sf1991 said:
hello all, first time logging onto this thread. i interviewed back on nov 7th and was accepted dec 22nd. i am totally thrilled at the prospect of being part of the class of 2010 at psucom (i live in san francisco but grew up in pittsburgh), but i haven't made my final decision yet. i was just waitlisted at stanford (that was my first choice), and now i have to decide between my two acceptances psucom and nymc. i loved both their campuses and curriculums, also like that they are both in more rural areas. for psu, i like the msr (i think it will help with applying for residency), i also like that the trauma center/hospital are right there, has a regional cancer center, known for cardiology, great fitness facilities, smaller class size. nymc has new anatomy lab/class faclilities, next to nyc, i think the clinical exposure would be more diverse, plus they prep you well for the boards and match well. plus my wife is a nurse and i think she would have more career opportunities in nyc. my heart says psu (i really am proud to be accepted there), but i am a mountain of indecision. any feedback would be greatly appreciated. i think we are going to fly back and tour the campus again and visit harrisburg. thanks for any input, and maybe i'll be seeing you in a few months.
I'm also married and have chosen PSU as the best place to go (of my acceptances) for BOTH of us. NYMC will end up being SUPER expensive b/c of cost of living and the fact that most will be better off moving to NYC for 3rd and 4th year (although many do commute from Westchester). NYC has ample job opps for pretty much any career and the pay seems pretty good until you start looking into living expenses (but being from SF, you should be used to that). However, if you and you're wife are really keen on the access to NYC, then certainly NYMC is probably better. It's a very different demographic that you'd be caring for all around Westchester and NYC. Of course, away rotations will cover anything you might miss at either school.
About PSU-- have you looked at some of the openings for nursing at Hershey med center and also the other area hospitals? They are abundant and pay pretty well for the area's cost of living.
My suggestions for choosing PSU vs NYMC:
1. Look at what specialty you think you are most interested in and check how each school matches (no pun intended) with that-- look at the faculty, the size of the department, any labs they might have, clinical research or centers, the match list for the past ~3-5 years, etc.
2. Check out housing and job opps WITH your wife (I doubt she'll have a problem finding one as a nurse!). All things being equal with the schools, you can even let her be the deciding factor. You both have to be happy b/c she'll be your support structure for the next 4 years (and beyond).
3. Check out general way of life, culture, etc of the surrounding for each school. If you're used to SF, then Central PA will be a bit of a culture shock. Very few (good) ethnic restaurants and not a very diverse population in general. HBurg is trying to get there, but you do have Philly, Baltimore, DC, and New York in driving distance for a weekend getaway. Again, you should both be cool with it.
4. You didn't mention kids (or the prospect of having them)... but it could also be a factor if you check out the schools, too. I am not caught up with schools in Valhalla or White Plains (think White Plains is not as nice, though), but I can say that the schools in Hershey are very good. In PA, people pay taxes that go specifically to the schools and you can kind of tell by the area you would live in (how much that tax is), how good the schools will be. Hershey is upper-middle class and has good schools... other surrounding towns are pretty good, too (E-town, etc). I think the HBurg city schools are not so hot, though.
Hope this helps. If you have any PA questions, you can PM me. Good luck on your decision (and Stanford!)... I know how tough it can be when you have to factor in more than just yourself!
