# Destroyer GC 264

#### docdew

2+ Year Member
The solution in this question states that the Ksp = [Pb]^2. I am confused as to why it is not Ksp = [Pb][2I]^2?

Thanks again!

#### LuckBloodandSweat

2+ Year Member
Since there's already Pb ions in the solution it's less soluble so you get Ksp= [Pb]^2. Feel free to pm me if you wanna ask about gchem/math. My test is tomorrow but helping others out and talking might calm me down a bit

OP

#### docdew

2+ Year Member
Since there's already Pb ions in the solution it's less soluble so you get Ksp= [Pb]^2. Feel free to pm me if you wanna ask about gchem/math. My test is tomorrow but helping others out and talking might calm me down a bit
Ah, I see now. I misread the question. Didn't realize that there were already Pb ions in the solution of PbI2 itself. Whoops. Thanks!

orgoman22
OP

#### docdew

2+ Year Member
On second thought, I still don't exactly understand it. I ran it by a few other kids from my review class, and they seem to be stumped as well. @LuckBloodandSweat, do you think you'd mind elaborating further? (i'm doing my best to help ease your nerves here!)

#### LuckBloodandSweat

2+ Year Member
No problem give me a few minutes I'll write something down and post it here

#### LuckBloodandSweat

2+ Year Member
Let me know if that's clear enough lol

#### Attachments

• 32.7 KB Views: 9
OP

#### docdew

2+ Year Member
Let me know if that's clear enough lol
ha yes, I was able to see it. No worries, and thank for the awesome response! But I unfortunately am still unclear as to why it is X instead of 2X exactly. I understand that there's a common ion effect taking place here, but how exactly did you calculate/determine that it is X instead of 2X for I- ions? Did you divide by two?

#### LuckBloodandSweat

2+ Year Member
I think the way any common ion effect works is that you just take away the coefficient you'd normally have but you would still square/cube/whatever function it would normally have. Sorry if I didn't make that clear.

OP

#### docdew

2+ Year Member
I think the way any common ion effect works is that you just take away the coefficient you'd normally have but you would still square/cube/whatever function it would normally have. Sorry if I didn't make that clear.
Hmm ok. Yeah, that does seem to be the case, I'm just still a bit curious for even more elaboration as to exactly what is going on here and how the common ion effect affects the coefficients.

Thank you very much for the help!

I wonder, @orgoman22, would you possibly be able to elaborate on this further?

#### fit2

2+ Year Member
Maybe it has something to do with when you throw I ions in the solution it's not like you add them in a +2X fashion. But when I combined with Pb it's gonna be 2I's for every 1 Pb. I think it's pretty common (haha) for common ion effect problems. Basically you don't have the coefficients when you do the ice table because the ions aren't dissociating in a set fashion. You're just throwing ions in the solution which then they combine in an orderly fashion (for example 2 I's for every Pb) to form the precipitate. maybe someone else can add something. Orgoman22 would definitely be your best bet haha