- Joined
- Nov 1, 2009
- Messages
- 2,920
- Reaction score
- 1,083
lynch LIS.
I've already stated that MJ is a villager than can ask ANY question to the mods but he cannot post on the thread or PM anyone.
he isnt silenced. He's just no longer allowed to PM with people in his group.
FWIW ....LIS has NOT posted in the thread today. A search on this thread shows his last post yesterday at 4pm. Unless he posted and had to delete because he was in fact silenced.I stated it before. His role was ambiguous. we talked about how he was likely to be a convert especially with 2 original wolves. Now he is no longer allowed to Pm with me, but has posted in thread. I have high suspicion of conversion
Why not? MJ is my second hunch after Doce.Maybe. From a game maker perspective it would seem odd to make a wolf perma silenced. All this is is a hunch
He had posted this morning. It looks like it's been deletedFWIW ....LIS has NOT posted in the thread today. A search on this thread shows his last post yesterday at 4pm. Unless he posted and had to delete because he was in fact silenced.
unlynch DocE
didn't see he role revealed right before my vote.
I assume whoever is a seer will double chec that (or already has)...
You're right, I could be way off. I'm just using what I know to try to get something goingWhy not? MJ is my second hunch after Doce.
I think it is a great mechanism.
No offense, but that is a pretty naive assumption..
In regard to this, in the Pangea game I was a wolf and could only post in plant pictures, so I don't think it's a big stretch.Maybe. From a game maker perspective it would seem odd to make a wolf perma silenced. All this is is a hunch
Ok, but that and i also believe allie who is pretty sure he's a villagerIn regard to this, in the Pangea game I was a wolf and could only post in plant pictures, so I don't think it's a big stretch.
I don't know why you're throwing in the towel already, LIS is still ahead by 4 votesYou're all idiots. seriously. Going after a silenced guy and someone with an actual alibi being put up by a character who admits to talking to Flagg (in a mirror perhaps).
Maybe if I die you'll at least have a small chance of me killing whatver wolf is framing me with my power. I'd assume it's vetash.
Lynch myself
M-o-o-n, that spells "I think is was LIS that came up with the rule that people should always lynch people that lynch themselves."I don't know why you're throwing in the towel already, LIS is still ahead by 4 votes
I don't know why you're throwing in the towel already, LIS is still ahead by 4 votes
So why vetash?
So why vetash?
Do you have any idea why MJ would be trying so hard to lynch you?Accused me of being Flagg despite talking to Flagg herself and me being quite open about my role from early. Survived a lynch by unknown means. Found to be chaos which everyone seems to forget. And voting for me before I decided to go nuclear and kill her as a present to everyone. You don't let a sure thing slip away because of a shiny distraction. Many a wolf , myself included, have pulled that trick. narrowly dodge a death and go on the offensive.
It's too late to waffle to her. Waffling to me let's me get her.
ok... I am going to make one PLEA not to lynch LIS...
Here's why...
I know that MJ had an ability activated last night. If he used it, it might have been on LIS, and then we are lynching a person who may (or may not be useful).
We can always investigate LIS as he is suspect #1 right now... and get him tomorrow.
In a recruitment game, there are going to be conversions... the most important thing is to find the RECRUITER.
I think no matter what, we are not going to get the wolf we are looking for.... and at worst we can still get him tomorrow.
I REALLY disagree with lynching a silenced player when we have seen that the mods are a bit devious and we can just as well be lynching a really important person for the villagers.
That is how I feel.
Yeah, that was the one reason I had to think MJ was a villager (prior to the info today about MJ being a villager). In a game with only 2 starting wolves, I doubt the mods would make one of the wolves stand out that much.But doesn't that seem a little too obvious? Nothing in the story indicates Flagg wouldn't be able to communicate, and that just seems too obvious of a trait for Flagg to have since it's drawing attention to him
I think that's what happened. I didn't see the post, but STL's reminder makes me think that happened.FWIW ....LIS has NOT posted in the thread today. A search on this thread shows his last post yesterday at 4pm. Unless he posted and had to delete because he was in fact silenced.