- Joined
- Apr 23, 2007
- Messages
- 353
- Reaction score
- 1
RATIONAL and REASONABLE DEBATE on this topic
NO FLAMING PLEASE
We have had numerous arguments and discussions regarding this topic on the OD and OMD forum on here. I feel this it the most rational solution to the issue of "establishing the lines" regarding primary eye care and ophthalmic surgery. We all know these facts are evident:
1) Dentists do NOT attend medical school and yet have Oral Maxillofacial Surgery (OMS). This is a 4-7 year resdency depending on the school and program. 80% of these surgeons have a certificate and do NOT have an MD (source American Dental Association).
2) The fact that the "eye" is a realm contained within optometry and medicine fuels the anger--discontent within the ranks of medicine because unlike dentistry which has no analagous route within medicine----optometrists and ophthalmologists share some territory.
3) Optometry from 1971 to present 2008 has evolved considerably in scope and training with OD's becoming the country's primary eye doctors (~75% of primary eye care is provided by OD's---source AOA, APHA, etc.....)
4) The Political climate surrounding optometry and ophthalmology is a heated one with absolute hatred for each other at an ORGANIZATIONAL LEVEL. Yet there is a lot of cooperation at the practitioner level.
PLEASE HAVE A RATIONAL OPINION AND LEAVE YOUR EMOTIONS OUT OF IT.....
1) For or against an optometry surgery residency (analagous to OMS) to solve the problem of surgery versus non surgery...
"JUST GO TO MEDICAL SCHOOL" is NOT an answer!!!!!!!!
2) If you are "for" then how would you set up the program (ie. length, requirement for entry, etc....)
Let the discussion begin.......
NO FLAMING PLEASE
We have had numerous arguments and discussions regarding this topic on the OD and OMD forum on here. I feel this it the most rational solution to the issue of "establishing the lines" regarding primary eye care and ophthalmic surgery. We all know these facts are evident:
1) Dentists do NOT attend medical school and yet have Oral Maxillofacial Surgery (OMS). This is a 4-7 year resdency depending on the school and program. 80% of these surgeons have a certificate and do NOT have an MD (source American Dental Association).
2) The fact that the "eye" is a realm contained within optometry and medicine fuels the anger--discontent within the ranks of medicine because unlike dentistry which has no analagous route within medicine----optometrists and ophthalmologists share some territory.
3) Optometry from 1971 to present 2008 has evolved considerably in scope and training with OD's becoming the country's primary eye doctors (~75% of primary eye care is provided by OD's---source AOA, APHA, etc.....)
4) The Political climate surrounding optometry and ophthalmology is a heated one with absolute hatred for each other at an ORGANIZATIONAL LEVEL. Yet there is a lot of cooperation at the practitioner level.
PLEASE HAVE A RATIONAL OPINION AND LEAVE YOUR EMOTIONS OUT OF IT.....
1) For or against an optometry surgery residency (analagous to OMS) to solve the problem of surgery versus non surgery...
"JUST GO TO MEDICAL SCHOOL" is NOT an answer!!!!!!!!
2) If you are "for" then how would you set up the program (ie. length, requirement for entry, etc....)
Let the discussion begin.......