decisions!
I am deciding between these two programs right now! I made a spreadsheet (edited from someone from this forum actually), went to admitted students day (If you could not make it, try to email/call students - I've been doing that also), and I am meeting alumni both for one-on-one conversation and at the school's reception in my city.
If you would rather be/work in NYC than Baltimore than Columbia would definitely be a better option. Personally, I love Baltimore and plan to stay in D.C. area after graduation so Hopkins seems to be a better choice. My note below will be biased - anyone who is leaning toward Columbia please chime in:
- About practicum abroad: If you decide to do the 6-month practicum at Columbia, you basically will miss out a semester of class while still pay for full tuition. For Hopkins, tuition is 75% off second year and you potentially can still take class online while you are abroad (depends on if the courses are offered online and if the country has reliable internet).
- About Cohort size: For MPH Epidemiology, your cohort will have 120 people. For MSPH GDEC, you will be with about 25 people. However, Columbia also tries to break down the cohort into smaller size by having all first-year students taking a cases-based, leadership class that only have 20 people from all departments - this will be your main "cohort."
- About network: my impression is that with international health, Hopkins itself has a more extensive network, established fieldwork all around the world. Columbia still has a very strong connection and can still help connect you to the right people though.
- About coursework: Epi training will be the same for both schools, Hopkins teaches Stata, Columbia teaches SAS. For Columbia, you will take electives based on your certificate - for Hopkins, you can take any electives your want for second year.
Anyhow, students from both schools have a lot of positive things to say about their programs and some concrete criticism too. Both are excellent choices so it all depends on what is important to you :-D