England - Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Right universe, wrong character. I did get a description of who took it, but didn't put it together until the hint. The fact you guessed the universe makes me very sus of you right now

It is a tinfoil, for sure. But otherwise the jump she made to having a pretty solid guess on who took my teapot means she has some additional knowledge that I don't know how she got but I can come up with a bunch of sus methods
So you’re telling me I’m such a good god damn tinfoiler about a ****ing teapot that my googling where the Sherwood Forest is in relation to everything else in England and all this stuff is that I was at least mostly right?
 
Day One - Green and Pleasant Land - Vote Tally

Capri () -
AM (2) - alissa, TME
Stagg (0) -
Sporty (0) -
Cray (0) -
Alissa (1) - finn
Zenge (3) - genny, sunshine, cray
DocE (6) - April, Dina, zenge, alleycat, Shorty, mkg
April (4) - Dubz, MsP, samac, Bread
Shorty (1) - stagg
Ms P (1) - bobloblaw
sunshine (3) - LIS, VMH, Barks
MKG (1) - DocE
Stagg (1) - AM
samac (1) - SAR
DocE changed to April just so ya know
 
I see some votes are swinging onto me. Cool, cool 😔 Debating between going back and actually reading today's posts after I skimmed all day or trying to see where I am on the tally and writing a role reveal if need be

In what will be the most potentially wolfy thing I will say all day: if you have a roll that's important I would definitely roll reveal right now. But that's my opinion because I just dropped my vote for you based on thinking your play is bad and would feel really bad if you had a convincingly and genuinely good role. You can take my advice and do with it whatever you want
 
@samac how confident are you that whoever stole my teapot is in the North group?

Because I have grave doubts that the slot is village
I’m pretty confident.
but I wish you would have kept quiet and waited because I’ve had breadcrumbs out that I wanted them to follow thinking they were village and if they would have jumped on that and then you revealed that would have been perfecto.
 
So you’re telling me I’m such a good god damn tinfoiler about a ****ing teapot that my googling where the Sherwood Forest is in relation to everything else in England and all this stuff is that I was at least mostly right?

Well I guess we're not being cryptic anymore
 
So were you lying about your sunshine read?

Ok, this seems REALLY disingenuous. I'm loath to defend another player to another player for obvious reasons, but ...

Alissa LITERALLY had just posted that she felt sunshine seemed frustrated villager. Seems like a pretty clear reason she changed her read. And then AM seems to throw shade with the lying comment. Makes no sense. Sketch.

I'm not quite in agreement with Alissa - I'm waffling ... I was having the same questions about whether sunshine was genuine villager frustration ... but I at least see her train of thought and can't figure out why AM would post that bit about lying.
 
In what will be the most potentially wolfy thing I will say all day: if you have a roll that's important I would definitely roll reveal right now. But that's my opinion because I just dropped my vote for you based on thinking your play is bad and would feel really bad if you had a convincingly and genuinely good role. You can take my advice and do with it whatever you want
I'll pre-write it and only post it if I get another vote or two, or if people start pulling off of you to put me in the lead.
 
Ok, this seems REALLY disingenuous. I'm loath to defend another player to another player for obvious reasons, but ...

Alissa LITERALLY had just posted that she felt sunshine seemed frustrated villager. Seems like a pretty clear reason she changed her read. And then AM seems to throw shade with the lying comment. Makes no sense. Sketch.

I'm not quite in agreement with Alissa - I'm waffling ... I was having the same questions about whether sunshine was genuine villager frustration ... but I at least see her train of thought and can't figure out why AM would post that bit about lying.
If you lok at the timing for my post and her reasoning in a separate post, you'll see that I initially missed it.
 
I’m pretty confident.
but I wish you would have kept quiet and waited because I’ve had breadcrumbs out that I wanted them to follow thinking they were village and if they would have jumped on that and then you revealed that would have been perfecto.

Yeah but trust me with the other parts of their ability, they would have known not to take those breadcrumbs.

Either way, if you're confident, then there's at least one woof between April, AM, and Finn
 
Woops. Fixed. Thanks.

The April wagon taking off close to yeet close feels weird to me.
It is and it isn't. It seems some people have pretty good logic for it. And also it's incredibly common day one. Which again, sort of speaks to how little information you're working with day one.
 
Uh. Over the top much? "veteran players being rude to newer players"?

Which veteran playerS? There are more than one? Rude how?

And why do you guys care sooooooo much about DocE (who I assume you're talking about, though I don't talk about him as a pleural "players") and give AM a free pass for the constant condescending, rude tone AM has been using?

I'm ok with the sunny vote, obviously, but the line of thought to get there seemed really weird.
Oh, for reference that's not my opinion, that's a paraphrase of something that sunny complains about in every game and I was pointing out that DocE's play is more extreme than previous examples I can think of where she was extremely upset about how much people were bullying her, but seemed to have very little problem with it here in this context
 
Do you have the same opinion toward's AM's response?
I don’t love it but I think AM usually tends to err towards “more info and sharing thoughts makes it harder for wolves to hide” over “don’t engage in speculation that can help wolves”
 
Oh, for reference that's not my opinion, that's a paraphrase of something that sunny complains about in every game and I was pointing out that DocE's play is more extreme than previous examples I can think of where she was extremely upset about how much people were bullying her, but seemed to have very little problem with it here in this context

because I'm online watching the last 30 minutes of the thread, I'll weigh in on this. Everyone had said how much she got angry in the past at people bullying her. Perhaps the last word of that sentence is the actual important part.
 
Well I was still trying. Although I was trying only because I thought Robin Hood actually could be kicking around still while you were woof but yeah you're probably right
I was thinking the same thing and thought Robinhood took your teapot and I thought someone else was likely the Sherrif of Nottingham. I was trying to sus out Robinhood to know who was left in the north, but that’s possibly? Probably? all wrong.

so it was the Sherrif of Nottingham who took your teapot then?
Which I love pippy for because it’s a literal wolf in the cartoons.
 
Also @samac I'd like to note that you're still on my vote for what feels like a not very good reason considering I explained (twice) why I village read you and it seems you understood that point. If you are going to stay on my vote I'd appreciate a different reason (ggoats flashbacks).
 
I bring agitation to the table.
Okay, Edelgard

No part about it being this hard on people and being this picky about the stances and phrases I use is fun. But it does (on a statistics level) win games.
Winning games is one thing and I absolutely can get salty when I'm being wrongly yeeted, but I don't think many of us spend 4+ hours a day playing this game at the expense of fun. We all want to win, but in the end... it's a game. Games should be fun.
 
Also @samac I'd like to note that you're still on my vote for what feels like a not very good reason considering I explained (twice) why I village read you and it seems you understood that point. If you are going to stay on my vote I'd appreciate a different reason (ggoats flashbacks).
Excuse me I was going on a tinfoil ride with SAR
 
Indeed, I am. But I've been talking to more than just Enigma today.

#1 She only has two votes.
#2 She's had several hours to defend and still has hours to defend as of now.

Is there a reason me sitting on MsP bothers you?

Why yes, alissa. And I already said I'd give them when they solidified.

Stop sounding reasonable. It scares me to not be scared of you.
 
So April, the big thing here is I’ve come to a conclusion either you, AM, or Finn is a wolf. I just don’t know which one.
 
Eh. Not great. I don't feel great about either wagon tbh

But that also might be because I'm fixated on finding the teapot stealer and samac thinks it's one of the Northies
I don't think it's you and I don't think it's Samac and I know it's not me, so that leaves AM or Finn. If I had to pick a wolf between the two, I'd pick Finn.
 
How do you feel about getting on the DocE vote so I can live?
I would probably make some compelling argument for a third person at this point. You have to know that if I go down every person who voted for me at any point is going to be examined with a fine toothed comb. You may be above suspicion if your role is good enough, but I'd still argue that suggesting going to me over trying to make a point for a third person is a pretty silly move. Just getting a whole bunch of other people to be the topic of conversation for their complete lack of strategy for picking me "just because". Also that rolls got to be really good because you continue to endorse sort of bad ideas.
 
Top