Take Step 1? I probably know the answer…

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Lugh

Lugh

Professional Worrier
2+ Year Member
Joined
Feb 24, 2022
Messages
38
Reaction score
23
My school straight up told us it is pointless to take Step 1. They said that only Level 1 is necessary and that only ~6% of the past few classes took Step 1. Now, I want to do FM so I know I’m not going into a very competitive specialty but if I want to try to get into a good program in a metro area, I feel like I need to be more competitive than just a Level 1 score.

Thoughts?
Members don't see this ad.
 
ALWAYS take step 1.

I know of people who only wanted to go to certain programs and those programs were fine with just COMLEX but you are shutting doors if you don't take step 1.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
FM match rate is virtually identical between comlex and step. Question is do you think you can pass easily? If so I'd say take step. If you're borderline it might not be worth the risk
 
Lugh said:
My school straight up told us it is pointless to take Step 1. They said that only Level 1 is necessary and that only ~6% of the past few classes took Step 1. Now, I want to do FM so I know I’m not going into a very competitive specialty but if I want to try to get into a good program in a metro area, I feel like I need to be more competitive than just a Level 1 score.

Thoughts?
Click to expand...
Is their reasoning that Step 1 is P/F and it's Step 2 that will count?

Or is it the more insidious DO True Believer mindset of "COMLEX is just as good as Steps and you don't need them at all"?
 
~50% of DOs take step 1 iirc. So either your school is an extreme outlier or they’re just wrong/lying.

There’s essentially no risk in taking it. If you fail, don’t report it and it’s like you never took it. The only downside to a fail is that if you wanted to submit a step 2 score, you’d have to submit a failed step 1. Although a failed step 1 likely wouldn’t translate to a good step 2 anyway so it’s nbd.

I’ve met too many DOs who wanted something more competitive than FM by the end of third year and just couldn’t get the time needed to study for two step exams.
 
Ho0v-man said:
~50% of DOs take step 1 iirc. So either your school is an extreme outlier or they’re just wrong/lying.

There’s essentially no risk in taking it. If you fail, don’t report it and it’s like you never took it. The only downside to a fail is that if you wanted to submit a step 2 score, you’d have to submit a failed step 1. Although a failed step 1 likely wouldn’t translate to a good step 2 anyway so it’s nbd.

I’ve met too many DOs who wanted something more competitive than FM by the end of third year and just couldn’t get the time needed to study for two step exams.
Click to expand...

How much higher (if any) do you think the match rates for the medium, medium-high competitive specialties would be for DOs that take both Steps 1 and 2 and perform average/above average on them?

e.g. gas was ~60% for DOs in 2022, but do you know how higher it is for DOs that take Steps 1 & 2?
 
DoctoOcto said:
How much higher (if any) do you think the match rates for the medium, medium-high competitive specialties would be for DOs that take both Steps 1 and 2 and perform average/above average on them?

e.g. gas was ~60% for DOs in 2022, but do you know how higher it is for DOs that take Steps 1 & 2?
Click to expand...

The “Score Unknown” column reflects DOs who didn’t submit Step 1 scores. Over 90% of all DO gas applicants had a Step 1 score, so the average match rate is much more reflective of that population.

1667306246866.png
 
DoctoOcto said:
How much higher (if any) do you think the match rates for the medium, medium-high competitive specialties would be for DOs that take both Steps 1 and 2 and perform average/above average on them?

e.g. gas was ~60% for DOs in 2022, but do you know how higher it is for DOs that take Steps 1 & 2?
Click to expand...
Look at the score breakdowns on the charting outcomes. Depending on score the match rate can be quite different.
 
Ho0v-man said:
~50% of DOs take step 1 iirc. So either your school is an extreme outlier or they’re just wrong/lying.

There’s essentially no risk in taking it. If you fail, don’t report it and it’s like you never took it. The only downside to a fail is that if you wanted to submit a step 2 score, you’d have to submit a failed step 1. Although a failed step 1 likely wouldn’t translate to a good step 2 anyway so it’s nbd.

I’ve met too many DOs who wanted something more competitive than FM by the end of third year and just couldn’t get the time needed to study for two step exams.
Click to expand...
My guess is that number is going to drop. My school had less than 1/3 take step in our class when previous classes were above that 50% mark.
 
DoctoOcto said:
How much higher (if any) do you think the match rates for the medium, medium-high competitive specialties would be for DOs that take both Steps 1 and 2 and perform average/above average on them?

e.g. gas was ~60% for DOs in 2022, but do you know how higher it is for DOs that take Steps 1 & 2?
Click to expand...
As seen above, 240+ on step 1 did pretty dang good. No score was a coin toss chance of matching and sub 230 step 1 starts showing diminishing returns.

It’s actually great evidence that doing well on these exams can only help you, despite what some schools would have you think.

DrZoidbergDO said:
My guess is that number is going to drop. My school had less than 1/3 take step in our class when previous classes were above that 50% mark.
Click to expand...
RIP to all the DOs who don’t want primary care. Between this, loss of a score on step 1, and school expansion, the specialist DO will be a relic by the time our kids are old enough to ignore our advice and become doctors.
 
Ho0v-man said:
As seen above, 240+ on step 1 did pretty dang good. No score was a coin toss chance of matching and sub 230 step 1 starts showing diminishing returns.

It’s actually great evidence that doing well on these exams can only help you, despite what some schools would have you think.


RIP to all the DOs who don’t want primary care. Between this, loss of a score on step 1, and school expansion, the specialist DO will be a relic by the time our kids are old enough to ignore our advice and become doctors.
Click to expand...

I wonder if the match rates into the more competitive specialties will be relatively steady for established schools whose graduates are known quantities? While those from new schools will struggle to match, and bring down the DO match rates overall.
 
DoctoOcto said:
I wonder if the match rates into the more competitive specialties will be relatively steady for established schools whose graduates are known quantities? While those from new schools will struggle to match, and bring down the DO match rates overall.
Click to expand...
I’m sure newer schools will do a little worse just because they tend to attract weaker students on average.

No one involved in residency selection knows anything about the different osteopathic schools. I literally spoke to someone involved in resident selection at my program about this very topic today FWIW.
 
just wondering...If you can just take step 2 without taking Step 1 , why would you still take Step 1??
 
Goro said:
Or is it the more insidious DO True Believer mindset of "COMLEX is just as good as Steps and you don't need them at all"?
Click to expand...
Sadly this is the prevailing philosophy preached to us at our school. Fortunately, the majority of us are wiser than that.
 
It is discussions like this, where students are receiving information from their schools to NOT take Step 1 that validate the idea that successful students are generally successful, not because of their school, but in spite of their school.

Always take Step 1. Your app needs to look like an MD application as much as possible. COMLEX is just a hoop to jump through. A tax we pay haha.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top