Posted anonymously via Google Forms
Program: New York Presbyterian (Columbia/Cornell)
Rotation: EM Sub-Internship
SLOE Provided: No
Comments: This is the residency program for Cornell and Columbia. You work two weeks at Columbia and two weeks at Cornell. Approximately 20 shifts that are a mix of 12's, 10's, and 8's. One shift of each: EMS ride along, peds, and urgent care. Roughly four overnight shifts. Each Wednesday is "off" for didactics which are mandatory and attended by all the residents; alternating between Cornell and Columbia campus each week. Pretty grueling schedule to be honest.
Columbia ED is a complete cluster ****. Basically one big room divided into two zones with patients only separated by curtains. Never a computer available for students and a terrible learning environment. Patients were regularly waiting 12 hours to be seen. Tons of hallway beds. Lots of Spanish spoken (huge Dominican Republic population). Nurses were overworked and there were lots of chances to place IV and roll patients to scanners, etc. Some of the worst patient care I've witnessed.
Cornell is a little better but not by much. They have one area that is brand new, one lower acuity area staffed mostly by PA's, and one area that is half rooms/half curtains.
The main problem with this program is that Cornell is on the upper East Side and Columbia is at 168th in Washington Heights...the commute is terrible at least half of the time depending on where you live. Residents seemed miserable working 12's plus the commute. Attendings and residents didn't teach much and I always felt like I was a burden.
Procedures: several lac repairs, many IV placements, US guided IV's, ABG's, cut a ring off, reduced a shoulder. VERY LITTLE TRAUMA in NYC comes to NYP so that was disappointing....maybe one activation per shift.
Residents: Didn't jive well with them. Very NYC centric group. Subsidized housing right next to Cornell is $2700 for a 1 bedroom.
SLOE: They don't write one. Instead, they assign you to a faculty member who writes you an individual letter based on feedback submitted by all of the attendings you work with that month. Unfortunately, I had never worked with this attending but scheduled a meeting outside of my clinical duties...it worked out fine and I still got a TON of interviews so not something to worry about. They give approximately 80% Honors (per the Sub-I director).
Overall: I do not recommend rotating here unless you absolutely want to live in NYC or are trying to decide if NYC is for you (coming from out of state). They are definitely strong academically given the double IVY association. Both ED's are kind of a disaster...especially Columbia. PD wasn't my favorite (could barely get a word in during the interview). They interview all Sub-I's during the rotation to save a trip back to NYC. No traditional SLOE but not really a problem.