Does anyone know that stats on how many non-Canadian internationals matriculate into US medical schools?
The data here shows that 97/1195 internationals matriculated into US medical schools, for a matriculation rate of 8% in the 2018-2019 cycle. But how many of these would be Canadians, who have an advantage over non-Canadians?
Information for international applicants who want to apply to U.S. medical schools.
students-residents.aamc.org
The data here (also from the AAMC) says "In the 2017 AMCAS application cycle, 1,933 foreign applicants applied to M.D. granting programs in the United States and 350 of those applicants were accepted. Of those accepted, 274 matriculated into medical school." which is different to the data in the table. Any reason why that might be the case?
Around or less than 10% acceptance rate for internationals sounds like a right number to me. There is a difference between Canadians and non-Canadian internationals. I don't know the acceptance rate per se, but it is reasonable to think that it is more difficult for non-Canadian internationals for several reasons.
The school systems of Canada and US are similar enough, so med schools have a better idea what educational background a Canadian applicant has compared to other internationals.
Plus lots of non-Canadian internationals did not come from English-speaking countries and do not use English as their first language, so being from Canada pretty much guarantees the English proficiency at least. It is definitely an advantage in interviews to speak good English.
Additionally, there are med schools that take Canadians but not other internationals, so Canadian applicants have a larger number of schools they can apply. And even for schools which say that they take both Canadian and non-Canadian internationals, it is hard to say whether there is a preference or not.
Therefore I don't think med schools prefer Canadians over non-Canadian internationals per se. It is just that Canadians have a larger number of schools to apply to and possible better English writing and interview skills. That is what puts Canadians to a better position than the rest of international applicants.
Also from my experience (so please take it with a grain of salt) -- my Canadian friends hear back earlier than me from schools even they submit their secondaries later than me.
So my own observation/conclusion is that for non-Canadian applicants, the top tier schools are usually the most friendly ones, plus some New York Schools (not sure why, but it is what I noticed from scrolling down MSAR). The mid-tier schools mostly are state schools that consider only a small number of OOS applicants, not to mention internationals. There is really no safety schools.