If there are any other ideas or suggestions to help improve my application, please let me know. Any advice on this situation would truly be helpful. Thanks!!!
Again, I'm an M1, not an ADCOM memeber. If you have a premed advisor you should be talking to them.
I'd go with retakin the MCAT as your first priority, though the DO postbac or just retaking classes are also both options. If you get into a DO SMP definitely do it. I would definitely push to at least bump your sci GPA up to 2.75 before starting the DO SMP/postbac, if you're going to take the SMP/postbac. The thing you have to realize is that your Cum GPA, Sci GPA, and MCAT are all several standard deviations below average (even for low ranked DO schools), so I'm not seeing a lot of hope here without something improving in (though if you have money to burn you might get lucky with DO). I'd say with your scores you best shot for an acceptance is the Carribiean, but be aware that getting in in no way means that you won't fail right back out. US MD or DO would require you to improve your app significantly.
Did you have a positive trend in college? Or a really good reason for your grades? Is there anything you have on your application to prove to ADCOMs that you won't fail out as soon as they let you in? The case you're making to ADCOMs is that your performance on the MCAT doesn't mean that you'll fail boards, and that your performance in college doesn't mean you'll fail out of medical school. Think about how you would need to have that case made to you, if you were on an ADCOM.
You can definitely do this, people have gotten in starting from way worse stats than yours, but it will take work and time. Honestly I think 2010 might application cycle than 2009 (maybe apply to your SMP college for 2009 if you choose to do an SMP), but if you keep pushing and doing well you will get it done.
So, to summarize, my advice:
1) retake your MCAT once your scoring 30s on the practice tests
2) retake a science class or two to bump up your science GPA
3) Do the DO SMP
4) Apply to medical school for 2010 (maybe your SMP school for 2009 if you do an SMP in 2009)
5) Get in.
Good luck.