Reverse WW - Game Thread

[WildZoo]

---

Members don't see this ad.

1) Don't really think we should be using activity to determine affiliation.
2) Plenty of wolves have ghosted before, or gotten busy, or whatever. They may not even have realized they weren't reaching the requirement (both cubs and nav seemed to indicate as much)
3) Vote for them if you truly think they are the most village, but don't do it just because they can't vote. That won't matter if we accidentally end the game today.

 

[dolphin106258]

ask midwife ig
but better safe than sorry
i'd call it angleshooting but her definition can differ from mine

...I’m gonna come back to this game when I’m less annoyed.

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

...I’m gonna come back to this game when I’m less annoyed.

why are you annoyed??

 

[Animal Midwife]

Official Day 5 Emergency Lynch Tally
cubs (1) - Frosty
Nav (1) - FTF

2/8
lynch close in ~23.5 hours

 

[WildZoo]

Also, idk what is up with acanth right now but I don't for a second believe there is a seer in this game, and if there is one i don't for a millisecond believe he is it.

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

Also, idk what is up with acanth right now but I don't for a second believe there is a seer in this game, and if there is one i don't for a millisecond believe he is it.

so you already think it's a fakeclaim
do you think he's villager or wolf because of it

 

[WildZoo]

so you already think it's a fakeclaim
do you think he's villager or wolf because of it

I haven't decided yet. Depends on wolf numbers I think and we're right at the border of 4 or 5 based on normal game ratios.

+/- the possibility of third party I guess

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

I haven't decided yet. Depends on wolf numbers I think and we're right at the border of 4 or 5 based on normal game ratios.

+/- the possibility of third party I guess

i think we're at 4 wolves total
This game comes months after Animal Midwife got readded to MU Staff
except the second time around her role changed from updating the database to being a Game Manager in training
meaning she's learning from all the MU Game designers on how to balance games
She's definitely subscribing to MU schools of thought, with all the intellectual discourse and scholarly articles
meaning that I'm thinking she's adhering to MU convention and if you want your ev's to be anywhere near balanced in a setup like this, you have 4 wolves, maximum 1 3p
and if im right about the suspected 3p wincon possibly being against the grain here, the last wolf lynch ends the game

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

if you couldnt tell yes i was saving that post for a while

 

[WildZoo]

I had no idea AM was so heavily involved on MU 😱

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

I had no idea AM was so heavily involved on MU 😱

yeah they love her there

 

[cubsrule4e]

I’m pretty sure every vote on the pip wagon is village

I agree, she played to our emotions to get the lynch, similar to what grebes is trying to pull now

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

I agree, she played to our emotions to get the lynch, similar to what grebes is trying to pull now

so if you don't like the grebes lynch
do you think the seer claim has credence or not?

 

[cubsrule4e]

so if you don't like the grebes lynch
do you think the seer claim has credence or not?

Not buying it at all, so I’d save grebes and acanth for last

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

Not buying it at all, so I’d save grebes and acanth for last

so you think they're w/v?
care to elaborate?

 

[Barkley13]

dont like this post
i think the refusal to come to a logical conclusion here makes the post feel agenda driven

What logical conclusion are you talking about?

 

[cubsrule4e]

so you think they're w/v?
care to elaborate?

I thought they were w/w and still could be. Their interactions have been weird AF. If I had to pick only one for wolf I’d say grebes

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

What logical conclusion are you talking about?

i think you've dodged both issues that you talked about in that post and settled on offering some minimal thought wrthem

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

I thought they were w/w and still could be. Their interactions have been weird AF. If I had to pick only one for wolf I’d say grebes

oh huhhhhhh
so you think it isnt 4 wolves
why

 

[Barkley13]

i think you've dodged both issues that you talked about in that post and settled on offering some minimal thought wrthem

What
I don’t think acanthy is a villager so we shouldn’t lynch him
I think both the kills were the same person and probably a third party
How is that dodging anything

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

Okay, this is a wonderful set up for me. I am a vanillager. Aka, if rules are how I think they should work, y’all should lynch me. Double beneficial effect there. Also.... I hope wolves can’t kill wolves as that is an instant game over wolf win

found this post while reading
makes me scratch my head a LOT

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

What
I don’t think acanthy is a villager so we shouldn’t lynch him
I think both the kills were the same person and probably a third party
How is that dodging anything

because from tone these thoughts look reluctant
possible retroactive
as if you were possibly building towards saying these things instead of outright thinking them

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

So who wants to talk about what lylo and MYLO mean in this game? 😀

another weird bit here
idk if the dude talking about getting lynched early would be thinking about xylophone situations
but that's nai ultimately i think

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

*********lynch genny*********

I feel like pippy, FTF, and MJ should be addressed at end game.

err huhh uhh huhh hehhhh

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

yeah nav is sketch
just reached the part where he flipped that read
off the table for the day
new solution required
flush.exe has stopped responding
unvote navilly

 

[deleted867257]

this game got significantly more difficult since we're down to 1 wolf

Where was it mentioned that there’s only 4 wolves? Or is that an assumption on game player part?
I’m not trusting that there’s only 1 left, if we assume that then it’ll be easier for those alive to gather village into a wolfy lynch.

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

Where was it mentioned that there’s only 4 wolves? Or is that an assumption on game player part?
I’m not trusting that there’s only 1 left, if we assume that then it’ll be easier for those alive to gather village into a wolfy lynch.

assuming 4 for aforementioned reasons

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

i think we're at 4 wolves total
This game comes months after Animal Midwife got readded to MU Staff
except the second time around her role changed from updating the database to being a Game Manager in training
meaning she's learning from all the MU Game designers on how to balance games
She's definitely subscribing to MU schools of thought, with all the intellectual discourse and scholarly articles
meaning that I'm thinking she's adhering to MU convention and if you want your ev's to be anywhere near balanced in a setup like this, you have 4 wolves, maximum 1 3p
and if im right about the suspected 3p wincon possibly being against the grain here, the last wolf lynch ends the game

@FrostySparrow

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

I’m still convinced that acanth is very wolfy. If anyone has a PR (not asking you to out yourself or anything, just putting this out there) and wants to look into that I have very strong feelings there.

.-.
what a world

 

[acanthuroidei]

.-.
what a world

You can't say grebes didn't ask for it.... ‍♀️

 

[deleted867257]

so the job for RIGHT NOW
is to not throw your vote willy nilly since for every single lynch moving forward
the game can be lost

so tell me if you agree with
-grebes and acan being v/v
-nav being a better lynch candidate than cubs

and also be prepared to discuss
-other strong village reads that need to be lynched
-the possible need for a plan for getting both cubs and nav safely out of the game considering that we in all likelihood won't get a f3

**unlynch cubs**

I’ll have to put a lynch at lunchtime tomorrow at the latest since I get off work at lunch close. So I’m hoping we can pull together for a general consensus by then. Since we have so few voters now your point above makes sense.

Idk Pippy had said several times I legit am not gonna be able to play so please kill me before this day. I thought it was a safe bet Bc I didn’t think she’d do that as a wolf. But whatevs that’s a whole different debate on ethical arguments in this game. Plus people will very easily jump on to an easy vote early especially D1 where there is less to go on even in an extended cycle. Nav is 100% not getting a vote from me. He did the same thing as Pippy at the beginning of the game and acted all weird. I’m not gonna vote there.

This was my thought with Pippy and imo she didn’t seem ww at the time. I didn’t think the I need death card would be used for a ww advantage like it was.

You think cubs would let himself get restricted from lack of posting and be a wolf???

Okay well my point still stands it wouldn’t be in the best interest of a nonoutted wolf to do that.

I see the point being made here, but could also be argued that it’d allow a ww to slide under the radar a bit easier because they’re on voting restriction. They can offer a contribution to some extent, but no actual voting necessary and no vote patterns to analyze. So I wouldn’t necessarily use this to say ww vs village.

i think we're at 4 wolves total
This game comes months after Animal Midwife got readded to MU Staff
except the second time around her role changed from updating the database to being a Game Manager in training
meaning she's learning from all the MU Game designers on how to balance games
She's definitely subscribing to MU schools of thought, with all the intellectual discourse and scholarly articles
meaning that I'm thinking she's adhering to MU convention and if you want your ev's to be anywhere near balanced in a setup like this, you have 4 wolves, maximum 1 3p
and if im right about the suspected 3p wincon possibly being against the grain here, the last wolf lynch ends the game

So sorry! Just caught up on this here. I see it now.

 

[grebes4lyfe]

Aight cool well I’m just gonna peace out of this game then.

I’m vanillager but apparently acanth’s seer claim
Is believable to y’all so you can see that I’m telling the truth whenever endgame is here and I get revealed as vanillager.

Not gonna post anymore this game since it doesn’t seem to matter

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

Aight cool well I’m just gonna peace out of this game then.

I’m vanillager but apparently acanth’s seer claim
Is believable to y’all so you can see that I’m telling the truth whenever endgame is here and I get revealed as vanillager.

Not gonna post anymore this game since it doesn’t seem to matter

who the **** said any of that

 

[grebes4lyfe]

Also since quotes are allowed here is my role PM:

I’m John sevier Austin

This man can both sing and talk backwards flawlessly. You are a vanillager.

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

BRO

 

[deleted867257]

What just happened here?

 

[grebes4lyfe]

What just happened here?

I drunk rage quit #noragretz

But actually I’m over trying to defend myself against acanth I have better **** to do like packing and moving across the country

Rooting for village but y’all are making it hard

 

[Navilly]

Does everyone not realize that miz was u turn, was killed on a night, and magically a wolf died at the same time. She was a bomb role. Or so I think anyway

 

[Navilly]

I drunk rage quit #noragretz

But actually I’m over trying to defend myself against acanth I have better **** to do like packing and moving across the country

Rooting for village but y’all are making it hard

Given that I have said it’s most likely acanth, as have others, not sure where the overreactions have come from?

 

[Navilly]

Also in a game this size we are at 1 wolf. And it’s between acanth and grebes lynch literally anyone else

 

[grebes4lyfe]

Also in a game this size we are at 1 wolf. And it’s between acanth and grebes lynch literally anyone else

This is kind of my point.

Nothing I say is likely to get you guys to lynch me at this point. And like I said, I’m packing, moving and leaving town in the next few days and don’t really have the time or desire to try and convince y’all otherwise. so I’m out.

 

[Navilly]

This is kind of my point.

Nothing I say is likely to get you guys to lynch me at this point. And like I said, I’m packing, moving and leaving town in the next few days and don’t really have the time or desire to try and convince y’all otherwise. so I’m out.

Yeah but if you are village and you don’t talk at all, you forfeit the game. As your vote won’t matter at the end. Literally do 5 gibberish posts to appease the mods, who are more worried about quantity than quality

 

[Barkley13]

Does everyone not realize that miz was u turn, was killed on a night, and magically a wolf died at the same time. She was a bomb role. Or so I think anyway

So do you think the wolves had an extra kill and had to use it then? Because why else would they

 

[grebes4lyfe]

Sorry guys was a little drunk and reactive last night.

I won’t rage quit but I’m also not gonna try very hard and if I’m still alive after Wednesday I actually won’t be around to play since I’ll be on vacation with my family and then I start driving.

I was kinda pissed that, even though I clearly laid that out earlier in the day and explicitly said that I do NOT want to go to endgame, that still became the plan.

I also just don’t enjoy being trolled by acanth and it pissed me off.

It’s my last day of work today so I probably won’t be on v much, if at all, today, including for lynch close.

###lynch dubz###

Because that was my instinct yesterday AM so I’ll just follow my gut

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

and we're back

 

[WildZoo]

So do you think the wolves had an extra kill and had to use it then? Because why else would they

Eh I think he's saying MJ was doing the kill and miz was a bomb so he died. I'm not sure how I feel about that theory.

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

just gonna forget last night ever happened tbh

 

[WildZoo]

I guess I'm not sure how I feel about anything currently. I don't know how this game would be balanced so I don't know if I should believe there even are PRs.

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

so
acanth grebes
cubs nav
dubz
dolphin allieh frosty
and barks

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

Also in a game this size we are at 1 wolf. And it’s between acanth and grebes lynch literally anyone else

yeah this is problematic if
1) you think they're v/v
2)see above