This has a lot from D1 so sorry in advance..... *EDITED to remove things I didnt end up commenting on*
I second that, I was AM's sidecar in the BoWWnty game and her attitude was similar to what I see here. I think she legit got annoyed at genny. But I also buy that genny's vote on AM was a joke and then she prolonged that conversation. The whole genny - AM discussion doesn't seem wolfy to me yet.
ok - so when i said this it wasnt enough for mel?? Conflicting feelings, probs why I find myself frequently frustrated with Mel but for me hes leaning village. See quote further down -- i hate that i cant move them after the fact
The whole "AM is 90% village" thing within 4-6 pages of game thread is what I hold issue with, save for select few mechanical circumstances which really shouldn't be coming up in the first day of play unless necessary.
You are once again putting words in my mouth because I don't have an issue with cross-referencing. I think the certainty of the read this early, on a player historically difficult for many to read, is ripe for misdirection and caution should be heeded.
Spicy SP
My post below was to Fluff
I mean theres still no posts so why remove my pressure vote? Are you just concerned because im coming after one of your wolf friends??? should i be looking more at you like others??
Just yeeted youngkal for the reason I brought up above (pressure vote someone to show up doesn't seem legit) and then threatening that if I don't like it they'll go on my bandwagon.
I did not say I was going to jump on any bandwagon but rather maybe should be looking at them with their level of defense. This still rubs me the wrong way.
I do agree that the phrasing of kal's response to fluff felt a little aggressive, though I didn't read it exactly in context so I'll have to find it again
i didn't find it aggressive at all. fluff pressured kal to move a vote without a reason for moving it, and kal questioned fluff's motive for that pressure. if anything, fluff's yeet is an overreaction.
Lol I frequently get called aggress but thanks Genny <3
It's not really pressure if it goes away before anything comes from it though. Piled on votes definitely cause more pressure
Yes, my reason for not moving even when IVY popped on for 2 seconds.
I was planning to yeet youngkal because I don't buy the vote on Ivy before they threatened to come after me.
again.....
I haven't really thought about genny. I don't like Octopus voting for Ivy for the same reason youngkal did, but not sure they are a true noob or not. I'd rather give them the benefit of the doubt for now. I just didn;t like them both pressure voting Ivy to just show up.
I definitely see where this is coming from.
I’ve felt better about Fluff overall with their latest set of posts… I think I want to see where this goes. Also stoat was pretty pingy in the noob game too, so I’m willing to give it some time.
Unyeet Stoat
Yeet Kal
Yeet Kal
Post 934 made me feel a little suspicious. It just seemed like a heavier response than was necessary with the question marks and the wolf accusation. Not a very heavy feeling, but it's the best I've got on this D1.
Based on 1 message with some extra "??" makes me wonder if we were too close to getting a wolf D1
I gotta go where the read takes me
Yeet stoats
@WildZoo why stoat? Because I'm curious if it's the same reason I'm feeling.
@Animal Midwife -- you asked me why and this is why. I saw a vote move to bluey and then SP was saying that maybe they could get behind it and then the WZ post that said Bluey was close is why I settled here.
Cant moved this post to where it fits above but its Mel saying that the village reads I gave werent enough.
It’s sketchy. your reads on me, AM, genny, we’re lackluster and had no real reasoning behind them.
My neWW years resolution is to be nicer.
Hmm the stoaty votes were based on this, among other reasons
Also the vote progression suggests resistance to the vissy wagon and the rapid pile-on on YK
Again this!!! I feel like there was a wolf underpressure somewhere
My thoughts on genny: not a wolf kill.
I would be surprised if she was killed by wolves. I had genny on my neutral/leaning wolf list. I found it strange that she yeeted Ivy for inactivity and said that she would change her vote if Ivy came on and "spewed village," yet when Ivy came on genny didn't seem to react to it much.
this conversation between genny & zenge stuck out to me
genny defended kal in regards to kal's (aggressive?) comment towards fluff.
genny barely had any posts and this is really all I could pick up on. Makes me think that genny was killed by village/neutral and that maybe ivy, zenge, or fluff felt a little threatened. I do also think that might not be what happened, as the info on genny is small and since I've narrowed down to three people so quickly it feels very ballsy and not something I could see fluff or zenge doing. Ivy however I am stuck on, due to them wanting to cause a three way tie, I don't think I would be as surprised if they were involved with this
I feel like genny didnt change because Ivy really didnt come in to say much 🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️ more discussion on this post below
I like that logic a lot. It might be a villager. Genny was on my wolfier list as well and I was going to investigate her today. So maybe one of the villagers thought that indeed they are catching a wolf. It could also be that Ivy is a wolf, and Genny was an experienced and bold enough player. But she wasn't really onto Ivy that much, so it would be very risky for Ivy to have gone after genny just because genny yeeted her for inactivity
Im torn what to make of this Genny dead with Ivy comments -- discussed further down this post was just relevant.
I just don't get why all of their votes came seemingly out of the blue, and imo not for any super great reasons. Like I'm just not seeing why either of them deserved to be yeeted? Even after reading that part of the thread
Thank you - it felt very weird.
I'm getting pretty tired but I want to be completely caught up before I go to sleep. Here are my reads as of page 32. I don't think they will change a lot based on the next few pages.
Vets I'm feeling good about: AM, Mel, Zenge, Samac
Neutral Vets: VMH, Lawpy, Kal
Wolfy Vets/?????? (aka idk how to read them but they all seem sus): Sporty, Vis, April
Village-y Noobs: Pshelty and True
Neutral Noobs: Zuri, Puppydogtor, OctDoc, WorthlessO2, Stoat
Wolfy Noobs: Fluffy, violet, ivy
For the noobs, I am having a hard time distinguishing between noobness and actual wolfiness. Because a lot of it stands out to me and makes me cringe (not in a bad way, just can't think of a synonym) because it seems so incredibly wolf-like, but then I see a noob do it and I have a crisis over whether or not they're a wolf or just a noob.
I saved because I agree with some of their reads. I have AM, Mel and Lawpy more village. SP more wolf unsure on other returners. I also felt Fluff and Ivy as wolfie and other noobs I have minimal feels for.
Yeah, going to agree with samacs here. This is weird.
wish i remember why i pinned this ----
Don’t like Mel mainly cuz they’re giving me a hard time. Suspicious of April and vis because of the way they played in early game
Ahhh typical Mel - i got these feels too but its just mel being mel (although ive never see him wolf)
The tie thing was hella wolfy to me. It came off weird and she kind of attempted to say it didn’t matter and was a joke, then said she was serious, and it ended up being all confusing and it stood out to me as a noob wolf being clumsy and trying not to trip up when it gathered more attention and scrutiny.
Alley hitting all my feels. I thought I quoted them but I didnt so I will explain here. Ivy wasnt around most of the day and didnt really contribute much when they did come on but yet I took a hit for staying on my pressure vote (ON DAY 1) even after there were others, we werent questioned as a group, but me alone? Its day 1 and i didnt have feels for the votes that were gaining speed so why not stay where i wanted? Maybe WW has changed but ill keep voting where i have feels. I still dont feel great about Ivy because of the defense that was started against me (im looking at you fluff). I didnt like the Ivy didnt give a vote and then wanted to vote Genny but didnt and was going to make a 3-way tie instead? Rubs me wrong. Maybe im going too far here but then i wonder if Ivy is wolf and took out Genny or if she has some one time shot and took out Genny.
YK has been acting weird and defensive from the Ivy vote, stoat and a couple others have noted this. Lots of looking at Zenge's posting history right now (honestly not sure how this is super relevant, but dubz was leading this initiative). Dubz, lawpy, and potential also started looking at stoaty for the YK thing.
Did/do you have a reason other than my 1-2 posts? I feel a lot of well others said this sooooo its enough -- not a fan
Um, what are you confused about? It was because of the strange tone that fluff noted, even I remember that from like 20 pages ago. Woofy.
I'm confused as to how a few ?? made so many people suspicious and how in no time I was "WOLF" but look your claiming exactly what I said yesterday........ hows it feel
Ivy has been 100% missing and not said anything really helpful. Everyone has ignored this and piled on me instead.
Id say careful but youve already got the votes id warn you against 😂😂😂😂
Dana in the noob game posted a bunch of in-depth ISOs. She turned out to be a wolf.
True also posted an in-depth ISO. Perhaps he's using the same tactic as Dana.
I'm not really concerned with that right now because I am much more suspicious of Octo and Ivy.
im still skeptical of Ivy
