- Joined
- Dec 11, 2014
- Messages
- 16,091
- Reaction score
- 24,339
Got left behind? Very possiblePerhaps it's cause a wolf did
Got left behind? Very possiblePerhaps it's cause a wolf did
Where do we have any evidence that mkg knew they were seered?
Like you're now bringing in conditional factors into this that we have no proof existed in order to make your argument. After I already conceded, that sure if they had proof Z was a power role then the shot might make sense. But that's a big if.
And for whatever it's worth, if Z had actually seered a wolf and had solid mod proof that mkg was a wolf, I'd have expected him to be a lot more explicit about it. I know it's been awhile since I played but "back in my day" people who had mod confirmed a wolf where a heck of a lot more open about it so that we didn't spend multiple cycles debating whether to vote that person or not.
Also just to make it even better he said he would entertain my theory too. So maybe he had something on Finn?I'm not sure if you've played with Z. I would actually expect him to make as strong of a case as possible without explicitly role revealing. He may have done so before the end of day, but they killed him before he could.
I'm also not sure what you're getting at here. Do you think AM is a wolf? Or are you just grasping at straws?
You haven't addressed the reason that I'm voting for you, which is your VCA.
I'm not sure if you've played with Z. I would actually expect him to make as strong of a case as possible without explicitly role revealing. He may have done so before the end of day, but they killed him before he could.
I'm also not sure what you're getting at here. Do you think AM is a wolf? Or are you just grasping at straws?
You haven't addressed the reason that I'm voting for you, which is your VCA.
None of this was secret information. Which means none of it actually matters to you. So how about you actually ask me what you want to know instead of saying I "didn't address it".
It seems like your more concerned with clearing the vig shot than clearing yourself, which is weird.
That's why I'm engaging with you rather than just plopping a vote down.
I obviously don't speak for anyone else, but the best way to get me off this vote is to present me with something more likely to net a wolf.
You made a statement that didn't warrant a response. Then didn't like the fact that I didn't respond. So I went ahead and repeated information that you should already have if you read the thread and we've accomplished nothing.
And you haven't asked anything further so...
So you would prefer me not to engage with you, when I'm pushing for your vote?
Fair enough. Good luck.
Uh no, what I was saying is that despite your claim that you're "engaging" you aren't.
I repeated the reasoning since you apparently wanted to hear it. I also invited t you ask questions. You said nothing about any of the reasoning I provided and asked zero questions.
Maybe we have different definitions of "engagement" but that's certainly not how I define it.
You banged on about the vig shot just as much as I did because we were having a discussion.I agree we have very different interpretations of the vig shot. It's weird that you are so intent on defending it.
You haven't really defended your VCA. It's not the only one that is lacking, but it doesn't look good.
If you or someone else can give me a better place to plant it, then I'm listening. But you haven't done that so far. Give me something to engage with.
This might be really out there but what popped into my head just now was the Child Catcher from Chitty Chitty Bang Bang lolAlso, for if my location theory proves right if anyone has any suspects for someone who is evil with candy from London lore/history that would be cool knowledge.
You banged on about the vig shot just as much as I did because we were having a discussion.
In your day to day life when you start a debate with someone do they just randomly walk away in the middle? Or just bow down and say that your opinion is right?
I explained my votes. What kind of defense are you looking for if that wasn't it? This is exactly what I mean when I say that despite your claim to the contrary you are not engaging. And based on the next quote, have zero interest in doing so.
So in other words you don't actually want to engage with me or assess my play. None of my explanations actually matter to you. Which you know, I stated in the first place but then you dragged me through this song and dance of pretending you wanted to engage. Clearly, I should have just gone to bed.
You said you didn't want to have a discussion. Then you walked away in the middle. I'm not sure what you are getting at here.
An actual defense would help. What have you given me?
I've given you more time than I've given anyone else so far this game. You've yet to give me a reason not to vote for you.
I'll even give you a freebie, mkg had you as a wolfread. Why not use that as a defense? If you aren't a wolf who is?
AM, me, Capri? There is a decent case against you and you've given nothing to the contrary.
And I'm one of the nice ones.
When? The part where you misinterpreted me calling you out for not actually engaging as tell you I didn't want you to engage? Because pretty sure I'm still standing here in this stupid discussion even though it's past midnight.
What I was getting at is you keep accusing me of being too intent on defending my opinion in regards to the vig shot. But you kept responding me and to basically call me "weird" for responding to you is a level of ridiculousness I can't even comprehend.
Though you know what, I am done with this discussion now.
How about you tell me what an "actual defense" is if explaining my votes/actions doesn't qualify? Because I already did that.
"mkg had me as a wolf read" is a pretty poor defense but thanks for the unnecessary "freebie". Wolves put other wolves in their reads all the time. Which I'm sure is exactly what you would have said had I brought that up on my own--which ya know adds to that feeling of being gaslit.
I've also mentioned people I'm suspicious of as wolves though you're sitting here pretending that I haven't
I've provided reasons the theory probably isn't correct.
I've provided reasons for my votes.
I've provided thoughts on people I thought were suspicious.
None of that is convincing you? Fine. That's fair enough. People aren't always convinced.
But drop the crap about claiming that I simply haven't defended at all. It's demonstrably false and I'm not going to sit here repeating myself over and over again while you tell me "not good enough". I would far rather you just admitted that nothing short of some magical mod information is going to change your mind than sit here dragging me through this song and dance.
This is a game. It's supposed to be fun. And right now, it isn't. At all.
I'm out for the day.
You all want to waste it tunnelled on me? Knock yourself out.
I wasn't sure of anything and said as much. I don't see how it damns me to have put it in YOUR hands. If you want to use that logic you should be damned as well for not voting mkg. At no point was I trying very hard to preserve her.Also, anyone else a little suspicious of cray after intentionally making it a tie because she was sure I’d break it in mkg’s favor?
I'm worried she is.Dubz, are you wolfing?
I don't know why you think you're entitled to every bit of info... and anyway didn't you break a tie to kill a villager over a wolf? Not sure that makes you the best person to trust with everything any way.So it wasn’t me who got left behind. No one else has owned up to it and I think everyone else has posted? Why tf is someone keeping that a secret?
Guys I got so much **** today I’m sorry. Pippy has had to put up with me for 48 whole hours. Y’all should show her some love for that.
How were you silenced anyway? Side effect of breaking tie?So it wasn’t me who got left behind. No one else has owned up to it and I think everyone else has posted? Why tf is someone keeping that a secret?
Guys I got so much **** today I’m sorry. Pippy has had to put up with me for 48 whole hours. Y’all should show her some love for that.
I'll point out that D2 I didn't know how samac would break the tie so I was putting mkg in danger staying on Zenge. Remember she asked me to move and I wouldn't?this is awkward because for some reason I though there'd be more colors
If someone has a final day 1 tally I can add it
Day Two - Keep Calm and WW On - Vote Tally
AM (1) - bobloblaw
Alissa (1) - stagg
Zenge (1) - Cray
Bobloblaw (1) - Ms P
Viscernable (7) - cyndia, capri, sunshine, sporty, mkg, samac, finn
Sunshine (1) - LIS
DocEspana (1) - Mayo
Dina (1) - dubz
Finn (2) - genny, alley
MKG (7) - barks, zenge, AM, dina, bread, DocE, visc
Capri (1) - alissa
Day 3 - Am I Sitting in a Tin Can - Vote Tally
Bread (6) - mkg, AM, sporty, dubz, Ms P, alissa
Sunshine (2) - DocE, LIS
MKG (7) - Dina, capri, barks, Stagg, Cyndia, mayo, crayola
Barks (1) - Bobloblaw
Finn (3) - samac, alley, genny
LIS (1) - Sunshine
Capri (1) - Finn
I don't trust your interpretation of what you were told in mod PM where you got a foil - not necessarily about our locations being relevant to roles - but that what happened to you the one night, is a wolf for sure.FOR THE LOVE OF GOD I SHOUTED ABOUT IT FOR THE WHOLE FIRST DAY BARRERRRKKKKKKSSSS.
The sheriff of Nottingham is in the game. I guess likely in the north given location importance’s.
Hmm maybe you're a wolf, wolves didn't do it, and you're trying to capitalize on susif no one claims the shot by morning i'm switching my vote to sunny and/or investigating z's potential pm partners
What would a 3P have to gain by that, that a villager or wolf wouldn't? Weird doesn't always mean 3p.It just seems too good to be true that a wolf would take that shot. It was... an odd choice for a villager to make, but with so many other less conspicuous choices, I don’t think wolves would’ve made it either.
...or they’d at least wait til night to make it.
I’m honestly wondering if the vig is 3P, based on that.
I'm wondering if this is some TMI leaking from the wolves, they weren't responsible for the shot on genny or on zenge and they're looking for the villager or 3P with kill powers.I thought they tried to shoot you?
Some are anytime, particularly vig shots. There's others like the executioner role TME had when she flipped. So we know one role in the game was.This is weird. Most abilities (I think) are day or night, but not any time of day.
At least, that's how I remember it. So 'wait til night' seems weird.
Yeah it's a bad look for samac, don't know what I make of the fact the first thing after mkg's flip she wants to throw shade on me. I'm not the one killed a villager to keep mkg alive.I can't reconcile mkg being a wolf and the vig shot also being wolfy. I can see either being true, but I can't wrap my head around both being true.
I don't really have much of a read on mkg to begin with.I'd love to ask samac more about why she felt mkg was being genuine--are we talking about the information seemed legit and if so, why or are we talking about "I just get good feels". I'd tried to parse this out during the vote, but given the short time frame I don't feel I really got to pursue that as much as I would have liked. Neither Vis nor mkg were my first choice yesterday.
@WildZoo I'm too lazy to find your post again and quote it but why do you feel better about alissa? I'm still thinking possible sketch and I'm not seeing anything that makes me rethink that.
I must have missed something. Where did James Bond come into this?
I didn’t even think about this, because I just assumed someone seered the Prime Minister.Yeah it's a bad look for samac, don't know what I make of the fact the first thing after mkg's flip she wants to throw shade on me. I'm not the one killed a villager to keep mkg alive.
omg you didn’t already have these done? Why are you slacking so hard???Incomplete, but will finish after I wake up more.
SAR (1) - dubz
MsP (1) - MsP
samac (1) - shorty
samac (2) - shorty, mkg
samac (3) - shorty, mkg, Enigma
SAR (2) - dubz, SAR
samac (4) - shorty, mkg, Enigma, samac
SAR (3) - dubz, SAR, April
SAR (4) - dubz, SAR, April, AM
shorty (1) - genny
DocE (1) - DocE
shorty (2) - genny, Zenge
shorty (3) - genny, Zenge, Dina
SAR (5) - dubz, SAR, April, AM, alissa
MsP (2) - MsP, sunshine
SAR (6) - dubz, SAR, April, AM, alissa, meats
MsP (3) - MsP, sunshine, Barks
capri (1) - capri
shorty (2) - Zenge, Dina
DocE (2) - DocE, genny
DocE (3) - DocE, genny, Vis
DocE (4) - DocE, genny, Vis, Cray
shorty (1) - Dina
SAR (7) - dubz, SAR, April, AM, alissa, meats, Zenge
SAR (6) - dubz, SAR, April, AM, meats, Zenge
DocE (5) - DocE, genny, Vis, Cray, alissa
samac (3) - shorty, mkg, Enigma
SAR (7) - dubz, SAR, April, AM, meats, Zenge, samac
samac (2) - mkg, Enigma
SAR (8) - dubz, SAR, April, AM, meats, Zenge, samac, shorty
samac (3) - mkg, Enigma, Bread
SAR (9) - dubz, SAR, April, AM, meats, Zenge, samac, shorty, finn
shorty (2) - Dina, Sporty
DocE (6) - DocE, genny, Vis, Cray, alissa, Cyndia
DocE (7) - DocE, genny, Vis, Cray, alissa, Cyndia, LIS
DocE (6) - DocE, Vis, Cray, alissa, Cyndia, LIS
MsP (4) - MsP, sunshine, Barks, genny
MsP (3) - MsP, Barks, genny
DocE (7) - DocE, Vis, Cray, Alissa, Cyndia, LIS, sunshine
RUNOFF
samac (1) - Zenge
MsP (1) - sunshine
samac (2) - Zenge, Cray
MsP (2) - sunshine, genny
MsP (3) - sunshine, genny, Barks
samac (3) - Zenge, Cray, finn
MsP (4) - sunshine, genny, Barks, AM
samac (4) - Zenge, Cray, finn, shorty
samac (5) - Zenge, Cray, finn, shorty, samac
samac (6) - Zenge, Cray, finn, shorty, samac, Enigma
MsP (5) - sunshine, genny, Barks, AM, MsP
samac (7) - Zenge, Cray, finn, shorty, samac, Enigma, mkg
MsP (6) - sunshine, genny, Barks, AM, MsP, capri
MsP (7) - sunshine, genny, Barks, AM, MsP, capri, dubz
samac (8) - Zenge, Cray, finn, shorty, samac, Enigma, mkg, Cyndia
samac (7) - Zenge, Cray, shorty, samac, Enigma, mkg, Cyndia
MsP (8) - sunshine, genny, Barks, AM, MsP, capri, dubz, finn
samac (8) - Zenge, Cray, shorty, samac, Enigma, mkg, Cyndia, DocE
samac (9) - Zenge, Cray, shorty, samac, Enigma, mkg, Cyndia, DocE, SAR
MsP (7) - sunshine, genny, Barks, AM, MsP, capri, dubz
samac (10) - Zenge, Cray, shorty, samac, Enigma, mkg, Cyndia, DocE, SAR, finn
17/28
Missing: Vis, Stagg, Bread, alissa, alley, LIS, April, meats, Dina, Bob, Sportycapri (1) - AM
AM (1) - MsP
Stagg (1) - shorty
Sporty (1) - dubz
Cray (1) - samac
alissa (1) - Barks
Zenge (1) - genny
DocE (1) - April
Sporty () -
April (1) - dubz
shorty (1) - DocE
April (2) - dubz, finn
DocE (2) - April, Dina
shorty (2) - DocE, Cray
Cray () -
Zenge (2) - genny, samac
MsP (1) - Bob
Zenge (1) - genny
Zenge (2) - genny, alissa
DocE (3) - April, Dina,
You’re right. In the 15 minutes before close I had a role reveal that sounded believable and went for the person that I had nothing on.I don't know why you think you're entitled to every bit of info... and anyway didn't you break a tie to kill a villager over a wolf? Not sure that makes you the best person to trust with everything any way.
No, i think I’ve said it but I posted a lot recently. That god damn candy I was given night 1 did it.How were you silenced anyway? Side effect of breaking tie?
For the love of god, I’m sure the sheriff of Nottingham is in the game.I don't trust your interpretation of what you were told in mod PM where you got a foil - not necessarily about our locations being relevant to roles - but that what happened to you the one night, is a wolf for sure.
It seems too big a mod clear revealing a wolf, I don't think Pippy would do that.
My goal wasn’t to throw shade at you immediately after the flip, it felt weird that I had been silent for 48 hours, the lasts posts you made about me were calling me suspicious, to going to trusting me.Yeah it's a bad look for samac, don't know what I make of the fact the first thing after mkg's flip she wants to throw shade on me. I'm not the one killed a villager to keep mkg alive.
I was trying to keep Bread/mkg a close vote today because ties look non-lethal and seeing what people do is valuable. I figured samac either has more info than I do, or if she's a wolf again it's good to see what people do.
I was less concerned about my own personal optics as I was helping people evaluate what's going on.
I do appreciate your enthusiasm in general. It's refreshing to see things from another lens. Just keeps further pushing you village for me even if I vehemently disagree with some of the conclusions.I don't see that it is locked so commenting. Don't want struck again.
Curious to who is going to Avalon? I am trying to think like a wolf and would guess DocE being what we know. Maybe Samac or someone else they have figured out that has PR.
I am way behind but catching up. Regarding Zenge. He seemed like he was on to several things. Try not to put too much confidence in all he said, but he was on sunshine. It reads like he knew something from his nightly cypher or from a PM. It makes it difficult for me to not sus Sunshine almost as much as Finn.
I assume Finn is a done deal. Too bad a look and too much against him, circumstantial or otherwise. And with such a bad situation the defense just don't feel like his heart is in it. Feels like he either knows he is out b/c wolf or b/c bad fate. He would have to reveal or something more drastic to escape.
I think we need to be looking at others in POE. Seems to me Sunshine leads that. Bread is next in line for me but has good moments.
I haven't shook the feeling like there is another twist coming. I imagine I never will. That makes me watch AM, Samac, cray and DocE closely. They are doing well or for other reasons. Anyone that is helping me also gets sus as that is what I would immediately do as a wolf. It happened with MKG and proved out and Sunshine helped too. Cray maybe a bit as well. (no good deed goes unpunished! lol) But please keep helping!
Barks. I just don't think I can get to all the stuff for you. Sorry. My angle was worrying AM was playing us. See who AM was helping the most and see if they had sus material. And through those glasses you did. I figured your flip may give two flips. Still watching.
Here is my list. More for me than you guys. It will help me keep things straight. This is the last time I play without keeping a running list of half organized ideas b/c you chaps all start running together except for the frequent posters.
neutral/POE- Finn, Sunshine, Bread
Don't want to be betrayed by- DocE (it would be too awesome for wolves if he was King John), AM (going to make me feel that way until I learn her meta), Cray (had style and nice to me for very opinionated person. And putting MKG decision in Samac hands was good for info but also sus), Samac (as you can see above, I don't like the thought of a Moriarty type pulling all the strings and making us look like daft gits)
Neutral- MsP, Barks, stag, dina, WildZoo (village with several wolf moments)
Village lean- hold the mayo (has been ace)
Village-me and genny (makes me lol)
I feel complimented that you think I could pull the strings that well. Make a girl blush.I don't see that it is locked so commenting. Don't want struck again.
Curious to who is going to Avalon? I am trying to think like a wolf and would guess DocE being what we know. Maybe Samac or someone else they have figured out that has PR.
I am way behind but catching up. Regarding Zenge. He seemed like he was on to several things. Try not to put too much confidence in all he said, but he was on sunshine. It reads like he knew something from his nightly cypher or from a PM. It makes it difficult for me to not sus Sunshine almost as much as Finn.
I assume Finn is a done deal. Too bad a look and too much against him, circumstantial or otherwise. And with such a bad situation the defense just don't feel like his heart is in it. Feels like he either knows he is out b/c wolf or b/c bad fate. He would have to reveal or something more drastic to escape.
I think we need to be looking at others in POE. Seems to me Sunshine leads that. Bread is next in line for me but has good moments.
I haven't shook the feeling like there is another twist coming. I imagine I never will. That makes me watch AM, Samac, cray and DocE closely. They are doing well or for other reasons. Anyone that is helping me also gets sus as that is what I would immediately do as a wolf. It happened with MKG and proved out and Sunshine helped too. Cray maybe a bit as well. (no good deed goes unpunished! lol) But please keep helping!
Barks. I just don't think I can get to all the stuff for you. Sorry. My angle was worrying AM was playing us. See who AM was helping the most and see if they had sus material. And through those glasses you did. I figured your flip may give two flips. Still watching.
Here is my list. More for me than you guys. It will help me keep things straight. This is the last time I play without keeping a running list of half organized ideas b/c you chaps all start running together except for the frequent posters.
neutral/POE- Finn, Sunshine, Bread
Don't want to be betrayed by- DocE (it would be too awesome for wolves if he was King John), AM (going to make me feel that way until I learn her meta), Cray (had style and nice to me for very opinionated person. And putting MKG decision in Samac hands was good for info but also sus), Samac (as you can see above, I don't like the thought of a Moriarty type pulling all the strings and making us look like daft gits)
Neutral- MsP, Barks, stag, dina, WildZoo (village with several wolf moments)
Village lean- hold the mayo (has been ace)
Village-me and genny (makes me lol)
I feel like I missed something. Avalon???Curious to who is going to Avalon?
LOL. Not afraid to step in front of a bus, you mean? I’m not really one for busing fellow wolves, but I’ll take a hit.That girl ain’t afraid of a bus.
For some reason this read makes me happy. It's where I feel I belongWildZoo (village with several wolf moments)
Avalon is the name pippy gave to the place the dead folks go.I feel like I missed something. Avalon???
LOL. Not afraid to step in front of a bus, you mean? I’m not really one for busing fellow wolves, but I’ll take a hit.
I just really wanted that enchilada hat.Yeah I was already reading genny village but the tie break looked good to me.
I offer my services as co-modWelp my computer is dead, so it may be a bit longer. Too bad Turing is dead -- I could use some IT support right now.
Considering all that it’s doing is likely letting some village folks live longer take your tiiiiiimmmmmmmeeeeeeeWelp my computer is dead, so it may be a bit longer. Too bad Turing is dead -- I could use some IT support right now.