WW: -Omitted Topic-: Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
@Matthew9Thirtyfive

#4 is the biggest. Look through his posts. Where is the wolf hunting? How convenient it is that capri is at the top of his list now
when this was the last read list he posted (Fri)



and yesterday, his only mentioned suspects were Barks & Genny. The last time he mentioned Capri was on Thursday.

and in spite of the fact that he is asking everyone why they are voting for him, he has given no reason to suspect capri
Hmmm
I did have that tingly feel when he mentioned capri but I looked back and he'd brought her up several times over the course of the game so felt better. Didn't realize there was a gap in suspicions, or at least stated ones.
 
I want to look into Genny because of her weird voting behavior at the end of last night.
I could see anyone EXCEPT YOU getting away with posting this, and still having it be logical. If you're truly a villager, then my vote switching shouldn't bother you, since I moved the vote away from you (a villager) and onto a known wolf. If you're a villager, you should be really happy there wasn't a tie involving you, and that I had the presence of mind to switch away from you. You shouldn't be complaining about how I voted since I didn't actually vote for you. The only way your indignation makes sense is if you have a guilty wolf conscience, and you're trying to shade me for pulling the vote away from a wolf (you).
 
Hmmm
I did have that tingly feel when he mentioned capri but I looked back and he'd brought her up several times over the course of the game so felt better. Didn't realize there was a gap in suspicions, or at least stated ones.
Speaking of tingly feels, this feels yucky to me for some reason
 
I could see anyone EXCEPT YOU getting away with posting this, and still having it be logical. If you're truly a villager, then my vote switching shouldn't bother you, since I moved the vote away from you (a villager) and onto a known wolf. If you're a villager, you should be really happy there wasn't a tie involving you, and that I had the presence of mind to switch away from you. You shouldn't be complaining about how I voted since I didn't actually vote for you. The only way your indignation makes sense is if you have a guilty wolf conscience, and you're trying to shade me for pulling the vote away from a wolf (you).
This is koala tea content

And now I'm intrigued

unlynch capri Lynch stagg
 
IMO you came to the right conclusion at the end of this post. Much, if not all, of what you mentioned is just AM's playstyle, and some of it is more distinctly part of her village play.
Yes, but why would he make that whole long post if he qualified at the beginning that other people might be able to tell him if it's just AM being AM?

Like, why not just ask "is this AM's play style?" instead of launching into a whole thing where he thinks she's wolfy, but then flip flops, but then goes back to it when called out?

He has also played a couple games with her so by this point should have some idea. She's not exactly a wallflower.

Also, why are you defending him?
 
Yes, but why would he make that whole long post if he qualified at the beginning that other people might be able to tell him if it's just AM being AM?

Like, why not just ask "is this AM's play style?" instead of launching into a whole thing where he thinks she's wolfy, but then flip flops, but then goes back to it when called out?

He has also played a couple games with her so by this point should have some idea. She's not exactly a wallflower.

Also, why are you defending him?
...where am I defending him?
 
D6 Unofficial Lynch Tally

stagg (6)
- koffee, matty, genny, grebes, Pippy, dubz
capri (2) - lawpy, AM
AM (1) - SOV

9/27

Missing: many

Deadline 11pm est (~10 hours)


tenor.gif
 
Figured it might because I've been all "meh to the stagg lynch!" but it's a new day and there's always time for reevaluation
This is koala tea content

And now I'm intrigued

unlynch capri Lynch stagg
:eyebrow:

One post from genny is going to make you swap to a big wagon on someone who you weren't wolf reading?
 
Yes, but why would he make that whole long post if he qualified at the beginning that other people might be able to tell him if it's just AM being AM?

Like, why not just ask "is this AM's play style?" instead of launching into a whole thing where he thinks she's wolfy, but then flip flops, but then goes back to it when called out?

He has also played a couple games with her so by this point should have some idea. She's not exactly a wallflower.

Also, why are you defending him?
Where is there a defense?

That post reads like SOV to me. I'm pretty sure I've seen him do the exact same sort of talking himself out in different games, so while it may be moot at the end it at least feels consistent.
 
:eyebrow:

One post from genny is going to make you swap to a big wagon on someone who you weren't wolf reading?
No, a post from genny, a lack of convincing defense from stagg, a point from coffee that actually got my attention, and a memory of a thought I had about the D2 vote a while back
 
...where am I defending him?
Where is there a defense?

Should have maybe said validation instead of defense. This to me felt a very subtle way of saying "you're wrong, but you're ok":
IMO you came to the right conclusion at the end of this post. Much, if not all, of what you mentioned is just AM's playstyle, and some of it is more distinctly part of her village play.
 
I went back to look and not only has stagg not mentioned capri since Thursday, that is also the only day he mentioned her as far as I can tell, and it was my bad not looking at the time stamps originally. I am very bothered that today he suddenly has brought her up again, conveniently when she's the potential counterwagon. And I think genny made a pretty great point considering how much stagg has gone on and on about village self preservation and all that.

So, because as sobsob pointed out, I haven't exactly been hitting it out of the park, I decided it might be worthwhile to throw in with those who are having a better game than I am.
 
I am questioning people.

Would you prefer that discussion stops?
She had literally quoted the post that was an interesting point and pushed her over the edge.

That post of genny's is a good one and has actually made me seriously consider a stagg lynch, too, so maybe it just seemed more reasonable to me than you. :shrug:
 
I could see anyone EXCEPT YOU getting away with posting this, and still having it be logical. If you're truly a villager, then my vote switching shouldn't bother you, since I moved the vote away from you (a villager) and onto a known wolf. If you're a villager, you should be really happy there wasn't a tie involving you, and that I had the presence of mind to switch away from you. You shouldn't be complaining about how I voted since I didn't actually vote for you. The only way your indignation makes sense is if you have a guilty wolf conscience, and you're trying to shade me for pulling the vote away from a wolf (you).
this is such a ****ty argument that I don't know whether to laugh or to cry.
This is koala tea content

And now I'm intrigued

unlynch capri Lynch stagg
wtf dubz?
:eyebrow:

One post from genny is going to make you swap to a big wagon on someone who you weren't wolf reading?
Stop reading my diary.
 
Yes, but why would he make that whole long post if he qualified at the beginning that other people might be able to tell him if it's just AM being AM?

Like, why not just ask "is this AM's play style?" instead of launching into a whole thing where he thinks she's wolfy, but then flip flops, but then goes back to it when called out?

He has also played a couple games with her so by this point should have some idea. She's not exactly a wallflower.

Also, why are you defending him?
How can you do what you wanted me to do without listing all the evidence? Huh?
I read through her posts, thought she was wolfy, started writing it out and wasn’t as sure when it was on paper. So i unlynched her. But the suspicion stood. No big mystery? How is any of that what a wolf would do? Geez Louise,

And I have no idea on the play of any of you,,,,,I think of WZ as a new player who is still feeling her way around WW. I don’t even bother trying to remember people’s play style because I am just not here enough.

FWIW... I asked the mods to allow WZ to consult with me as a non playing “consultant” after she died because it was too much for me to keep up with, I thought they would say no, but actually were going to allow it if she wasn’t resurrected (they didn’t say it exactly like that...more like depends on a certain mechanic...let you know tomorrow).
 
Jesus Christ I give up. Coffee's on my case if I go with my original read, cheezit and pip on my case if I reevaluate, sobsob on my case no matter what I do, y'all should have just left me dead. Forgot how much I hate being resurrected.
 
How can you do what you wanted me to do without listing all the evidence? Huh?
I read through her posts, thought she was wolfy, started writing it out and wasn’t as sure when it was on paper. But the suspicion stood. So i unlynched her. No big mystery? How is any of that what a wolf would do? Geez Louise,

And I have no idea on the play of any of you,,,,,I think of WZ as a new player who is still feeling her way around WW. I don’t even bother trying to remember people’s play style because I am just not here enough.

FWIW... I asked the mods to allow WZ to consult with me as a non playing “consultant” after she died because it was too much for me to keep up with, I thought they would say no, but actually were going to allow it if she wasn’t resurrected (they didn’t say it exactly like that...more like depends on a certain mechanic...let you know tomorrow).

Wait how do you feel about Allie, Trouts (ie Trilt) and TG (ThoracicGuy) if you think WZ is new?
 
FWIW... I asked the mods to allow WZ to consult with me as a non playing “consultant” after she died because it was too much for me to keep up with, I thought they would say no, but actually were going to allow it if she wasn’t resurrected (they didn’t say it exactly like that...more like depends on a certain mechanic...let you know tomorrow).
It was you?? Sobsob. I am honored. And actually a little sad I was brought back to my own life instead lol
 
That's wasn't what I was saying at all
Ok, I'm just saying that's how it came off to me when I first read it. I can't know if that is what you meant, and it sounds like it wasn't.

She had literally quoted the post that was an interesting point and pushed her over the edge.

That post of genny's is a good one and has actually made me seriously consider a stagg lynch, too, so maybe it just seemed more reasonable to me than you. :shrug:
I didn't say it was a bad argument from genny. Please note where my vote is sitting right now.
 
Explain why you think it's ****ty?
Kind of depends if you value new information or not. For those who think a second Lynch attempt was always a waste of time, her vote is suspect as now we are still debating the stagg topic. But for those who think all village lives preserved is good, then her act was correct. I am more in Genny camp than stagg/Mel but I see where they are coming from. I don’t think it is Lynch deciding one way or another.
 
Ok, I'm just saying that's how it came off to me when I first read it. I can't know if that is what you meant, and it sounds like it wasn't.
I wasn't commenting on sobsob either way, he's still in my neutral reads. I was commenting on AM.
 
I have a sinus headache and I don't want to get dressed to go to the store to buy more allergy meds. So I'm going to angrily WW for a bit, k?
(Prime Now is lyfe if you have it in your area. I got pedialyte freezies and drugs and ramen all day when I had pneumonia lol).
 
are you asking because you think this is relevant to his reads? this seems like a distraction about who seems new to an older player. knock it off if so

What? Fun is outlawed in WW now? Talking about GOT is ok, but a brief discussion about my senility is not? Geroff my lawn.
 
Allie predates WZ as far as I recall.
Same for trill

TG came from the lounge, no. Not exactly sure.

All predate WZ
Sobsob no. I was in your original noob class. Allie was/is my mentor though so you're right there. Trilt was in the noob game the year after me. And TG did come from the lounge but I think I remember his first game and it was after I'd been playing a couple years.
 
Jesus people, a lot of assumptions being made that are wrong. This is why it seems like I'm not giving reads, because I'm having to spend my days defending stupid crap like this. Be warned, massive posts incoming.
 
Jesus people, a lot of assumptions being made that are wrong. This is why it seems like I'm not giving reads, because I'm having to spend my days defending stupid crap like this. Be warned, massive posts incoming.
:scared:
 
Top