Supernatural WW 2019 Edition Sign Ups & Game Thread

[Animal Midwife]

---

Members do not see this ad.

I'm not convinced enough by my tone read of him to trust it over my tinfoils lol

Mind sharing the tinfoils?

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

omg i love that sauce

It's heaven in a bottle

 

[SportPonies]

Mind sharing the tinfoils?

cubs is a wolf who I am unable read due to his lack of posts and he's voting FTF, who is also a wolf, to push distance between them on D1, as per the miz on cubs vote in (I believe) Birthday.

 

[PippyPony]

Tinfoil ≠ regular suspicion

Respect the sanctity of the most shiniest of hats plz people 👽

 

[Animal Midwife]

Unofficial Day 1 Heat of the Moment Lynch Tally

FTF (3) - cubs, Sporty, capri
cubs (1) - AM
Nav (2) - Barks, mutts
SAR (1) - Coffee?
genny (1) - Nav
miz (2) - kras, paws
MJ (1) - kcough
cheezit (1) - FTF
Sporty (1) - genny
Coffee? (1) - Pippy
MsP (1) - miz

15/25 votes
lynch close in ~1.5 hours
Missing: @Melchizedek @fromthebox @Mad Jack @acanthuroidei @SnowshoeDog143 @Ms Procrastinator @StartingoverVet @SARdoghandler @mypetmoose

 

[PippyPony]

@Melchizedek why so many posts but no votes?

 

[Animal Midwife]

cubs is a wolf who I am unable read due to his lack of posts and he's voting FTF, who is also a wolf, to push distance between them on D1, as per the miz on cubs vote in (I believe) Birthday.

So shouldn't miz be the one bussing then? But no that didn't happen in Birthday.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Game Mechanics:
6. Ask anyone who has played my games before how much you should rely on role reveals. That is all I will say about that.

So roles aren't indicative of alignment. Well knowledge of the show doesn't help there. There are multiple characters on the show that kind of constantly switch back and forth between good and evil so I can kind of understand why roles aren't indicative of alignment.

 

[SportPonies]

So shouldn't miz be the one bussing then? But no that didn't happen in Birthday.

n....no. I think there's a miscommunication between us, because this crazy train has nothing to do with miz. I was just referencing that particular vote.


@CoffeeQuestionMark where ya at?
@mizchiefmanaged got any thoughts?
@StayingPositive2017 also curious to hear your thoughts at this point.

 

[PippyPony]

So shouldn't miz be the one bussing then? But no that didn't happen in Birthday.

Spoiler: uhhh

 

[Animal Midwife]

n....no. I think there's a miscommunication between us, because this crazy train has nothing to do with miz. I was just referencing that particular vote.

Okay, then why is a miz-specific bus being mentioned?

 

[cubsrule4e]

Took me some time but

Dr. ForgotToFlush

Animal Midwife
CoffeeQuestionMark
genny
mypetmoose
Mad Jack
Lawper
kraskadva

acanthuroidei
Ms Procrastinator
fromthebox

Melchizedek
SportPonies
muttmanager
Dinashadow

StartingoverVet
SARdoghandler
kcoughli

Barkley13
capri1722
cubsrule4e
SnowshoeDog143
StayingPositive2017

Navilly
FTF
mizchiefmanaged
PippyPony

What exactly is this? Sorry I’m a bit slow

 

[Animal Midwife]

Spoiler: uhhh

Hm?

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

n....no. I think there's a miscommunication between us, because this crazy train has nothing to do with miz. I was just referencing that particular vote.


@CoffeeQuestionMark where ya at?
@mizchiefmanaged got any thoughts?
@StayingPositive2017 also curious to hear your thoughts at this point.

I don’t like Coffee? being absent. I feel a bit better about you atm. Would be ok with a cubs vote, maybe a Mel vote. All I’ve got right now is feels.

I kinda bussed cubs in that game but it was accidental. Or maybe it was the next game. I bussed him with no votes and then disappeared and then he got lynched. It was a bit of an accidental bus.

 

[PippyPony]

Okay, then why is a miz-specific bus being mentioned?

Because people don't all think like robots and so they can extrapolate...?

Sorry, I rarely defend other people and actually didn't even play the game in question but I feel like this a semantics thing that is going to go in circles

 

[Animal Midwife]

Because people don't all think like robots and so they can extrapolate...?

Sorry, I rarely defend other people and actually didn't even play the game in question but I feel like this a semantics thing that is going to go in circles

I'm confused though. Can you explain it to me?

 

[mypetmoose]

Because people don't all think like robots and so they can extrapolate...?

Sorry, I rarely defend other people and actually didn't even play the game in question but I feel like this a semantics thing that is going to go in circles

How do you feel about Sporty?

 

[SportPonies]

Okay, then why is a miz-specific bus being mentioned?

Because that's my tinfoil about this game (so far lol). Same deal, but with cubs and FTF. Day 1, wolf on wolf vote to distance themselves.
If you're asking why I'm bringing that one up instead of x instance, it's because my WW memory only spans very selectively and it's the only specific one I remember haha

I don’t like Coffee? being absent. I feel a bit better about you atm. Would be ok with a cubs vote, maybe a Mel vote. All I’ve got right now is feels.

I kinda bussed cubs in that game but it was accidental. Or maybe it was the next game. I bussed him with no votes and then disappeared and then he got lynched. It was a bit of an accidental bus.

This is actually exactly what I meant. It was accidental because you were on him with no votes, as would be the case here (provided they're both wolves).



I've now clarified this tinfoil so extensively that I feel like it's becoming distracting.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

What exactly is this? Sorry I’m a bit slow

People with the coolest usernames

 

[mypetmoose]

How do you feel about Sporty?

other than Animal Midwife's conversation with her is unhelpful

 

[cubsrule4e]

@cubsrule4e where r u
also want words from @Mad Jack and @Dinashadow

Was at work, now at a dinner meeting reading about 8 posts at a time

 

[cubsrule4e]

#############lynch FTF##########

thinking.

The apple doesn’t fall far from the tree! 😍

 

[Animal Midwife]

Because that's my tinfoil about this game (so far lol). Same deal, but with cubs and FTF. Day 1, wolf on wolf vote to distance themselves.
If you're asking why I'm bringing that one up instead of x instance, it's because my WW memory only spans very selectively and it's the only specific one I remember haha

Well, a world where this is exactly true means cubs is the PR wolf. I'm just mainly wondering why go for a bus today when there's likely ~4 wolves.

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

What exactly is this? Sorry I’m a bit slow

I spent 40 hours a week developing a WW algorithm with an extensive database. All I have to do is give it a list of names and it'll sort them for me from top to bottom

 

[PippyPony]

I'm confused though. Can you explain it to me?

She was using a past event as an example of a type of behavior (like "in the style of ___"), not as a literal reference to a specific person doing the same thing again. Broadly extrapolating from previous experience is a normal way of problem solving haha.

@SportPonies you're on your own now though 😛

 

[cubsrule4e]

Lynch Cubs

Do you have any reads? When you wolf you seem to like to sneak by without providing a lot of game content and I'm getting that feeling right now.

I think [redacted] is acting pretty wolfy right now because [redacted]. [redacted] and [redacted] are at the top of my village reads because [redacted]. Hope this helps!

 

[PippyPony]

How do you feel about Sporty?

I think she is using the name of Foil in vain, but I actually feel relatively ok about her at the moment

 

[mypetmoose]

I spent 40 hours a week developing a WW algorithm with an extensive database. All I have to do is give it a list of names and it'll sort them for me from top to bottom

I know this is a joke, but can you give us a straight answer? Why is your name on there twice and why aren't some of the cooler names (like miz, lol) near the top?

 

[Animal Midwife]

She was using a past event as an example of a type of behavior (like "in the style of ___"), not as a literal reference to a specific person doing the same thing again. Broadly extrapolating from previous experience is a normal way of problem solving haha.

@SportPonies you're on your own now though 😛

Okay, but it has to fit the meta for me. Because I could say you're bussing all your teammates like Stagg but it'd have to be a specific world/scenario to have a realistic chance to be true (like Omitted).

 

[Animal Midwife]

I know this is a joke, but can you give us a straight answer? Why is your name on there twice and why aren't some of the cooler names (like miz, lol) near the top?

Is this helping you find wolves?

 

[mypetmoose]

I think she is using the name of Foil in vain, but I actually feel relatively ok about her at the moment

Okay, how do you feel about AM?

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

Is this helping you find wolves?

Animal Rudewife

 

[PippyPony]

Okay, but it has to fit the meta for me. Because I could say you're bussing all your teammates like Stagg but it'd have to be a specific world/scenario to have a realistic chance to be true (like Omitted).

Maybe I am bussing all my teammates like Stagg

Do Miz and Stagg hold exclusive rights to bussing?

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

I know this is a joke, but can you give us a straight answer? Why is your name on there twice and why aren't some of the cooler names (like miz, lol) near the top?

because Dr.FTF is objectively cooler than just regular FTF

and any names with a z get automatically shifted down
same with numbers

 

[cubsrule4e]

cubs is a wolf who I am unable read due to his lack of posts and he's voting FTF, who is also a wolf, to push distance between them on D1, as per the miz on cubs vote in (I believe) Birthday.

So seriously. When is the last time you read me village? Have you ever?

 

[Dinashadow]

@mypetmoose have you voted yet and if you haven't why?

 

[PippyPony]

Okay, how do you feel about AM?

She's being stubborn and overly literal and it's about to get mildly annoying but I don't have her as wolfy based on her content from yesterday.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Maybe I am bussing all my teammates like Stagg

Do Miz and Stagg hold exclusive rights to bussing?

Their specific type I'd say so. It's the deepest of wolfing.

 

[SportPonies]

Well, a world where this is exactly true means cubs is the PR wolf. I'm just mainly wondering why go for a bus today when there's likely ~4 wolves.

I don't think anyone is going for a true bus, nor am I going for an "exactly true" reference. But voting for another wolf who you feel will not be lynched is a totally viable move on D1, and I'm saying that's something that could be happening here, as it did prior. The actual fact cubs died was not intentional on the wolves' part in that game, and I don't think that is the intent in this game.

But this conversation is largely nonconstructive at this point, because it's not even some theory I'm wholely invested in. It's just something that was in the back of my mind that you asked me to bring up. So can we please resume our normally scheduled WW now that we've beaten the sportpony to death?

 

[Animal Midwife]

I don't think anyone is going for a true bus, nor am I going for an "exactly true" reference. But voting for another wolf who you feel will not be lynched is a totally viable move on D1, and I'm saying that's something that could be happening here, as it did prior. The actual fact cubs died was not intentional on the wolves' part in that game, and I don't think that is the intent in this game.

But this conversation is largely nonconstructive at this point, because it's not even some theory I'm wholely invested in. It's just something that was in the back of my mind that you asked me to bring up. So can we please resume our normally scheduled WW now that we've beaten the sportpony to death?

Okay, what are the results of your isos?

 

[SportPonies]

So seriously. When is the last time you read me village? Have you ever?

When you're village lol

But for a real answer, I've never read you strong village as far as my memory serves, BUT I have called you out on being non-village early-game in every game you have played as non-village. Some game, that streak will end. But that's why I was waiting for you to come back. I need posts to read.

But to clarify the post you quoted (again. This is the sound of me banging my head against my desk). I was not saying I think you are wolf. I was saying that was my tinfoil that could be possible, especially since I had no posts to base a read off off.

 

[mypetmoose]

Is this helping you find wolves?

It might be. I'm just figuring things out the best way I know how-asking questions. Sometimes their response says something important. Sometimes it turns out that line of questioning was trash. Gotta try it out anyway

 

[SportPonies]

Okay, what are the results of your isos?

bunch of village leans and a bunch of question marks.

 

[Animal Midwife]

bunch of village leans and a bunch of question marks.

Can I hear them?

 

[mypetmoose]

@mypetmoose have you voted yet and if you haven't why?

I haven't. I'm still thinking...

 

[cubsrule4e]

When you're village lol

But for a real answer, I've never read you strong village as far as my memory serves, BUT I have called you out on being non-village early-game in every game you have played as non-village. Some game, that streak will end. But that's why I was waiting for you to come back. I need posts to read.

But to clarify the post you quoted (again. This is the sound of me banging my head against my desk). I was not saying I think you are wolf. I was saying that was my tinfoil that could be possible, especially since I had no posts to base a read off off.

Ah ok. Well your streak ends today lol. And would I really try the same strategy 2 games out of 3 where it almost and should have cost wolves the game from day 1? I’m not THAT bold

 

[PippyPony]

@WildZoo @Coopah

Lynch does close in about an hour, right? I'm not making that up?

And heads up that the previous unofficial lynch tally has 9 people listed as missing but says 15/25 voting

 

[Animal Midwife]

@WildZoo @Coopah

Lynch does close in about an hour, right? I'm not making that up?

And heads up that the previous unofficial lynch tally has 9 people listed as missing but says 15/25 voting

I really can't find the tenth and it's tripping me up.

 

[Dr. ForgotToFlush]

I would like to request a votecount, please.

 

[SportPonies]

Ah ok. Well your streak ends today lol. And would I really try the same strategy 2 games out of 3 where it almost and should have cost wolves the game from day 1? I’m not THAT bold

omg it's a tinfoil. It was not, and still is not, my primary hypothesis, despite the fact that we've now all spent like 2 whole pages talking about it. It's just something I was planning on keeping in the back of my mind as a consideration while I was evaluating several people.

I would like to request a votecount, please.

You plan on defending at all?