Soccer WW - Match thread!

Started by ziggyandjazzy
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Browse articles Compare schools My application plan Read Interview Feedback
Practice for interviews Ask an Advisor
mypetmoose said:
I have thought of this, but it just feels off. @everyone, I haven't shared the full details of my role yet, but I also don't think anyone benefits from me doing so... let me know what you think...

@BigCats
@Sunbodi

You both said "it didn't line up". I still think SAR is sketchy AF and this doesn't make sense to me, but I'd like to know what part ticked you off
Click to expand...
SAR's been acting weird all game, I was willing to buy the odd night protector thing with no counterclaim, but I'm not buying it if there's an every night protector already present. Claiming to protect genny N1 (who said she didn't receive any notifications) when at least from some of the spreadsheets I've read, you get a notice if you'd been protected. Claiming to protect Sunbodi N3, who got a yellow card last night, which is definitely something I feel like a protector should be able to defend against. Just all around didn't line up.
 
forums.studentdoctor.net

Soccer WW - Match thread!

Ok here are my thoughts on the last couple of pages of thread. I’m betting we have 2-3 wolves left, maybe 4 if we started with 5 and there was a conversion. I feel much better about mpm today than I did yesterday. Especially after her explanation of everything. I’m also not so much leaning...
forums.studentdoctor.net forums.studentdoctor.net

mypetmoose said:
I have thought of this, but it just feels off. @everyone, I haven't shared the full details of my role yet, but I also don't think anyone benefits from me doing so... let me know what you think...

@BigCats
@Sunbodi

You both said "it didn't line up". I still think SAR is sketchy AF and this doesn't make sense to me, but I'd like to know what part ticked you off
Click to expand...
 
BigCats said:
SAR's been acting weird all game, I was willing to buy the odd night protector thing with no counterclaim, but I'm not buying it if there's an every night protector already present. Claiming to protect genny N1 (who said she didn't receive any notifications) when at least from some of the spreadsheets I've read, you get a notice if you'd been protected. Claiming to protect Sunbodi N3, who got a yellow card last night, which is definitely something I feel like a protector should be able to defend against. Just all around didn't line up.
Click to expand...

My role says something along the lines of (paraphrasing is hard) that I only stop goals, not penalties. So I'm pretty sure I can't stop blocks
 
mizchiefmanaged said:
This is a bad idea. This outs remaining PRs for a small chance of vengeful wolf.
Click to expand...
That's why I'm not asking just PRs to remove their votes. I'm asking ~everyone~ who hasn't already claimed vanillager or used-up power to remove their votes. If everyone does it, then there's plenty of plausible deniability- did they take their vote off because they were a PR or a vanillager? The three of us have already outed ourselves on thread. Wolves won't gain any new info by that.
 
HRH Queeb SAR said:
My role says something along the lines of (paraphrasing is hard) that I only stop goals, not penalties. So I'm pretty sure I can't stop blocks
Click to expand...
So since you're a villager and we already have 1 protector alive and it's safe for us to kill 1 village (since we already killed 2 wolves)-
I'm sure you don't mind taking one for the team so we can narrow down wolves?
 
BigCats said:
That's why I'm not asking just PRs to remove their votes. I'm asking ~everyone~ who hasn't already claimed vanillager or used-up power to remove their votes. If everyone does it, then there's plenty of plausible deniability- did they take their vote off because they were a PR or a vanillager? The three of us have already outed ourselves on thread. Wolves won't gain any new info by that.
Click to expand...
I’d like to add AT LEAST one more person to this lynch. On the off chance of multiple 3P
 
genny said:
Don't count on it. Not every game does notifications. And protector doesn't always protect from all actions, sometimes it's just kills.
Click to expand...
I think it would be strange for a protector role to block against kills but not potential vig kills via yellow cards.
 
mizchiefmanaged said:
I’d like to add AT LEAST one more person to this lynch. On the off chance of multiple 3P
Click to expand...
I think three of us can handle it. If two or so other villagers would like to hang around at lynch close just in case, they're more than welcome to. I can't imagine there's all too many non-villagers left with the size of this game, though.
 
@SARdoghandler me and Bigcats don't mind sacrificing ourselves for village.

Since you claim village and your role is redundant I'm sure you don't mind either?
 
BigCats said:
SAR's been acting weird all game, I was willing to buy the odd night protector thing with no counterclaim, but I'm not buying it if there's an every night protector already present. Claiming to protect genny N1 (who said she didn't receive any notifications) when at least from some of the spreadsheets I've read, you get a notice if you'd been protected. Claiming to protect Sunbodi N3, who got a yellow card last night, which is definitely something I feel like a protector should be able to defend against. Just all around didn't line up.
Click to expand...
Oh, um actually I also protected genny N1, and I've also protected myself. There really are no notifications I'm pretty sure.
 
Sunbodi said:
So since you're a villager and we already have 1 protector alive and it's safe for us to kill 1 village (since we already killed 2 wolves)-
I'm sure you don't mind taking one for the team so we can narrow down wolves?
Click to expand...

I mean, sure if that's what you guys want. But just an FYI this type of thinking can NAIL you in games with really creative mechanics
 
Omg. Y'all don't need to be explaining why you're removing your vote. The purpose of using the outed vanilla core for this is to ensure that no one else gets outed in the process of removing their votes. ~Everyone has plausible deniability if everyone does it~
 
HRH Queeb SAR said:
I mean, sure if that's what you guys want. But just an FYI this type of thinking can NAIL you in games with really creative mechanics
Click to expand...
Yeah unless the mods are favoring wolves and throwing them a bone after we demolished them two nights in a row- I doubt there would be enough creative mechanics to let them win.

If mods changed mechanics halfway through that's very unfair.
 
mypetmoose said:
Opposite. But I actually think I like BigCats plan better now, but I'd be much more comfortable with 4-5 on the lynch
Click to expand...
If anyone else would like to volunteer as a sacrifice, they're welcome to. I think 3 + 1-2 people watching should suffice but I'm all for extra paranoia.
 
Sunbodi said:
Yeah unless the mods are favoring wolves and throwing them a bone after we demolished them two nights in a row- I doubt there would be enough creative mechanics to let them win.

If mods changed mechanics halfway through that's very unfair.
Click to expand...

Oh my sweet summer child. You need to play more games. There are many games where a village mislynch turned the entire tide of the game completely
 
Wolf chat after learning they have to sacrifice their wolf protector

download (19).jpeg
 
Sunbodi said:
Yeah unless the mods are favoring wolves and throwing them a bone after we demolished them two nights in a row- I doubt there would be enough creative mechanics to let them win.

If mods changed mechanics halfway through that's very unfair.
Click to expand...
mods wouldn't change the mechanics of the games when the game has already started. They create a balanced game before it begins and then sees what players do with it. It would be set up prior. The mods would have no idea how villagers or wolves will do (because of course that depends on the players).
 
WonderingStudent said:
mods wouldn't change the mechanics of the games when the game has already started. They create a balanced game before it begins and then sees what players do with it. It would be set up prior. The mods would have no idea how villagers or wolves will do (because of course that depends on the players).
Click to expand...
yup. the players ruin games that sweat and tears were put into all the time.
 
Unlynch SAR lynch Nav - I’d like to put pressure on Nav. My analysis may have cleared him earlier but mel stated he’s good at changing his game play to come across villager if necessary. So basically throw out my analysis lol

edit: sorry zig to throw out a vote in the middle of tallying
 
D4 GOOOOAAAAALLLLLLL Lynch Tally

Killer () -
Lupin () -
SAR (6) - Miz, Navilly, MsP, BC, Sunbodi, Killer
Nav (3) - Wolfie, Mel, Alissa
Wondering (1) - SAR

10/15 Players Voting

Lynch close 7 pm PST/10 pm EST (1 hour)

giphy.gif
 
Last edited:
@Sunbodi just curious about your epic table. Did you keep one in the noob game even though you were dead to follow along? Or is this table a new thing?
 
Or I guess we could just not do a vanilla core plan and see what happens :shrug: just sayin’, if SAR goes all vengeful wolf and takes out an actual PR, I tried my best.
 
alissa14 said:
@Sunbodi just curious about your epic table. Did you keep one in the noob game even though you were dead to follow along? Or is this table a new thing?
Click to expand...
I keep a table when playing Town of Salem/Mafia.

I rage quit after being lynched D2 in noob game so I didn't make a table. I play better when I have a table.
 
alissa14 said:
Unlynch SAR lynch Nav - I’d like to put pressure on Nav. My analysis may have cleared him earlier but mel stated he’s good at changing his game play to come across villager if necessary. So basically throw out my analysis lol

edit: sorry zig to throw out a vote in the middle of tallying
Click to expand...
How is that putting pressure on Nav when we’re clearly lynching SAR tonight? Do your pressure lynch tomorrow.
 
Shouldn't the wolf chat be policing Alissa right now? Like telling her not to do stupid lynches. Idk, if I were a wolf I wouldn't make any moves without first consolidating with my team.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.