WW in Colorado

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
So was it just a single brownie each night or were there two on some nights? Because @SARdoghandler said in PM's she got a brownie on the same night I did and it definitely threw me off.
There was never two brownies given out on one night. I went back and looked at that. SAR received the brownie on N7 and you received the brownie on N8. The confusion may have arisen from the fact that N7 was the one that closed at midday.
 
There was never two brownies given out on one night. I went back and looked at that. SAR received the brownie on N7 and you received the brownie on N8. The confusion may have arisen from the fact that N7 was the one that closed at midday.

Yes, this is what confused me. And I'm easy to confuse in the first place haha
 
There was never two brownies given out on one night. I went back and looked at that. SAR received the brownie on N7 and you received the brownie on N8. The confusion may have arisen from the fact that N7 was the one that closed at midday.

Idk what happened, I just know that I got the PM from ya'll that I got a brownie around 9:15 am on Friday, and Friday night around 6 or 7 pm SAR said she had also gotten a brownie the night before. Idk if she thought I had meant 2 nights ago or something, but it definitely put my target more on her and away from Mel. At least for me it did, probably should have posted in thread to clear up confusion, but didn't want to give away that I was PM'ing with SAR.
 
Yes, this is what confused me. And I'm easy to confuse in the first place haha

Idk what happened, I just know that I got the PM from ya'll that I got a brownie around 9:15 am on Friday, and Friday night around 6 or 7 pm SAR said she had also gotten a brownie the night before. Idk if she thought I had meant 2 nights ago or something, but it definitely put my target more on her and away from Mel. At least for me it did, probably should have posted in thread to clear up confusion, but didn't want to give away that I was PM'ing with SAR.
Both of y'all did have the correct N7/N8 header though 😉 I made sure to check that first.
 
Idk what happened, I just know that I got the PM from ya'll that I got a brownie around 9:15 am on Friday, and Friday night around 6 or 7 pm SAR said she had also gotten a brownie the night before. Idk if she thought I had meant 2 nights ago or something, but it definitely put my target more on her and away from Mel. At least for me it did, probably should have posted in thread to clear up confusion, but didn't want to give away that I was PM'ing with SAR.

In my brownie message I pmed you, it did have the title "n7" so it wasn't intentional confusing, I swear! Haha
 
How come my protection didn't keep am from getting buried by a wolf? That was the we whole reason I figured it had to be a village thing.

Because I needed to be punished for my blocking sins.

But really, I think for these mods protection only applies to kills rather than all actions.
 
That really was a good game! Thanks mods for making that up for everyone. I’m definitely going to play on the next one, now that I really get how a whole game is played start to finish. I learned more by actually playing, sorry I didn’t do much to help the village and for my noobness hopefully it’ll go away as I play more games. :prof:
 
I'm also proud of @Miranda Senft for dodging the lynch the first time. I thought the combo of you being busy plus a late bandwagon would ensure your lynch. Apparently you can smooth talk your way out of stuff...
I had to hide the dirty little secret that when we met last weekend, we were both wolves and Moose kept asking if she was getting lynched 😆
 
Also sorry about the post restrictions. I was having too much fun being an evil mastermind 😏

You self-inflicted ones were interestingly timed...

I had to hide the dirty little secret that when we met last weekend, we were both wolves and Moose kept asking if she was getting lynched 😆

lol That encouraged my next block seeing no post later referencing this since Moose was revealed as a wolf.
 
That really was a good game! Thanks mods for making that up for everyone. I’m definitely going to play on the next one, now that I really get how a whole game is played start to finish. I learned more by actually playing, sorry I didn’t do much to help the village and for my noobness hopefully it’ll go away as I play more games. :prof:

I felt bad killing you but felt you were mod confirmed village to am so you had to go. Look forward to having you in the next game!
 
The game may have seemed village tilted since kara talked about not thinking the wolves could win, but a 21:6 ratio (once you include converts) is pretty well in the wolves' favor, especially when one of those is a last minute conversion. I realize the timing rested on stagg's choice to hold onto the rez.

Even if you count the two village rezzes as extra villagers, 23:6 is still a lower ratio than I'd run a game at, especially around here. Inactivity is a thing and it tends to hurt village more than it hurts wolves so I think games really need to be a little more village favoring to fit the game culture here.

It's funny if you think about the irl game that is like...a 9:1 ratio lol
 
Also, #offended that the other wolves overruled converting me. Look how little heat I got in my second life 😛 no consideration for the historic importance of a manator getting to wolf with her manatee...
Oh Kara wanted to, believe me. But we didn't know that conversion was going to be so subtle in the write-up. You're a solid choice for a convert bc you're a good villager (as is shown by my recent conversion of you), so we didn't want to go down that path in case people started convert hunting. We thought converting Mel was crazy enough that it might work (and it did!)
 
Oh Kara wanted to, believe me. But we didn't know that conversion was going to be so subtle in the write-up. You're a solid choice for a convert bc you're a good villager (as is shown by my recent conversion of you), so we didn't want to go down that path in case people started convert hunting. We thought converting Mel was crazy enough that it might work (and it did!)
Oh yeah, I never managed to find the convert hint either even though I could feel the conversion in my bones lol think it was already mentioned but lawp dying in that lynch muddied the waters a bit on that statement in...whichever write-up it was
 
The game may have seemed village tilted since kara talked about not thinking the wolves could win, but a 21:6 ratio (once you include converts) is pretty well in the wolves' favor, especially when one of those is a last minute conversion. I realize the timing rested on stagg's choice to hold onto the rez.

Even if you count the two village rezzes as extra villagers, 23:6 is still a lower ratio than I'd run a game at, especially around here. Inactivity is a thing and it tends to hurt village more than it hurts wolves so I think games really need to be a little more village favoring to fit the game culture here.

It's funny if you think about the irl game that is like...a 9:1 ratio lol
Also the killing off of people after missing 1 vote hurt the village. Which was also suggested by the wolves. Supposedly mods were discussing it already, but if a wolf is suggesting it, it probably is not a great plan.
 
Oh yeah, I never managed to find the convert hint either even though I could feel the conversion in my bones lol think it was already mentioned but lawp dying in that lynch muddied the waters a bit on that statement in...whichever write-up it was
Something about “was it worth it?” When snowy died I think. Very subtle hint. I don’t think anyone would’ve gotten it tbh.
 
The game may have seemed village tilted since kara talked about not thinking the wolves could win, but a 21:6 ratio (once you include converts) is pretty well in the wolves' favor, especially when one of those is a last minute conversion. I realize the timing rested on stagg's choice to hold onto the rez.

Even if you count the two village rezzes as extra villagers, 23:6 is still a lower ratio than I'd run a game at, especially around here. Inactivity is a thing and it tends to hurt village more than it hurts wolves so I think games really need to be a little more village favoring to fit the game culture here.

It's funny if you think about the irl game that is like...a 9:1 ratio lol

Yeah I didn't expect that second convert which is why I thought it was difficult. If the rez had happened before we offed the seers though or the seers were never outed, would have been much different
 
Also the killing off of people after missing 1 vote hurt the village. Which was also suggested by the wolves. Supposedly mods were discussing it already, but if a wolf is suggesting it, it probably is not a great plan.

I do think it helps village. There are a lot of times wolves will choose to keep the quiet ones around for lynch fodder as they are seen as sketchy. It especially helps village at endgame. By removing those players, village has to focus less on the quiet ones and has better chances in end game. This is why filly and I were getting yelled at in endgame in 3 wworlds. I agree there could have been a different policy on how to implement it though
 
I do think it helps village. There are a lot of times wolves will choose to keep the quiet ones around for lynch fodder as they are seen as sketchy. It especially helps village at endgame. By removing those players, village has to focus less on the quiet ones and has better chances in end game. This is why filly and I were getting yelled at in endgame in 3 wworlds. I agree there could have been a different policy on how to implement it though
Replace them then, don’t just kill em off because they’ve missed one single lynch. Especially when other days, they were actively helping wolf hunt. Or give them two or three strikes. Killing them off lowers village numbers for the wolves and brings them closer to winning without them having to lynch or kill.
 
Yeah I didn't expect that second convert which is why I thought it was difficult. If the rez had happened before we offed the seers though or the seers were never outed, would have been much different
Yeah I've probably talked enough about the seers being outted at this point lol
 
Congrats to the wolves on the win!

Should've stuck with my gut regarding Mel. Don't know how the hydra got rezzed as a wolf but that's interesting. Just happy the game finally ended

That was completely random. I asked mods early on if I knew whether my rezzes would come back as village and they said I did not. After the rezzes I asked them if there was any rhyme or reason/way I could have figured out who would have come back as a wolf, they said it was completely random.

Replace them then, don’t just kill em off because they’ve missed one single lynch. Especially when other days, they were actively helping wolf hunt. Or give them two or three strikes. Killing them off lowers village numbers for the wolves and brings them closer to winning without them having to lynch or kill.

Agree. I get it if someone isn't participating at all (like Houston) or posts like twice in 3 days and doesn't vote, but the kata smite sucked because she'd been participating and seemed to have something come up irl, as she was very active that day both in PMs and chat then suddenly disappeared. I don't think she should have been punished for that when she'd been participating all along.
 
Also I totally shouldn't have rezzed anyone at the end. After Genny came out as actually having lynch cancellation, Mel probably would have been the next day vote and village would have won. I only rezzed because I thought that would happen and was convinced based on PMs that SAR was the wolf. Sorry village 🙁
 
Also I totally shouldn't have rezzed anyone at the end. After Genny came out as actually having lynch cancellation, Mel probably would have been the next day vote and village would have won. I only rezzed because I thought that would happen and was convinced based on PMs that SAR was the wolf. Sorry village 🙁
Yeah I double checked with Genny about the timing and message wording before just going ahead and lynching SAR. Plus she just didn't feel wolfy to me and claiming to have the brownies when she didn't just seemed silly. Probably would have pushed the cheezit train harder if I hadn't been busy having fun all that day 😛 Is what it is lol
 
Top