I thought you have mentioned it before, which means after that game and all future games, trying to use that as a lis tell would be limited because he would likely have tried to compensate for the tell
That's fine, thanks for clarifying.I don't recall having ever mentioned it before this game. And I don't really use it as a "tell" because it is a bit more complex than just confrontational vs. not..... also has a bit to do with game theme, who is modding the game, how involved he's been, etc. He's been very non-confrontational in some games recently and been a villager, but he also wasn't as dedicated in those games....
I mean, if I'm wrong then
But overall I'm not getting the wolfy vibes from him because of the way he's acting. Whereas everyone else is seeing the way he's acting as suspicious. I just know he acts that way as a villager when he's actually been really active and interested in the game.
There are definitely several games I can recall where he was very argumentative and defensive as a wolf. Those are the times that stick out in my head and help solidify my vote. My original suspicions of him had to do with the weird vote one day where he didn't agree with plurality but then put a vote in that put us closer to plurality. If his defense of that move was the need to "get a vote in" that just seems silly. You don't need to get a vote in on some one that is clearly going down. It's better for the villagers to hold off on reaching plurality and actually talk, which is the whole point of the theme of this game, right?I don't recall having ever mentioned it before this game. And I don't really use it as a "tell" because it is a bit more complex than just confrontational vs. not..... also has a bit to do with game theme, who is modding the game, how involved he's been, etc. He's been very non-confrontational in some games recently and been a villager, but he also wasn't as dedicated in those games....
I mean, if I'm wrong then
But overall I'm not getting the wolfy vibes from him because of the way he's acting. Whereas everyone else is seeing the way he's acting as suspicious. I just know he acts that way as a villager when he's actually been really active and interested in the game.
Not to rain on everyone's parade, but out of the dead,
He claims in the post below that he explained his vote, but I don't see where that happened. Maybe someone else sees it? Here is a link to page 20 for your convenience.
I'll leave it up to @LetItSnow if he wants to respond. From what I remember, LIS said that we shouldn't be afraid to close early because of majority but instead should own our suspicions and lynch. Otherwise, wolves could use AFK sympathy to dodge a lynch.
Ok.... meant the first quote to be the one that Jilary posted. Missed it since my computer temporarily decided to bring up the battery settings menu whenever I tried to press enter.
First quote out of the two at the bottom of my post, not DVMD's quote at the very top of my post.
I felt that was more in response to the fact that I mentioned AM didn't come on to defend. I'm less concerned with that and more concerned with the early ending of a lynch cycle, which isn't helpful to villagers IMO.
KayDubs was #5 per my count. And with Zen unlynching, FB was also needed to reach plurality.
I blame my migraines. They make me post like my brain is on fire
I speculated about this earlier. Let me go back and find the FB posts that make me think the wolves figured her out.
FB liked the posts by Zen and Jilary. If there actually is a strongman role, I would think it would make the wolves take notice that FB suggested it for this game, and suggested it as the reason why WTF was killed so easily.
Yeah.... Day 10 with migraines....
Thank you for not calling me absolutely useless...
Nice catch! So maybe there really is a strongman!
It wouldn't even have to be from the likes, her own post would have been signal enough that she may have known there was a strongman. If it was just the likes it would make me suspicious of the people who made the posts (most likely to notice the likes) but since she made that post on her own...was her post before or after the others?
I believe FBs post was the first to mention a strongman.
Nope, I'm a villager so nothing to get caught about.
I disagree that my posts have been an overreaction. We've both said our peace about it and aren't getting anywhere with this argument, so
I find this enthusiasm hard to buy, since I basically said the same idea earlier (though much abbreviated) in a post where I called you wolfy. You did respond to that post, so I'm assuming you read it then too.Nice catch! So maybe there really is a strongman!
Sure, people can think me a convert option, but only the most paranoid of people should think me a possibility as an original wolf... You've even said so yourself earlier iirc
I guess my feeling is that AM was getting lynched with or without your vote. I work long hours too and I also often don't have a single moment to catch up during that time, so I understand. But I think it would have been better to hold off on your vote and allow discussion instead of pushing plurality. I don't believe conversation was stagnant that morning. I had intended to come back and make some comments as soon as I could, but when I came back the lynch was closed and the thread locked for the night.
I haven't hid my enthusiasm for the idea of a strongman. I actually just recently posted that I thought it was less likely since FB died because I didn't remember who posted about it in the first place.
Nevermind! Found it. I guess I was focusing on the first part of your post. I honestly didn't even consider the second part. At that point I just assumed that STL really did seer FB and didn't give any credit to your theory because you didn't specifically say FB was the first to post about the strongman role and I had forgotten that until you posted the quote. I honestly didn't think anything of FB liking my posts either. Kdubs has liked a bunch of my posts too. None of that really catches my eye.
I think kaydubs has liked 20 of my posts in the past two days. I think she's delirious due to her headaches, or you guys just don't realize sheer brilliance like she has
