Caribbean + Genius = ?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
You guys are missing the point of this thread. I should've used a better word than "genius".

My question was this: if I am going to the Caribbean because I didn't put in my full effort as opposed to having those stats with max effort, how difficult would a Caribbean success be? Simple question. Didn't mean for the attitude. Honestly I LOL'd after re-reading my initial post on this thread. It came across in a way I didn't intend.

Nah, you posted multiple times again in this same thread on the first page insinuating the same thing you were in your original post.
 
You guys are missing the point of this thread. I should've used a better word than "genius".

My question was this: if I am going to the Caribbean because I didn't put in my full effort as opposed to having those stats with max effort, how difficult would a Caribbean success be? Simple question. Didn't mean for the attitude. Honestly I LOL'd after re-reading my initial post on this thread. It came across in a way I didn't intend.

I'm not going to answer this question because you asked it 3 times already. You do realize that if you actually dedicated a few months and retook that MCAT and got a 35+, you would be competitive for a lot of top tier MD schools. 27 is below average at pretty much all US MD schools and barely average at DO. Seriously, if you would put some damn effort into your education, you would have a decent shot at a Top 20 school likely. Now, you will suffer from your laziness. Also, you should probably stop talking and looking for validation which nobody I repeat NOBODY on here is going to give you.
 
You guys are missing the point of this thread. I should've used a better word than "genius".

My question was this: if I am going to the Caribbean because I didn't put in my full effort as opposed to having those stats with max effort, how difficult would a Caribbean success be? Simple question. Didn't mean for the attitude. Honestly I LOL'd after re-reading my initial post on this thread. It came across in a way I didn't intend.
Let's say that you go on to enroll in the best Caribbean medical school (pick one, I'm sure any of them will take you).
Let's say your genius finally shines through and you score 255 on Step 1.
How will a Program Director interpret this data?
What are the likely reasons for a person who could get that score attending a Carib school?

Hint: it isn't a pretty differential.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
As @gyngyn mentioned, schools don't only look at your numbers as an indication of how well your performance is, but they can make inferences based on certain decisions you made. If there's one damn person on this thread you should listen to, it's @gyngyn or @Goro. They are admissions officers themselves and they will tell you how wrong you are.
 
I'm not going to answer this question because you asked it 3 times already. You do realize that if you actually dedicated a few months and retook that MCAT and got a 35+, you would be competitive for a lot of top tier MD schools. 27 is below average at pretty much all US MD schools and barely average at DO. Seriously, if you would put some damn effort into your education, you would have a decent shot at a Top 20 school likely. Now, you will suffer from your laziness. Also, you should probably stop talking and looking for validation which nobody I repeat NOBODY on here is going to give you.
This...is a bit misinformed.

A 35/3.6 is a below average LizzyM for many, if not all, of the Top 20, especially with a prior 27 as many schools average the scores together. If all there is on the rest of his app is some halfhearted volunteering, plus probably no good letter sources and no mention of research...he'd be lucky to get one or two interviews at schools well below Top 20.

For some DOs a 3.6/27 is meh but at others it's a good step above their median. He should (if he isn't just an awesome troll) go for the DOs that his stats can carry him into >>> Carib.
 
If you were such a genius you would've gotten a better MCAT score and get into US MD or DO and have the brains to figure out not to go to Caribbean in the first place!!!!!!!
 
This...is a bit misinformed.

A 35/3.6 is a below average LizzyM for many, if not all, of the Top 20, especially with a prior 27 as many schools average the scores together. If all there is on the rest of his app is some halfhearted volunteering, plus probably no good letter sources and no mention of research...he'd be lucky to get one or two interviews at schools well below Top 20.

For some DOs a 3.6/27 is meh but at others it's a good step above their median. He should (if he isn't just an awesome troll) go for the DOs that his stats can carry him into >>> Carib.

Top 20 was a bit of an exaggeration lol.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
This...is a bit misinformed.

A 35/3.6 is a below average LizzyM for many, if not all, of the Top 20, especially with a prior 27 as many schools average the scores together. If all there is on the rest of his app is some halfhearted volunteering, plus probably no good letter sources and no mention of research...he'd be lucky to get one or two interviews at schools well below Top 20.

For some DOs a 3.6/27 is meh but at others it's a good step above their median. He should (if he isn't just an awesome troll) go for the DOs that his stats can carry him into >>> Carib.

Just for reference, here is a compilation of median MCAT scores for the top 20:

37, 37, 36, 35, 38, 38, 37, 36, 35, 37, 31, 37, 34, 37, 37, 36, 35, 37, 37, 37

The <36 scores are UCSF, Duke, UWash, UCLA, and UCSD respectively.

Median GPAs all hover between 3.80 and 3.95. Excluding UWash, as that isn't likely an option for OP anyway, the lowest possible LizzyM score is 72. So yes, 35/3.6 (71) is below every Top 20 school except for UWash.
 
I work at a hospital and once asked a pizza delivery guy for a ride home because the bus system had gotten stalled.
He and I ended up doing a lot of talking, and he discussed how he got kicked out of a Caribbean med school because he was
"smart and knew what it took to be a doctor but just didn't apply himself because the classes were boring."
Really nice guy, but it's eerie how similar his story sounds to what I presume to be the beginning of yours.

Anyway good luck in the Caribbean. I think it's a really good idea.
8380600e005e38b3282169f68d174eb0.png
 
Just for reference, here is a compilation of median MCAT scores for the top 20:

37, 37, 36, 35, 38, 38, 37, 36, 35, 37, 31, 37, 34, 37, 37, 36, 35, 37, 37, 37

The <36 scores are UCSF, Duke, UWash, UCLA, and UCSD respectively.

Median GPAs all hover between 3.80 and 3.95. Excluding UWash, as that isn't likely an option for OP anyway, the lowest possible LizzyM score is 72. So yes, 35/3.6 (71) is below every Top 20 school except for UWash.
Yeah, and that's the Top 20 USNews Research. Top 20 by LizzyM last year were

76.5, 76.3, 75.7, 75.2, 75.1, 75.0, 74.9, 74.5, 74.3, 74.1, 74.0, 74.0, 73.9, 73.8, 73.8, 73.7, 73.5, 73.5, 73.5, 73.1
 
This has got to be a troll thread. That or narcissistic personality disorder.
You should never label someone with a disorder because of bad behavior. There are honestly people who cannot control it.

Well, to be fair a lot of people are arrogant dinguses because they have insanely impressive stats and resumes. This is just the rare case of an arrogant dingus with absolutely nothing even good going for him

I second this.
 
He sadly is not a troll. He is a poor misguided individual, that thinks he is to good to be a DO. I have read at lest two treads made by him, and they all come back to him being stuck up.
 
Yeah because the preclinical years are sooooooooooo different hahahahaha

pff, the preclinical years are cake. You study -> you learn the material -> you get the grade you deserve.

Third year you get to work your ass off and as your entire grade is a subjective evaluation by some catty OBGyn about how much "enthusiasm" you put into doing a vaginal exam in a 350 lb non-English speaking woman who happens to be menstruating.

/with apologies to gyngyn. I'm sure you're awesome and objective... 😎
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
If the letters at the end of your name mean more to you than practicing medicine, you are in the wrong field.
 
pff, the preclinical years are cake. You study -> you learn the material -> you get the grade you deserve.

Third year you get to work your ass off and as your entire grade is a subjective evaluation by some catty OBGyn about how much "enthusiasm" you put into doing a vaginal exam in a 350 lb non-English speaking woman who happens to be menstruating.

/with apologies to gyngyn. I'm sure you're awesome and objective... 😎
No one ever said this was for the faint of heart.
 
If I apply myself, bring up my GPA with 2 semesters, study for and retake the MCAT, will I have a decent shot at a US MD school? I do have 1 publication and 1 strong rec letter, but that's about it for ECs. And I see that most schools require a minimum of 5 letters :O
 
If I apply myself, bring up my GPA with 2 semesters, study for and retake the MCAT, will I have a decent shot at a US MD school? I do have 1 publication and 1 strong rec letter, but that's about it for ECs. And I see that most schools require a minimum of 5 letters :O

Get more letters, volunteer at a hospital, get some shadowing, retake that MCAT for a 35 or even a 40+, and you will have a shot.
Just lose the ego. It will not help you at all.
 
No one ever said this was for the faint of heart.

Eh, I actually liked what I got to do on that rotation (I learned better surgical technique than when I was on surgery). What I hated was the fact that I was considered "unprofessional" for watching sports highlights at 4am on my laptop during a night that the OB floor had 2/14 beds full while the all female resident crew read fashion blogs.

Seriously, the point stands. If you have a low bullsh-t tolerance, med school is not for you.
 
Hello Y'all,

Due to personal, non-academic reasons, I do not feel that my GPA, MCAT, and ECs properly reflect my ability to succeed in medical school. I literally did not study for the MCAT, yet scored a 27. I just cram 30 minutes before my exams and got a 3.6 GPA. I have a few volunteering activities, which I nearly got kicked out of because they are so boring (the triviality of the tasks given to volunteers bothers be, I love the patient interaction of course). Anyways, I know that in med school if I study, I will be able to more than master the material.

So...what if I go the Caribbean and totally rock all the classes? How hard will it be to graduate a successful doctor and match into a respectable residency?

I honestly hate college with a passion, and just want to move out and begin med school where real medical training occurs (handing out check in forms in the ER is nothing nothing nothing nothing at all like being an ER doctor, obviously). I just can't wait to start med school, so I want to start at the Caribbean.

TL;DR: if you are a genius who would have done well in a US med school, and then you go to the Caribbean and graduate with flying colors, can you still be a successful doctor?

Thanks!

Poor @mimelim is seriously facepalming now. To do him justice, below are his excellent posts that should be stickied in the Caribbean forums to inform the uninformed.

Systematically.

#1 Where you go to medical school matters for residency placement. Anyone that tells you otherwise doesn't know anything about residency or is lying to you. I'm sorry, but your father doesn't know what he is talking about. First, there is a gap between US MD schools and US DO schools and then a substantially larger gap between those two and everything else. You will be at a huge disadvantage coming out of the Caribbean. For every success story, there are 10, if not more unhappy stories and probably 10 more disaster stories. What people will debate is, how much difference between different US MD schools there is. For the vast majority of applicants (90%+) the US MD schools are functional equivalents. However, if you are looking at going into a competitive specialty or a competitive academic program in any specialty, what school you go to matters.

#2 Where you go to medical school matters for your education. Your first two years of school are going to be basic science and organ system classroom learning. There is very little difference between different schools. Some would even make the argument that a well organized, motivated student could self study the first two years and turn out just as well as any US MD student. What is different between schools and where there is a huge difference between US MD schools and everything else is the quality of rotation sites. If you are at Hopkins, you rotate at only Hopkins hospitals, unless you choose to do some electives elsewhere. And yes, where you do your clinical rotations matter. Can you still learn and do well not going to a big name program, yes. But, you are going to be at a disadvantage later.

#3 https://www.aamc.org/download/321518/data/factstable25-4.pdf

If you take all 3600 Caucasian students that had a 3.60-3.79 PGA and a 27-29 MCAT, 45% of them got into a US MD school. DO NOT MISINTERPRET this statistic. This does NOT mean that you have a 45% chance of getting into medical school. It means that a good number of people with your statistics will get into medical school somewhere. The ones that do, a) applied smart and broad, b) had other things on their applications that made them superior to the others in the applicant pool. It is well worth taking a full year to apply once and apply well. With good planning and some buffing, you stand a reasonable shot at getting into a US MD program. Forget the minors/double majors. They are meaningless. If you prepared inadequately for the MCAT the first time, you should evaluate if you can reasonably improve on your score. You should retake if in your estimation you can on average improve your score by 3 or more points. Then you should focus on continuing your ECs and developing stronger connections for your letters.
#1 Functionally MD = DO. A DO can do every job that an MD can.

#2 Yes, there is bias in the community and among physicians against DO. It is logical, after all, almost by definition US MD students had better scores than their US DO counterparts. People tend to look down on others they see as being 'inferior' to them. A bit silly, but such is life. I would argue (with faculty and a father in this group) that physicians who trained in the 70s and 80s hold the largest bias. But, the reality is that the vast majority of the public and people at large don't know the difference and are going to go to you if you are a good practitioner, regardless of the two letters after your name.

#3 Your residency chances are much higher as a DO than a Caribbean MD. Thus, your chances of being employed as a physician after you invest a lot of time, money and effort are significantly higher if you go DO over Caribbean MD.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Schools do not require 5 letters minimum...

@ComputerGuy365 rein it in buddy. Advice like "Just score 99.9th percentile on the MCAT and you can go MD!" shows off your nonexistent experience with the MCAT and the collegiate premed game

If I applied right now to DO, how likely is it that I'd get accepted?
Pretty good with a pub and your stats, especially at the lower DO's with median MCATs 24-27
 
Ok so...I guess my questions shifts to this...how bad will it be to have a DO instead of an MD? Would it just get a few bad looks from colleagues or would it prevent me from getting a decent job/residency?
 
You guys are missing the point of this thread. I should've used a better word than "genius".

My question was this: if I am going to the Caribbean because I didn't put in my full effort as opposed to having those stats with max effort, how difficult would a Caribbean success be? Simple question. Didn't mean for the attitude. Honestly I LOL'd after re-reading my initial post on this thread. It came across in a way I didn't intend.

Imagine what you could do if you actually tried...
So why not actually try it?

If you started at a Caribbean school next month, by the time you actually get a residency, you'd be no later in the process than if you spend the extra three years actually preparing for medical school.

You say you're wicked smart.
Your behavior says otherwise.
 
Ok so...I guess my questions shifts to this...how bad will it be to have a DO instead of an MD? Would it just get a few bad looks from colleagues or would it prevent me from getting a decent job/residency?

It's time to show a little initiative and go do some searching on your own.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I'm going to compare your situation to a one night stand.

She looks really attractive, she's got tits, a nice smile, even an attractive personality as a bonus.

For some odd reason, she's really attracted to you. She wants you, so you say heck, I'll do it, surely nothing bad will happen to ME. People have done it , they've made it out alright, so will I!

At first, it goes really great. You love it. She's excited, you're excited. FINALLY, all of this buildup and you have gotten something you once dreamed about.

It ends. She's gone the next day, life goes on. You forget about it.

Before you know it, sometime later, you get this pain in your crotch, a massive outbreak of sores, and you have to go see the doctor. Tests come back, you've got the clap.

Here's a summary in case you weren't following.

This girl is the Caribbean, she's pretending she's interested because she wants satisfaction or is getting over something. In this case, the school wants your money. It's a pretty attractive deal because you like sex and women, otherwise known as an MD degree.

The time period after the initial "encounter" (your admission), where you go about living normally, is the first two years at a Caribbean school.

Now that STD test is your Step 1 score. No one wants to match with you anymore.
 
I'm going to compare your situation to a one night stand.

She looks really attractive, she's got tits, a nice smile, even an attractive personality as a bonus.

For some odd reason, she's really attracted to you. She wants you, so you say heck, I'll do it, surely nothing bad will happen to ME. People have done it , they've made it out alright, so will I!

At first, it goes really great. You love it. She's excited, you're excited. FINALLY, all of this buildup and you have gotten something you once dreamed about.

It ends. She's gone the next day, life goes on. You forget about it.

Before you know it, sometime later, you get this pain in your crotch, a massive outbreak of sores, and you have to go see the doctor. Tests come back, you've got the clap.

Here's a summary in case you weren't following.

This girl is the Caribbean, she's pretending she's interested because she wants satisfaction or is getting over something. In this case, the school wants your money. It's a pretty attractive deal because you like sex and women, otherwise known as an MD degree.

The time period after the initial "encounter" (your admission), where you go about living normally, is the first two years at a Caribbean school.

Now that STD test is your Step 1 score. No one wants to match with you anymore.

ok-then.gif


That's enough internet for tonight.. lol.
 
If I applied right now to DO, how likely is it that I'd get accepted?
Listen bud, I was in your shoes at one point hoping to burn through med school as quickly as possible, which is the vibe I'm picking up from all your questions. In hindsight, the much wiser decision is to take your time and make sure you apply with your strongest possible application. Being a doctor with a carribean degree at 25 over a US MD or DO at 28 is insane... young doctors get older and the Doogie Howser boy genius novelty disappears. You know what doesn't change? The school on your diploma. Do it once and do it right.
 
Ok so...I guess my questions shifts to this...how bad will it be to have a DO instead of an MD? Would it just get a few bad looks from colleagues or would it prevent me from getting a decent job/residency?
This question has been answered countless times across multiple threads you have started. You clearly either didn't care enough to read the responses, or lack the intelligence to understand them. I can't believe I'm going to say this, but I think the Caribbean is too good for you. Medicine is not for you, period. If you want people to blow smoke up your a** for not doing anything, go become a chiropractor (you get to wear a white coat and everything!)
 
This question has been answered countless times across multiple threads you have started. You clearly either didn't care enough to read the responses, or lack the intelligence to understand them. I can't believe I'm going to say this, but I think the Caribbean is too good for you. Medicine is not for you, period. If you want people to blow smoke up your a** for not doing anything, go become a chiropractor (you get to wear a white coat and everything!)

Chiropractors have DC or something, Caribs have MD. It's all about the MD imho.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad