NeWW Girl - Sign Up & Game Thread

[Truenamer]

I love that we have very few consensus village reads. That is... So great... I love it...

1. Truenamer

I've gotten us started

---

Members don't see this ad.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

it's been good

I'll take it

 

[IvyMoose]

Voting for me is not the way. If I had to move their vote to someone, it would be Kate... the person I'm voting for.

Ivy, bless you, but you really do have a defensive streak

... and defensive streak is bad i presume

 

[chicandtoughness]

I probably would have listened to you yesterday if I knew who you were lol

Can you share why? I assume y'all have experience playing together and you have trusted his reads in the past, but that's the past and this is this game. Just want to understand this dynamic.

I've played enough games with genny to know she is almost always sussed, so what do you find suspicious about her gameplay here?
There has been a lot of mechanics talk, but I don't feel True is being super solve-y here. Do you just get a good feeling from his post?

Genny - I feel like I sus her every single game off of vibes alone and I'm always wrong, so I would not read too much into my read lol
True - although it has felt a little shallow, I think he is genuinely trying to contribute in a way that is helpful (e.g. pointing out my mechanics misreads, explaining to Kate how things work, cautioning us to not reveal PRs). Yes, it can totally be a wolf strategy too, but I'm inclined to believe due to the small game that this is being genuinely helpful

I haven't read a ton of this game tbh but I still lowkey feel kinda confident in my reads, maybe I'll do a read through on Wednesday but yeah I really think dubz js the correct kill today it's hard to see that d1 coming from townDubz, even busy townDubz

Clem, I think you might just be... well, being Clem. But this is such horrible logic idk what to think. You barely read the game and immediately hard pushed Dubz, even if you're amazing at reading them, Dubz barely gave you anything TO read. You could be right but this logic just doesn't work with my brain.

What things? Can you clarify which things?

Yes, see #485. Ivy's played around 5 games, which is enough to get a sense of wolf strategy, the concept of a strongarm (or at the least the ability to google the mafia wiki for it). I feel like others have brought up Ivy's noob-ness and she's leaning on it to get out of having to explain thought process.

Ahhhhh it's :47 and I'm only on page 11!!!

 

[potentialsheltervet]

1. Truenamer

I've gotten us started

Like. Why are you sussing genny? Why is chic sussing genny? I feel so good about genny

 

[alissa14]

Day 2 Tally: "Jess are you cooking a frittata in a saucepan? What is this, prison?"

Player	Voted by
Dubz/PSV	Clem, Kate
Kate	TrueNamer
Ivy	PSV, chic, miranda
TrueNamer	genny, Vis
Clem	Ivy
Leading:	@IvyMoose
Missing:
Yeet Close:	10PM CDT/11PM EDT TODAY (~10 MINUTES)
Last Updated:	10:49 PM EST / 9:49 PM CDT by Alissa

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I feel like others have brought up Ivy's noob-ness and she's leaning on it to get out of having to explain thought process

Huh. Could be, I guess. The AtE is getting to my heart some but I see what you're saying.
Also ivy is a man but he let us call him her for nine months without correction. Fun throwback there.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Clem, I think you might just be... well, being Clem.

One thing I will say is every game, he is unequivocally Clem. Sometimes it drives me crazy and I don't get the thought process but he Clems around regardless. You gotta respect the clemminess.

 

[chicandtoughness]

Yeah. See I believe him and I am wary not to listen to someone I trust when they seem so confident.

I don't understand why you'd believe someone who just came on the thread, said "I haven't read much", saw the three meme posts Dubz posted, and immediately claimed Dubz was wolf. Whether Dubz is wolf or not is something else we can discuss, but it blows my mind that you jumped on Clem's thought train when it was a very unsubstantiated train to begin with. What is the basis for your trust?!

Eh, Dubz was essentially AFK yesterday, and she was asking her question at a whole group of folks who voted together. She could absolutely have been a wolf who relied on her pack to NK and then had a brain-slip on who it was; I've been in packs like that.

And Dubz is very pack-loyal, if she felt like she wasn't doing a good job she'd be inclined to pass the torch to a spectator.

I can understand that reasoning. And for some reason I just believe it's unlike Dubz to be careless like that

 

[Truenamer]

... and defensive streak is bad i presume

Pretty sure it's a big reason why a bunch of folks are voting for you, yeah

 

[IvyMoose]

Yes, see #485. Ivy's played around 5 games, which is enough to get a sense of wolf strategy, the concept of a strongarm (or at the least the ability to google the mafia wiki for it). I feel like others have brought up Ivy's noob-ness and she's leaning on it to get out of having to explain thought process.

You'd be surprised... i know very little strategy and regret to inform you I am not a quick learner in strategy games

I get you have to assume bc if I am a wolf you can't trust what I say, but since I am village, trust this: I literally don't know what wolf PR (or any village PR) could be even though I read the "semi-open" page many times

 

[Truenamer]

Like. Why are you sussing genny? Why is chic sussing genny? I feel so good about genny

I just have little ability to read genny and she keeps trying to boot me, so it edges her towards "suss" in my brain.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Pretty sure it's a big reason why a bunch of folks are voting for you, yeah

I think I've played almost every game Ivy has played and the reactivity still triggers me

 

[Viscernable]

My Kate vote is mostly based on her vote movements feeling weird on D1 (as I've expressed earlier) and a general... circularity to her posting today

Tell me about this circularity

 

[Viscernable]

This is not the way

IDK WHAT TO DO

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I just have little ability to read genny and she keeps trying to boot me, so it edges her towards "suss" in my brain.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

IDK WHAT TO DO

I think my POE is looking like Ivy, chic, Clem.
Vote one of those and tell me how it feels

 

[chicandtoughness]

honestly Kate is village lean bc I don't know how she plays and I am giving her the benefit of the doubt)

Ivy nooooo bb. This is not a reason to give someone a village lean :'(
If anything you should be more wary if you don't know how someone plays and they have pinged any strange tingly feelings.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I also think Ivy is not compatible with the latter two, unless he's in anti-spew

 

[alissa14]

Day 2 Tally: "Jess are you cooking a frittata in a saucepan? What is this, prison?"

Player	Voted by
Dubz/PSV	Clem, Kate
Kate	TrueNamer
Ivy	PSV, chic, miranda
TrueNamer	genny, Vis
Clem	Ivy
Leading:	@IvyMoose
Missing:
Yeet Close:	10PM CDT/11PM EDT TODAY (~4 MINUTES)
Last Updated:	10:55 PM EST / 9:55 PM CDT by Alissa

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Ivy nooooo bb. This is not a reason to give someone a village lean :'(
If anything you should be more wary if you don't know how someone plays and they have pinged any strange tingly feelings.

Oh, my. Not the place to discuss strange, tingly feelings 😳

 

[IvyMoose]

Pretty sure it's a big reason why a bunch of folks are voting for you, yeah

well... next game I will not defend myself (as hard).

anyways, I will say that since I am going down, so far little in terms of sus reads now, village lean genny? IDK how to read people I'm coming clean.

//

I think I've played almost every game Ivy has played and the reactivity still triggers me

UwU

 

[chicandtoughness]

This spread of votes makes me terrified lol.

 

[Truenamer]

Tell me about this circularity

Blarg, making me explain my position? Pretty wolfy of you, Vissy

But in short, I feel like her votes/positions haven't just had minimal justification, they've had zero clear wolf-hunting justification. It's just been "clem says so", "gotta self prez", and then back to "clem says so" with some vibes thrown in. I may be being unfair, but I don't have time to do a proper ISO or read through before 10pm. I will have time tomorrow if she and I are both alive, and I'll do it properly then.

 

[IvyMoose]

Ivy nooooo bb. This is not a reason to give someone a village lean :'(
If anything you should be more wary if you don't know how someone plays and they have pinged any strange tingly feelings.

I have done this before and... failed miserably. So sus read Kate? Lemme ask the audience!

 

[chicandtoughness]

Ivy, name your top three sus folks. If you were forced to vote three of us off the island, who would they be?

 

[Truenamer]

This spread of votes makes me terrified lol.

I hear you on that, worried we're having a repeat of Sunday.

I'm going to request that the vigilante aims carefully.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Blarg, making me explain my position? Pretty wolfy of you, Vissy

But in short, I feel like her votes/positions haven't just had minimal justification, they've had zero clear wolf-hunting justification. It's just been "clem says so", "gotta self prez", and then back to "clem says so" with some vibes thrown in. I may be being unfair, but I don't have time to do a proper ISO or read through before 10pm. I will have time tomorrow if she and I are both alive, and I'll do it properly then.

I... Agree
But also Kate swore she doesn't eat babies

 

[Viscernable]

AUGH

UNVOTE TRUE
UNVOTE IVY

 

[IvyMoose]

Ivy, name your top three sus folks. If you were forced to vote three of us off the island, who would they be?

Clem, miranda, maybe Vis? Just not sitting well with their style

 

[Viscernable]

Bite ivy

 

[Viscernable]

VOTE IVY

 

[chicandtoughness]

I agree with True, though my needle on True has moved towards neutral - Kate has spent a lot of time today justifying her trust in Clem's wolf read of Dubz/PSV, which... just doesn't sit right with me.

 

[Viscernable]

Jesus CHRIST

 

[IvyMoose]

Bite ivy

wolves bite O_O

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Clem, miranda, maybe Vis? Just not sitting well with their style

Wait, what about Kate?

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Oh I was expecting the thread to lock right at 10

 

[IvyMoose]

Wait, what about Kate?

IDK! we got a lot of content but can't read her well enough... slight village lean with uncertain meta? maybe slight wolf read if I wanna read into her style of interaction?

 

[potentialsheltervet]

This feels rebellious

 

[potentialsheltervet]

IDK! we got a lot of content but can't read her well enough... slight village lean with uncertain meta? maybe slight wolf read if I wanna read into her style of interaction?

I thought you said sus lean though?

 

[alleycat03]

Oh I was expecting the thread to lock right at 10

Can talk until writeup is posted

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I have done this before and... failed miserably. So sus read Kate? Lemme ask the audience!

Here

 

[chicandtoughness]

Ivy you said you were sussing Kate earlier? but she's not on your list? village lean genny?

(If you do end up flipping village please know there are no hard feelings - it's so hard for me sometimes to tell if someone is being genuine noob or being fake noob and actually a good wolf lol)

 

[alissa14]

YEET CLOSED - CHECK YA VOTES

Day 2 Tally: "Jess are you cooking a frittata in a saucepan? What is this, prison?"

Player	Voted by
Dubz/PSV	Clem, Kate
Kate	TrueNamer
Ivy	PSV, chic, miranda, Vis
TrueNamer	genny
Clem	Ivy
Leading:	@IvyMoose
Missing:
Yeet Close:	10PM CDT/11PM EDT TODAY
Last Updated:	11:01 PM EST / 10:01 PM CDT by Alissa

Thread will close once the day write up is posted

 

[alleycat03]

I’m at dinner on mobile so ~vote closed~ but Alissa’s doing the official stuff

 

[Truenamer]

This feels rebellious

WE ARE THE GODS IN CHAINS

 

[chicandtoughness]

slight village lean with uncertain meta? maybe slight wolf read

@___@

 

[alleycat03]

YEET CLOSED - CHECK YA VOTES

Day 2 Tally: "Jess are you cooking a frittata in a saucepan? What is this, prison?"

Player	Voted by
Dubz/PSV	Clem, Kate
Kate	TrueNamer
Ivy	PSV, chic, miranda, Vis
TrueNamer	genny
Clem	Ivy
Leading:	@IvyMoose
Missing:
Yeet Close:	10PM CDT/11PM EDT TODAY
Last Updated:	11:01 PM EST / 10:01 PM CDT by Alissa

Thread will close once the day write up is posted

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Alright chic is reading my mind rn

 

[IvyMoose]

Here

that was an actual question not a read lmao