D
deleted564680
Hey all,
I was bored this time of year, and I know there are a lot of opinions on the legitimacy of the Doximity residency rankings. However, we don't really have much else to go on and LOTS of programs/attendings are taking these rankings very seriously now (as opposed to the first year). Likely, these will be more "legitimate" as years go on.
Anyway, it was weird to me that Doximity doesn't list the rankings of all the programs in an overall fashion, so I did it myself. Using an excel file, I marked down the ranking for each institution in 15 of the specialities (I left out FM due to wide variance, hospitals with multiple affiliations, etc.). Since some programs don't offer all residencies, it was unfair to do an average ranking, so I came up with a points system (o for no program, .5 for rank >100, 1 for rank 51-100, 2 for 26-50, 3 for 11-25, 4 for 6-10, 5 for 2-5, 6 for no.1).
These are the rankings I obtained and I'm open to criticism, input, and modifications. Not a lot of surprises here but interesting that when compared to US News and World Report of top hospitals, Michigan residencies outperform their hospital (not even listed in top 15) and Cleveland Clinics residencies underperform their hospital (listed at no. 5 hospital but 17 on this list).
Overall:
1. MGH (95)
2. UCSF (87)
3. Johns Hopkins (85)
4. BWH (84)
5. WashU (74)
6. U Michigan (73)
7. Stanford (72)
8. UPMC (71)
9. Penn (69)
10. Mayo - MN (66)
11. U Washington (65)
12. Columbia - NY (63.5)
13. Duke (63)
14. UTSW (62)
14. Northwestern (62)
16. UCLA (61)
17. Cleveland Clinic (57)
17. NYU (57)
19. Emory (55)
20. Cornell - NY (51.5)
21. Baylor (51)
22. Vanderbilt (49)
23. BIDMC (47)
23. UNC (47)
25. U Iowa (46)
26. USC (45)
27. Cincinnati (44)
28. U Colorado (43.5)
29. Icahn - Mt. Sinai (43)
29. UCSD (43)
29. Miami - Jackson (43)
29. U Utah (43)
33. Ohio State (42)
34. Yale (40)
34. U Chicago (40)
36. Indiana U (39)
37. UVA (39)
38. UAB (38.5)
39. U Wisconsin (37.5)
40. UF - Gainesville (36.5)
Regions:
NE
MGH
Hopkins
BWH
UPMC
Penn
MW
WashU
Michigan
Mayo
NW
Cleveland Clinic
S
Duke
UTSW
Emory
Baylor
Vanderbilt
W
UCSF
Stanford
Washington
UCLA
USC
I was bored this time of year, and I know there are a lot of opinions on the legitimacy of the Doximity residency rankings. However, we don't really have much else to go on and LOTS of programs/attendings are taking these rankings very seriously now (as opposed to the first year). Likely, these will be more "legitimate" as years go on.
Anyway, it was weird to me that Doximity doesn't list the rankings of all the programs in an overall fashion, so I did it myself. Using an excel file, I marked down the ranking for each institution in 15 of the specialities (I left out FM due to wide variance, hospitals with multiple affiliations, etc.). Since some programs don't offer all residencies, it was unfair to do an average ranking, so I came up with a points system (o for no program, .5 for rank >100, 1 for rank 51-100, 2 for 26-50, 3 for 11-25, 4 for 6-10, 5 for 2-5, 6 for no.1).
These are the rankings I obtained and I'm open to criticism, input, and modifications. Not a lot of surprises here but interesting that when compared to US News and World Report of top hospitals, Michigan residencies outperform their hospital (not even listed in top 15) and Cleveland Clinics residencies underperform their hospital (listed at no. 5 hospital but 17 on this list).
Overall:
1. MGH (95)
2. UCSF (87)
3. Johns Hopkins (85)
4. BWH (84)
5. WashU (74)
6. U Michigan (73)
7. Stanford (72)
8. UPMC (71)
9. Penn (69)
10. Mayo - MN (66)
11. U Washington (65)
12. Columbia - NY (63.5)
13. Duke (63)
14. UTSW (62)
14. Northwestern (62)
16. UCLA (61)
17. Cleveland Clinic (57)
17. NYU (57)
19. Emory (55)
20. Cornell - NY (51.5)
21. Baylor (51)
22. Vanderbilt (49)
23. BIDMC (47)
23. UNC (47)
25. U Iowa (46)
26. USC (45)
27. Cincinnati (44)
28. U Colorado (43.5)
29. Icahn - Mt. Sinai (43)
29. UCSD (43)
29. Miami - Jackson (43)
29. U Utah (43)
33. Ohio State (42)
34. Yale (40)
34. U Chicago (40)
36. Indiana U (39)
37. UVA (39)
38. UAB (38.5)
39. U Wisconsin (37.5)
40. UF - Gainesville (36.5)
Regions:
NE
MGH
Hopkins
BWH
UPMC
Penn
MW
WashU
Michigan
Mayo
NW
Cleveland Clinic
S
Duke
UTSW
Emory
Baylor
Vanderbilt
W
UCSF
Stanford
Washington
UCLA
USC