- Joined
- May 2, 2006
- Messages
- 624
- Reaction score
- 7
- Points
- 4,551
- Post Doc
jsnuka said:Can anyone offer a up a working definition of what this entails?
Is anyone out there attached to a SPECOPS unit now or been attached to one in the past?
Is this ultimately different from an operational tour with any other unit?
To make it short. No, there is no difference in what YOU will do as a physician assigned to a Special Forces unit or regular unit. If you had special forces training the answer would be different.jsnuka said:All branches please.
At a minimum, the docs have to be Flight surgery qualified, and likely airborne qualified (some docs have jumped with their teams). Dive medicine is a possibility as well as Ranger school and Q school.
So far and away, the Army has the most opportunities while the Navy/Marine Corps does not?
rotatores said:For comparison sake..."flight surgery" in the Army is a 6 wk course compared to Navy's 6 month course. Although what you speak of may be correct...an Army SF spot (Rich correct me if I'm wrong) or an Army GMO spot are few and far between whereas Navy GMO's are the norm. Now I'm not trying to compare Army and Navy...but I believe in your post you seem to be forgetting all the cool stuff that a Navy GMO, DMO or flight surgeon can do straight out of internship.
rotatores
USUHS 2006
As far as who has more opportunities, I'm just passing on COL Farr's opinion. Navy GMO's do probably get more field time than other branches, but the question was originally about SF and I think Army has the largest SF community and it's supposed to be growing over the next 5-10 yrs.
Are you a Navy student at USUHS now? If so, I need to talk to you before you get to bogged down with graduation stuff and the transition to your internship.
Croooz said:You guys are presenting the exception to the rule.
Yes the Army has more chances to go with Special Forces. You will be sent to SERE school 1st to see if you can hack the rest of training. What you will see are SERE, Airborne, and Ranger qualified docs. Docs are usually given permission to go thru the rest of the phases of the Q course but not the oppurtunity.
The Navy has some cool things with DMO. However I would say your chances are better with the Army if Special Forces is what you want....but can you even make it past SERE. 🙄![]()
After my 3rd tour in Nam as a member of Shadow Company I formed Operational Detachment-Delta with Col. Beckwith. I then got bored with that and formed DEVGRU, which we called SEAL Team 6 back then cuz there were only 6 of us. Then I was recruited by a a government agency to conduct clandestine operations in places I can't remember. I've won the Medal of Honor but my records are sealed. Now I'm going to go back and earn my 3 doctorate at USUHS....after I finish a combined JD/MBA/MDIV program. 🙄GMO_52 said:OK, time to bust it out again...I was the door-gunner on the space shuttle.
Seriously, you're training to be a doctor. If you want to go to summer camp, fine, but don't lose sight of why we're there.
HAHAHA...right and the military is just allowing these SF docs carteblanche to all these schools. The teams can't even get their operators billets but the physician is gonna get one.grumbo said:Most people want to be docs first, but want to do something different in the military and so they go SF. These guys will do Flight Surgery and Airborne as extra qualifications.
Some people want to be SF soldiers more than doctors. These guys will do all of the courses since that's what they want to do. Being a doctor is the extra qualification for these guys.
It's your choice: Doc giving SF support or SF guy with doc skills in support.
Fair enough. 👍 It's a very, very small group.grumbo said:Actually, I probably won't do much of anything beyond run-of-the-mill Army doc stuff for one simple fact: I hate running. I just think it's interesting to see what "could" be done. This stuff is all very rare and only for a select group of people, but for people interested in it, it's nice to see what the limits can be. I know that the vast majority docs (including myself) will do only clinical things and see the field only when we get deployed. However, there is that small group of docs who will do interesting things and have cool stories to tell to bored med students.
Boy I tell you these Mayo non-trads are somethin... 😉efex101 said:Just one point of clarity but Special Forces is Army only although they do fall under Special Operations command. It helps to make sure you use the right term for the right folks. All others like the SEALS, Air Force PJ's, etc...fall under the Special Operations umbrella. I hear this/read this all the time and it is wrong to call a SEAL Special Forces...
grumbo said:I agree that Army Flight surgery is basically nothing. In fact, one of the main reasons that Army SF uses flight surgeons is a political move. The non-medical guys would not allow the SF slots to be designated as more than two or three specialties. If a unit was allowed to have a doc and it was designated a FP or EM slot, then a motivated peds doc couldn't get it (even if he was prior SF). So, they changed it so all SF slots are Flight surgery slots. A quick six week course and you're good to go no matter what medical specialty you are.
efex101 said:Just one point of clarity but Special Forces is Army only although they do fall under Special Operations command. It helps to make sure you use the right term for the right folks. All others like the SEALS, Air Force PJ's, etc...fall under the Special Operations umbrella. I hear this/read this all the time and it is wrong to call a SEAL Special Forces...
He he...nah just a pet peeve of mine since hubby is SF...
dtn3t said:You're right, the Army FS course is pretty much a Gentlemen's course. I did it as my last elective for med school last year, and it was an awesome time. Now don't get me wrong, you learn a lot of stuff that is useful, but it was still a good time and I got to know a lot of very good people. And you're right in that Rocky Farr, er, COL Farr tries to get all of his spec ops docs FS qual'ed, because they can be used with the 160th SOAR. I'm not so sure if it's so the little peds doc (like me) can do spec ops (not SF) stuff, but that makes sense. And according to Farr, there are slots for any specialty, granted peds and the other low speed specialties are a lot less in number.
Tiger26 said:So do you have to USUHS to do the FS course as a med school elective. The reason I ask is that I'm about to get commissioned via ROTC into the guard and doing the med student to med corps program during med school starting this fall as an MS1. I would really be interested in doing the FS course if I could during fourth year.

Tiger26 said:So do you have to USUHS to do the FS course as a med school elective. The reason I ask is that I'm about to get commissioned via ROTC into the guard and doing the med student to med corps program during med school starting this fall as an MS1. I would really be interested in doing the FS course if I could during fourth year.
alpha62 said:72 hours before I was due to fly home from asia, somebody came running up to me all out of breath saying " man, I'm glad I caught you, this is yours, man you musta pissed somebody off "
It was a set of orders for army FS course TDY in PCS route.
Actually you can go to SFAS straight off the streets if you're 20yr old.chrisjohn said:18D folks. Hey you can do that immediatly out of basic if you're an E4.
jsnuka said:Any commentary from the Navy, Marine Corps and Air Force folx? We have had a lot of commentary from the Army, and it is greatly appreciated, but what about the other branches?
Another question, de facto, wouldn't all of the flight surgeon courses have a SERE course component or are there gradations of SERE training?
Croooz said:Actually you can go to SFAS straight off the streets if you're 20yr old.
18X is having good success. It was tried during Nam as well. National Guard has been doing it since the beginning...I think, I'm not sure about that one.chrisjohn said:How things change. I remember an SF recruiter trying to get the E4s coming out of the 96B basic course. Had a recruiter from the 82nd as well and he got the rest of us to volunteer for jump school. We had two tabbed Rangers reclassing, taking advantage of the ultra low promotion points, grumbling about how SF was recruiting "babies."
SERE used to have three gradations of courses, don't know what the current class configuration is.
The whackers need love too.LADoc00 said:Why would you even want be to a spec ops doc? The whole reason is you are doing spec ops is to whack bad guys....
Croooz said:jsnuka,
I don't believe you were prior service. Here's a question for you; explain to me what the difference is between a Navy physician and Marine Corps physician? What billets are there for Marine Corps physicians with Force Recon vs Navy physicians with Force?
At last count I asked you 7 questions. You have yet to answer. You believe that just because you ask nicely people should come on here and answer your lazy and thoughtless questions? Perhaps if you used that little button labeled "search" it might help to clarify your Rambo fantasies.jsnuka said:Crooz,
The "open" overtures of affection form you are "kind", but I am married and I figure that you are not my type.
As with anything in life, if it concerns you and you have a question about it, you ASK.
Now if you have nothing (and clearly that is the case) constructive to offer to the discussion, IGNORE it.
It would go a long way to making most folx who visit here, enjoy there time and experience.
How is this any different than what goes on in military units?chrisjohn said:This is why I HATE military medicine threads. Everyone wants to bust balls, they're own and everyone else's.