Hi all,
This post is for me and about 10 other Navy HPSP D4 students at my school. We are all leaning towards Credentialing Tours, but want your opinion. We know this topic has been discussed in some older threads, and have seen opinions going both ways. We know that programs change with time, and that everybody has different experiences. So we wanted to see what the current opinion is of a Navy AEGD vs Navy Credentialing Tour. (Our end goal is to be private practice GPs).
If you comment on your experience, we would really appreciate that! We know many of you have given valuable insight in other posts (thank you for that!), but it would be great to have it all in one place. Any and all advice is welcome! Thank you!
Which school are you at? I'm mildly surprised that any school has 10-11 current D4 Navy students since the numbers of scholarships have gone down in recent years. I know my school had about 10 that graduated the year after I graduated, but they were recruited during the height of the war.
Also, are you sure that all of the students intend to go private practice GP? If any of them have an interest in specialty then we may want to add GPR programs into the mix. Additionally, you may want to consider adding the Comprehensive Dentistry program into the mix, although it does incur an extra year of training (but no extra years of payback) versus the AEGD.
Considering the question as you posed it:
The AEGD offers you a certificate that may be used for licensure in certain states; this may be an advantage for those who are looking to practice in those states following the end of their service.
The AEGD also brings you out to 5 years of total active duty service. In most states, this will qualify you for licensure by credential. It is important to note that there are many states that will no longer accept your NERB/SRTA/WREB or other licensing examination once five years have passed. Since most schools take their licensing examinations in winter to spring of the fourth year, this means that by the end of your 4+1 years of service you will no longer be eligible for licensure by examination, so you'll want to review your options for licensure before you separate to ensure that the state will allow licensure by credential.
If you do a credentialing tour and separate at 4 years service, you may not qualify for licensure by credential and will need to ensure that you can still obtain a license by examination in your destination state.
The AEGD offers a structured didactic and clinical experience, the requirements of which you can find in the accreditation standards for that program. You will gain structured experience in the areas of periodontics, prosthodontics (although the removable prosth experience will be low at any Navy facility), endodontics, and oral/maxillofacial surgery. You may have good exposure to other specialties depending on your location - those programs located at or near the largest facilities (Naval Medical Center San Diego, Naval Medical Center Portsmouth, Naval Postgraduate Dental School) will have the most exposure to the other specialties like Path, Radiology, Ortho, and Pedo. You will also gain something like 200-250 hours of CE that can be used for your licensure renewal as well as credit towards AGD status.
The credentialing tour will vary by location. If you end up at Great Lakes, MCRD San Diego, or MCRD Parris Island, you should get some very good experience in operative and exodontia and structured exposure to the other major specialties (prosth, endo, perio), as these facilities are very used to receiving large numbers of credentialing dentists. However, at other locations, it will depend on specialist availability and mission requirements - if they need you doing exams and operative and can't spare you to do elective rotations, then you may not be able to get specialty experience. Speaking from experience, at one of my past duty stations we had several credentialing tour dentists that were not able to get any exodontia experience through their three year tours and only got limited endodontic experience. We were able to change that as specialists and leadership rotated out and new specialists very open to teaching came in, but more importantly we were able to get them rotations because the rest of the providers were able to handle the primary mission of keeping the personnel dentally ready. Your experience in a credentialing tour will depend on your location, your leadership, and the providers and specialists you work with (the AEGD will also be highly influenced by the leadership and PD). I know dentists who had great credentialing tours and I know dentists who left the Navy because of poor ones. I also know those who had good PGY-1 experiences and bad as well.
Please let me know if you have any more questions.