BOWWLING TOURNAMENT GAME THREAD

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
@Melchizedek you keep calling me out for missing information and yet you haven't said a single thing the multiple times I gave a very valid explanation for AM's defense of Zenge that's based on very strong evidence from previous games

Again. I would be willing to explore AM. BUT. The Zenge defense is not it.
AM does have a blind spot for Zenge. I think that’s an accurate statement to make. Even just her trying to claim him as an offspring through his marriage to shorty. But that’s not the only thing that’s stood out to me as incredibly odd about her play this game. It’s way more about her gameplay and how she’s misconstrued what’s happening on thread multiple times now.
 
not forgotten but rather you didnt ping me to put you in
like sketchy were my top wolf feels then middle were like more wolfie than not neutrals werent listed and then village
Your pings are really confusing to me… alleycat has been in the center of discussion all day yesterday along with Zenge, but you “forget” about her?
Along with your reluctance to vote Mel and bring violet again in the spotlight, you’re either thinking way out of the box or it’s wolfy AF.
 
Before I forget: I’m going to play AM’s favorite card to play

If I was a wolf I wouldn’t have killed Dubz N1. Yeah Visc was in her wolf reads but zenge and I were deep village and WZ likes to claim a zenge reading card. We could have ridden than for days.

Plus after the birthday kill and the D1 last minute wagon I pulled on her, she’d never forgive me
 
AM does have a blind spot for Zenge. I think that’s an accurate statement to make. Even just her trying to claim him as an offspring through his marriage to shorty. But that’s not the only thing that’s stood out to me as incredibly odd about her play this game. It’s way more about her gameplay and how she’s misconstrued what’s happening on thread multiple times now.
I’ve liked her gameplay a lot and it never stroke me as wolfy. What I never understood was her insists on voting meats. It made me sus of meats but I shouldn’t have been. @Animal Midwife im not sure if you addressed this but why meats over mel/ vis or others until now?
 
I have a couple of tests today so I'm unlikely to do an in-depth ISO on Mel until after close, but anyone else is welcome to compare what was said from N1 between flipped wolves up until Zenge's death (including how how Mel went from saying "Vis isn't it" for two consecutive cycles to switching to her minutes before the claim/"rojo").
***
Good luck on your exams!!
***
 
Before I forget: I’m going to play AM’s favorite card to play

If I was a wolf I wouldn’t have killed Dubz N1. Yeah Visc was in her wolf reads but zenge and I were deep village and WZ likes to claim a zenge reading card. We could have ridden than for days.

Plus after the birthday kill and the D1 last minute wagon I pulled on her, she’d never forgive me
But in the same logic, if AM was a wolf she’d have fought the pack to not kill DubZ on N1? I’m not sure who said that but it’s been mentioned before
 
Your pings are really confusing to me… alleycat has been in the center of discussion all day yesterday along with Zenge, but you “forget” about her?
Along with your reluctance to vote Mel and bring violet again in the spotlight, you’re either thinking way out of the box or it’s wolfy AF.
I think the reads she posted was back from D2? I’m not sure I completely understand her point about forgetting me, but I was a lot less present on like D2 b/c of school than I have been more recently.
 
AM does have a blind spot for Zenge. I think that’s an accurate statement to make. Even just her trying to claim him as an offspring through his marriage to shorty. But that’s not the only thing that’s stood out to me as incredibly odd about her play this game. It’s way more about her gameplay and how she’s misconstrued what’s happening on thread multiple times now.
Can you point out where you see that? You and Mel have mentioned it multiple times but I haven't seen a single quote pulled to support it other than her Zenge soft clear
 
But in the same logic, if AM was a wolf she’d have fought the pack to not kill DubZ on N1? I’m not sure who said that but it’s been mentioned before
Mel brought that up, but off of the fact that Dubz just modded the noob game. I could see AM honoring that or being okay with the Dubz kill since Dubz was hardcore wolfreading Vis.

And since we had the bounty game technically in between the noob game and this game, which Dubz played, I could see AM not actually “honoring” the recent modding since there was a game since the noob game.

I don’t think the NK of Dubz incriminates AM or exonerates her
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Can you point out where you see that? You and Mel have mentioned it multiple times but I haven't seen a single quote pulled to support it other than her Zenge soft clear
I got into a couple of squirmishes with her throughout this game. I know that’s not super helpful, but I’m in class rn playing so I can’t really pull it up while I’m on mobile. I did “pull quotes” when I directly responded to her and questioned her about things that made no sense to me.

One thing that stands out to me is her adamantly refusing to name someone who was her top wolf read. She just provided a broad POE and wouldn’t tell me who in it was the wolfiest. Plus the misconstruing of “most” people reading fluffy as village (which wasn’t true) and even the more recent mixup of pshelty and puppy with the vig shot on VMH claim. I believe there were several things Mel and Sporty saw too
 
Because your first point is fair, but it’s also contingent on saying that Visc bussed me early and then Zenge bussed me also on D1. I buy the Visc part but you are REALLY stretching if you want to say that they BOTH decided that putting me on the board D1 was a good idea when more often than not, it’s those out of nowhere last minute wagons that do me in.
Zenge voted you several minutes after Vis moved onto self-prezzing. Meaning you had a grand total of one (1) vote at EOD.
I call out anyone sitting on RVS votes that close to end of D1. You have noted this yourself so you’re arguing that a village tell of mine is wolfy?
It's not a village tell. You have said RVS regardless of your affiliation. You also called out multiple people for nonexistent RVS when, as pointed out at the time, it was only Vis and Lawpy (who happened to be voting for you). This was just the first instance of you having a conclusion disconnected with the threadstate.
Show me where I got in the way of Visc’s vote wagon? I pushed YK and never shut down discussion about Visc. Unlike you shutting people down for considering wolf!zenge.
Sure. Putting post numbers since ISOs are buggy.

#507, #1276, #1300, #1555, #1607, #1711, #1981, #2781, #2977, #3181, #3195, #3213, #3215, #3421 (nothing mentioned about kal being villagey nor Vis being a wolf)

Bonus: #3692
I was re assessing Visc the IRL night before that day and then had work the next morning so I couldn’t be on to do more analysis.
That's interesting considering all quotes except for one during this timeline still push kal over Vis.
 
But in the same logic, if AM was a wolf she’d have fought the pack to not kill DubZ on N1? I’m not sure who said that but it’s been mentioned before
I said that. I was considering this the next game after the noob game but apparently there have been other games that Dubz played in since, so the theory that AM wouldn’t let the pack kill Dubz N1 on a modding pass holds no water for me anymore
It's not a village tell. You have said RVS regardless of your affiliation.
I stand corrected, you’re pushing an NAI tell as wolfy.

#507, #1276, #1300, #1555, #1607, #1711, #1981, #2781, #2977, #3181, #3195, #3213, #3215, #3421 (nothing mentioned about kal being villagey nor Vis being a wolf)

Bonus: #3692
Someone check these posts while I’m mobile to see if it’s actually me defending or just me saying YK is wolfier than Visc because of my suspicions about YK hiding her vote protection.
 
Before I forget: I’m going to play AM’s favorite card to play

If I was a wolf I wouldn’t have killed Dubz N1. Yeah Visc was in her wolf reads but zenge and I were deep village and WZ likes to claim a zenge reading card. We could have ridden than for days.

Plus after the birthday kill and the D1 last minute wagon I pulled on her, she’d never forgive me
The number one issue with all of this is you're excluding that I was also high on dubz's village list. So if that really excludes you from being a wolf, then that makes me proven village as well.

Unless... maybe that's not a real clear.
 
I got into a couple of squirmishes with her throughout this game. I know that’s not super helpful, but I’m in class rn playing so I can’t really pull it up while I’m on mobile. I did “pull quotes” when I directly responded to her and questioned her about things that made no sense to me.

One thing that stands out to me is her adamantly refusing to name someone who was her top wolf read. She just provided a broad POE and wouldn’t tell me who in it was the wolfiest. Plus the misconstruing of “most” people reading fluffy as village (which wasn’t true) and even the more recent mixup of pshelty and puppy with the vig shot on VMH claim. I believe there were several things Mel and Sporty saw too
I wouldn’t hold it against her that she confused puppy and PSV.
I remember your discussion with her about her POE, but since she’s shared it several times, and given her integrity, I can see that as AM being stubborn.
I actually really appreciate that she defended me. Most people were reading me neutral rather than village.
Ppl reading me village off the top of my head: True, DubZ, AM, Lawpy, and later Violet, Blue and maybe PSV (?)
I think she was mostly attacking the fact that you’re reading me wolfy.
Others who found me wolfy and have voted for me are: Vis, Zenge, Mel, sporty, puppydogtor
 
I’ve liked her gameplay a lot and it never stroke me as wolfy. What I never understood was her insists on voting meats. It made me sus of meats but I shouldn’t have been. @Animal Midwife im not sure if you addressed this but why meats over mel/ vis or others until now?
Meats's positioning on POE members bothered me. She kept POEing people I was village reading and giving Mel a pass. Turns out she was just pocketed, but it's was difficult to distinguish between that and active buddying.
 
Meats's positioning on POE members bothered me. She kept POEing people I was village reading and giving Mel a pass. Turn out she was just pocketed, but it's was difficult to distinguish between that and active buddying.
Honestly, same. I was bothered that Mel and vis defended her so much. Alley too, but she was her PM partner… YK is still giving Mel a pass despite Mel pushing a YK vote on D3.
 
I wouldn’t hold it against her that she confused puppy and PSV.
I remember your discussion with her about her POE, but since she’s shared it several times, and given her integrity, I can see that as AM being stubborn.
I actually really appreciate that she defended me. Most people were reading me neutral rather than village.
Ppl reading me village off the top of my head: True, DubZ, AM, Lawpy, and later Violet, Blue and maybe PSV (?)
I think she was mostly attacking the fact that you’re reading me wolfy.
Others who found me wolfy and have voted for me are: Vis, Zenge, Mel, sporty, puppydogtor
As of right now, I believe your tracking claim since it was 1x use and N2 was the only night where we had duplicate tracking. I follow your logic and I get why you would've chosen me as your tracking target. Zenge was the other person besides myself pushing you hard early in the game, and I don't really see him doing that as extreme as he did if you're his packmate. I don't think it clears you 100%, but I am reading you as village right now.

BTW, people can village read you as a wolf and as a villager, and if they're a wolf they can push you as a misyeet. Just because she defended you does not clear her as a villager. If she is a wolf, she knows your affilation and can defend you and get you to village read her since she's defending you. If you're village reading her solely because she defended you, then she's pocketing you.
 
Honestly, same. I was bothered that Mel and vis defended her so much. Alley too, but she was her PM partner… YK is still giving Mel a pass despite Mel pushing a YK vote on D3.
I was right about Meats and about Zenge. I was also right about Vis, as she was in my wolf reads the entire game. Are my reads perfect? No. I defended VMH because nobody could actually explain to me what was so wolfy about her, and nothing she had done in PMs or on thread actually seemed as wolfy as AM claimed it was.
 
Mel and AM's interactions are striking me very strongly as v/w. AM is either doing exceptionally strong powerwolfing or she isn't a wolf. Personally, unless Mel flips village, I'm inclined to believe it's the latter. However, I'm working myself into a frenzy over the possibility of a failed yeet today so I'm at a bit of an impasse with whether or not we should go for the Mel yeet.
 
Zenge voted you several minutes after Vis moved onto self-prezzing. Meaning you had a grand total of one (1) vote at EOD.

It's not a village tell. You have said RVS regardless of your affiliation. You also called out multiple people for nonexistent RVS when, as pointed out at the time, it was only Vis and Lawpy (who happened to be voting for you). This was just the first instance of you having a conclusion disconnected with the threadstate.

Sure. Putting post numbers since ISOs are buggy.

#507, #1276, #1300, #1555, #1607, #1711, #1981, #2781, #2977, #3181, #3195, #3213, #3215, #3421 (nothing mentioned about kal being villagey nor Vis being a wolf)

Bonus: #3692

That's interesting considering all quotes except for one during this timeline still push kal over Vis.
I can't find a good way to search those posts right now but I can come back to them later.
 
Meats's positioning on POE members bothered me. She kept POEing people I was village reading and giving Mel a pass. Turns out she was just pocketed, but it's was difficult to distinguish between that and active buddying.
Who was she pocketed by? Vis and Zenge? Mel? Mel hasn't flipped so you can't actually state that she was pocketed.
 
Mel and AM's interactions are striking me very strongly as v/w. AM is either doing exceptionally strong powerwolfing or she isn't a wolf. Personally, unless Mel flips village, I'm inclined to believe it's the latter. However, I'm working myself into a frenzy over the possibility of a failed yeet today so I'm at a bit of an impasse with whether or not we should go for the Mel yeet.
AM hates wolfing, but she's actually really good at it. The fact that she's gotten this far without much scrutiny is proof that she's a strong wolf.

I am not sure what to do about the Mel situation. I believe his claim and I personally think that he is village. I think y'all are going to attempt to yeet him tonight, and I don't think it will work. YK confirmed that the ability he has is in the game, and they described it in the same manner. I don't know if it is a wolfy power or a village power though, because it could go either way. We have to decide whether or not he actually used the ability today or if he's actually using it tomorrow, and that is the hard part for me.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I’ve liked her gameplay a lot and it never stroke me as wolfy. What I never understood was her insists on voting meats. It made me sus of meats but I shouldn’t have been. @Animal Midwife im not sure if you addressed this but why meats over mel/ vis or others until now?
I can totally relate to this. I had VMH on my wolf list for a while for my own reasons, but seeing them on AM's list definitely influenced me when it shouldn't have.

Mel and AM's interactions are striking me very strongly as v/w. AM is either doing exceptionally strong powerwolfing or she isn't a wolf. Personally, unless Mel flips village, I'm inclined to believe it's the latter. However, I'm working myself into a frenzy over the possibility of a failed yeet today so I'm at a bit of an impasse with whether or not we should go for the Mel yeet.
I feel this. I think I'm sticking with Mel today, but if Mel is village then I will certainly be looking into AM next
 
Fluff, April is not the most well informed person to weigh in about whether I’m a villager or wolf. She’s not been able to read and is selectively choosing to see what she wants to see. This is bad villaging
The reason I’m asking April is because of something @potentialsheltervet hinted. PSV I don’t want to call out people but what do you think about the friend True had with him when he got killed?
 
I got into a couple of squirmishes with her throughout this game. I know that’s not super helpful, but I’m in class rn playing so I can’t really pull it up while I’m on mobile. I did “pull quotes” when I directly responded to her and questioned her about things that made no sense to me.

One thing that stands out to me is her adamantly refusing to name someone who was her top wolf read. She just provided a broad POE and wouldn’t tell me who in it was the wolfiest.
I literally did. We've been over this already.
Plus the misconstruing of “most” people reading fluffy as village (which wasn’t true)
It was true. Lo and behold Zenge was trying to capitalize on the situation. Mel trying to get on there last second is what bothered me too.
and even the more recent mixup of pshelty and puppy with the vig shot on VMH claim. I believe there were several things Mel and Sporty saw too
I don't know what other things you're referring to but I don't see how confusing shelter/puppy can be anything but NAI.
 
I can't find the post but I remember Mel at one point saying "If I'm wrong you can yeet me tomorrow" which is bugging me because it's either being truthful with the goal of tripping us up (Mel used the ability and it's protecting him today) or he's hoping we'll believe him for the shiggles (he's protecting himself tomorrow).
 
If Lawpy is a wolf then I’ve been completely tricked. I have not seen him as a wolf, but I would expect him to act at least a little bit different from the other games I’ve played with him while he’s been a villager.

Samac and pshelter both feel village to me. Same with the other people I mentioned, like Zenge and puppy. But I’m 100% getting paranoid that any of them could be a wolf who snuck into my village reads too easily.

But it’s been a few days (plus the modkills) of only villagers dying, and I feel like we need to catch a wolf pretty badly, so when the people I was wolf reading don’t seem wolfy anymore, then there’s something wrong with my reads. But I haven’t figured out yet what is wrong with my reads and why they aren’t meshing right in my brain anymore.
Hmm 🤔
 
PSV I don’t want to call out people but what do you think about the friend True had with him when he got killed?
I'm conflicted. I'm thinking it's talking about Mel having protected him D2 from the yeet but Mel's protection not extending to NKs from wolves. It could be talking about something else but it would make sense to me.
 
Come on. I suspected Zenge was a wolf when nobody else did, and I’ve been explaining it to everyone else why I thought he was a wolf for what feels like days now.
alleys pls it looked like you had zenges in your village reads and began expressing doubts on him after the vissy flip. While it’s true others were reading zenges villagey, i’m not sure how this shows how you were reading zenges wolf when no one else did
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Okay yeah I was wrong. I went back and it looks like True died N3 and Mel would've protected him D3 then, so could've still protected YK D2.
So if that's the reason you're planning to yeet YK @justafluff don't do it because I misremembered.
 
But why YK? Am I getting my timeline wrong?
Was true's death N2 or N3?
N2.
You said something about April that would conflict with what Mel is claiming. That’s what I’m trying to figure out
YK because she’s pushing a violet vote out of nowhere. But if Mel’s innocent, then a YK vote doesn’t make sense.
@youngkal Mel claims he protected you but you re probably wolf and that vis blocked you so that you can have village cred. Yet you still avoid voting for Mel. Why is that??