- Joined
- Dec 13, 2016
- Messages
- 284
- Reaction score
- 611
PAYE has been discontinued, but the people who are in the program (signed up when it was still going) can stay with it. Trust me, you will absolutely pay your fair share to the government in due time, heck a major reason tuition costs are as high as they are in the first place has to do with them just handing out student loans like free candy.
I'm not really taking advantage of you, to be quite honest. For example, I served in the military and was paid peanuts for four years, I literally qualified to be on food stamps. If I gain back some of the lost time/money from the government (or "society") I think it's a fair deal. I'm still paying back the loans I took out from dental school, just at a much lower rate because I'm smart enough to use the system that's against me, against itself. Billionaires pay no taxes, scum pay no taxes, the complete burden of taxes lays on the upper middle class (dentists, MDs, lawyers, etc.). Not turning this into a political post at all, but I think the only fair way to do taxes is a flat percentage across the board of whatever you make. Everyone should contribute to the roads and schools we all use.
Another point @LLUDDS15 is that PAYE has definitely not been discontinued. If you took out loans for the first time after Oct 2007 and at least 1 loan after October 2011 then you're eligible. REPAYE is open to anyone with Direct loans. You can choose between both plans if you have eligibility for both. It's between REPAYE and IBR only for folks who are ineligible for PAYE.
For what it's worth, I ran the numbers through my own calculator based on differing income numbers both low and high, and I found the tax penalty to be between $350,000 to $400,000 in 20 years. That's still better than refinancing and paying it back for sure, but the accountants numbers seem off to me. I'm not trying to be disrespectful just helpful. Hard for that tone to come off right online. Also those numbers could be much higher if they raise marginal tax rates. They could also be much lower too if they pass a bailout bill for student loan borrowers that makes forgiven balances tax free. Either way it sounds like a reasonable approach that you're taking.
This is not a comment about your advisor or accountant in particular, but a lot of advisors and / or accountants try to appear competent on student loans to win business in other areas.