here's a debate w/ Lou Dobbs and Jorge Ramos
http://www.cnn.com/2006/POLITICS/03/29/immigration/index.html (click on debate with b/w lou dobbs )
it's funny how whenever Lou asks any of these questions, Jorge completely circumvents them.
I think Lou is correct in that if we let the illegals stay (guest worker etc) the people that are going to hurt the most are teh MIDDLE CLASS. The rich absolutely LOVE having illegals here (why do you think both dems and a lot of reps love the idea of guest worker) cuz it's cheap labor.
Who friggin gets hurt. Middle class. Sure, inflation is driven down by having cheap labor, but as a result, the middle class workers dont have a platform to negotiate wages. Plus the social security, medicare,etc of the middle class is what's being soaked up by the ILLEGALs.
Sure you can tell the middle class, "get more educated, get anther degree!". but i ask you this, what the hell is that. I mean everyone does not have the desire, or the drive, and some would say the ability to become say a doctor, lawyer, engineer. I mean why would hte avg joe that worked at Ford Motor company benefit from getting another degree? Plus he might be in his mid 50's and cant really change careers.
additionally, i think it's such BS that ppl are making this into racial issue. What's the racial issue here? it's a matter of breaking the law. as lou says in his debate, mexican americans make over 50% of the LEGAL immigrants to this country. So there's no racism. if you come here legally, he we got no probs.
It's unfortunate, but the mid class is friggin gonna get slammed.