HoWWrses: Game Thread

Started by SportPonies
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Browse articles Compare schools My application plan Read Interview Feedback
Practice for interviews Ask an Advisor
Melchizedek said:
Okay show me a hint in the write up or give me some theories who you think is a convert, or where do we start hunting for a convert?
We don't even know for sure if thats how conversion works. In Orchestra, if I had become the only wolf at any point, KD would have given me a night to kill AND convert someone. What if there's an auto-convert when the game gets to a certain point.
Y'all are working with way too many assumptions.


You wanna hear about how I was hungover today after last night and then I got picked up by my parents to go to the hospital for my doctor's appointment where I got x-rays done and finally cleared to start PT almost 3 months after my accident and then my parents drove me to their house an hour and a half away from the hospital, and I got on my computer after taking a nap to recover from hobbling everywhere with a broken leg? Okay cool, now you've heard.

TL;DR. I was busy but still came on thread with hours before lynch close to share info I had.
Click to expand...
Dude, no need to get so defensive. You said cubs not coming on earlier and saying he was blocked wasn’t a very village thing to do. I thought that argument was weak, so I was just showing how the exact same thing could be said about you.
 
CoffeeQuestionMark said:
Looks like wolf Mel 😛
I also recall we tried to pull s scam last game too
Click to expand...
I can't tell if you're joking, but if you're not thats not true and you know it. Literally everyone was on to me almost from the get go last game.

Don't take my word for it, Dina, another person who wolfed with us last game has mentioned that I feel village this game.

Okay fine maybe I pocketed Dina in PM's (Which its up to her to make that judgement whether I did or not, I haven't been very active in PM's this game besides a few conversations at key moments) I even told you Cray has the best record at reading me and she was reading me village pretty hard this game.


Caiter92 said:
Dude, no need to get so defensive. You said cubs not coming on earlier and saying he was blocked wasn’t a very village thing to do. I thought that argument was weak, so I was just showing how the exact same thing could be said about you.
Click to expand...
I was going for "mildly amused and saucy" my bad if it came off defensive or rude.
Its not the same though. Cubs came on and voted for Cray and stuck around to elaborate why. Doesn't take much longer to say "oh yeah, and I was blocked last night." Nope he withheld that information from village, which is detrimental.
 
****************************************************
Day 8 Mustang Sally Monday Lynch Tally

Snowy () -
Mel (5) - genny, Coffee?, Ski, Snowy, cubs
Weim (1) - mutts
Dina (1) - killer
Cray () -
cubs (1) - Mel

8/14 voting
Mel, you are in lead!

Missing: Dina, Cray, Cait, MSU, MJ, Weim

Lynch close at 9pm CST (2.5 hrs)
mustang-sally-gif.251148

all you wanna do is ride
****************************************************
 
The only thing that concerns me is whoever brought up the "small formidable" presence, which we are now assuming is mel vs the "large formidable presence," and the possible village blocker vs wolf blocker based on the description. Are we sure there is still a blocker on each side? Could both of these be wolf powers?
 
cubsrule4e said:
When a conversion happens the wolves cant kill, isnt that accurate?
Click to expand...
This is another one of those "depends on the game" situations. No one has said they were attacked, so I doubt protection stopped the kill. Mel said he blocked you, but I don't think you were a wolf prior to last night, so it wasn't that block that stopped the kill. I'm kind of left with conversion for the reason why no villagers were killed.

Or... the wolves really are powerful enough to kill the mods and we're all doomed 😱
 
genny said:
@Melchizedek I have reason to believe cubs is village, or at least was village up until last night when I'm assuming conversion occurred. Who's next on your list?
Click to expand...
Snowy and Mutts for previously stated reasons.

If we're assuming conversion was last night (BIG IF backed by a LOT of assumptions)
My converts are: KL - has stayed fairly off the radar since being rezzed not many people have brought her up.
Dina - for the above minus the rezz part.
 
Day 8 Mustang Sally Monday Lynch Tally

Snowy (1) - genny
Mel (3) - Coffee?, Ski, Snowy
Weim (1) - mutts
Dina (1) - killer
Cray () -
cubs (1) - Mel

7/14 voting
Mel, you are in the lead!

Missing: Dina, Cray, Cait, MSU, MJ, Weim, Cubs

Lynch close at 9pm CST (~1.5 hrs)
mustang-sally-gif.251148

all you wanna do is ride
 
genny said:
So the one thing that's giving me misgivings about the mel lynch is that no one has stepped up to claim the other blocker, and it's making me worry that the other blocker is the wolfy one and is just staying silent.
Click to expand...

Same. But there are also a lot of people who havent checked in today...
 
genny said:
unlynch mel
lynch snowy

also, has anyone ever mixed ginger kombucha with white wine? it's the perfect end to a really loooooong day.
Click to expand...
Wait a damn second. I built a whole dang argument to show I thought Snowy was wolf blocker only to be disproven as she is in fact the rezzer and had an explanation for what happened with Kara.

So why snowy?
 
Let's pretend for a second that no one who has voted today is an ORIGINAL wolf

Snowy - rezzer
genny - Vouch from Cait
Cubs - Vouch from genny
Mel - village blocker???
Killer/Ski - died village
Coffee - mod cleared
MJ - ??? well he has been voting for the wolves at least

Out of
Dina, Cray, MSU, Weim

Is there anyone we can agree to lynch today as a group consensus?
 
CoffeeQuestionMark said:
MJ - ??? well he has been voting for the wolves at least

Out of
Dina, Cray, MSU, Weim

Is there anyone we can agree to lynch today as a group consensus?
Click to expand...

I don’t really think MJ just voting for wolves should clear him... cause he’s only been showing up to do that.

But I have reasons to feel okay about cray for now, so I don’t think she should be up today.
 
CoffeeQuestionMark said:
Let's pretend for a second that no one who has voted today is an ORIGINAL wolf

Snowy - rezzer
genny - Vouch from Cait
Cubs - Vouch from genny
Mel - village blocker???
Killer/Ski - died village
Coffee - mod cleared
MJ - ??? well he has been voting for the wolves at least

Out of
Dina, Cray, MSU, Weim

Is there anyone we can agree to lynch today as a group consensus?
Click to expand...

I was on cray and no one liked that. None of the other 3 have struck me as particularly wolfy. capri/bryndi were all over MSU so she is least wolfy on that list for me
 
genny said:
unlynch mel
lynch snowy

also, has anyone ever mixed ginger kombucha with white wine? it's the perfect end to a really loooooong day.
Click to expand...

CoffeeQuestionMark said:
Wait a damn second. I built a whole dang argument to show I thought Snowy was wolf blocker only to be disproven as she is in fact the rezzer and had an explanation for what happened with Kara.

So why snowy?
Click to expand...
yes this is a thing.
I forgot Snowy clarified the Kara thing.

CoffeeQuestionMark said:
Let's pretend for a second that no one who has voted today is an ORIGINAL wolf

Snowy - rezzer
genny - Vouch from Cait
Cubs - Vouch from genny
Mel - village blocker???
Killer/Ski - died village
Coffee - mod cleared
MJ - ??? well he has been voting for the wolves at least

Out of
Dina, Cray, MSU, Weim

Is there anyone we can agree to lynch today as a group consensus?
Click to expand...


I can back a vote between Cubs, Mutts, and Dina at this point for self-prez.
If I'm lynched today, or if I'm not and when I die tonight, lynch cubs so I don't have to hate village for the time I outted a wolf and they still didn't believe me 🙄.
 
Melchizedek said:
yes this is a thing.
I forgot Snowy clarified the Kara thing.




I can back a vote between Cubs, Mutts, and Dina at this point for self-prez.
If I'm lynched today, or if I'm not and when I die tonight, lynch cubs so I don't have to hate village for the time I outted a wolf and they still didn't believe me 🙄.
Click to expand...
Not to mention as I look back Snowy, Meats, and I were the only ones still alive that voted bryndi D1.

I HIGHLY doubt the rezzer is a wolf
 
Or I guess I could get ninja'd by Cubs tieing the vote to snowy. Which does NOT make me feel good about voting there.

giphy.gif
 
Melchizedek said:
yes this is a thing.
I forgot Snowy clarified the Kara thing.




I can back a vote between Cubs, Mutts, and Dina at this point for self-prez.
If I'm lynched today, or if I'm not and when I die tonight, lynch cubs so I don't have to hate village for the time I outted a wolf and they still didn't believe me 🙄.
Click to expand...

You do realize you can block stuff that isnt a wolf kill action? You do realize of all the things you COULD block, that a wolf kill is the least likely? Also, a lot of people believe there was a conversion last night and thus no wolf NK. Not sure why you started this tunnel but I think youre either villager thats just wrong or a wolf thats trying to frame me
 
CoffeeQuestionMark said:
Let's pretend for a second that no one who has voted today is an ORIGINAL wolf

Snowy - rezzer
genny - Vouch from Cait
Cubs - Vouch from genny
Mel - village blocker???
Killer/Ski - died village
Coffee - mod cleared
MJ - ??? well he has been voting for the wolves at least

Out of
Dina, Cray, MSU, Weim

Is there anyone we can agree to lynch today as a group consensus?
Click to expand...

Um I voted today - if were trying to vote in a block i think the options should be Weim, Cubs or Genny

Melchizedek said:
yes this is a thing.
I forgot Snowy clarified the Kara thing.

I can back a vote between Cubs, Mutts, and Dina at this point for self-prez.
If I'm lynched today, or if I'm not and when I die tonight, lynch cubs so I don't have to hate village for the time I outted a wolf and they still didn't believe me 🙄.
Click to expand...

Cubs is sketching me out. Lets not lynch me. What's making you think Dina this game?

Edit- typo
 
Caiter92 said:
I don’t really think MJ just voting for wolves should clear him... cause he’s only been showing up to do that.

But I have reasons to feel okay about cray for now, so I don’t think she should be up today.
Click to expand...
I think it makes him less likely to be wolf and I wouldn't be thrilled to vote there but guess I could

So add cray - vouch from Cait
And I'm also going to put Mutts - SOFT vouch from Coffee - if the group wants to vote there I would want to talk to her first

I will put unlynch Mel Lynch Dina for now
 
wow I am insanely behind

7 pm deadlines are killer for me, man

I'll do my best

I'm OK with a Mel lynch, he's had some good thoughts, and I haven't had that wolf get my gun moment with him, but I don't always get that strong of confirmation when he's a wolf and I vote there, it's NAI if I don't get that feeling

there's been a few points that have worried me, his tunneling of Kara, perhaps superficial looking into of other players, the point on AM earlier raised my eyebrow
 
Crayola227 said:
wow I am insanely behind

7 pm deadlines are killer for me, man

I'll do my best

I'm OK with a Mel lynch, he's had some good thoughts, and I haven't had that wolf get my gun moment with him, but I don't always get that strong of confirmation when he's a wolf and I vote there, it's NAI if I don't get that feeling

there's been a few points that have worried me, his tunneling of Kara, perhaps superficial looking into of other players, the point on AM earlier raised my eyebrow
Click to expand...
What do you think of him claiming village blocker and having no counter claim yet?
 
****************************************************
Day 8 Mustang Sally Monday Lynch Tally

Snowy (2) - MJ, cubs
Mel (2) - Ski, Snowy
Weim (1) - mutts
Dina (2) - killer, Coffee?
Cray () -
cubs (1) - Mel
MJ (1) - genny

9/14 voting
Mel, Dina, and Snowy you are in lead!

Missing: Dina, Cray, Cait, MSU, Weim

Lynch close at 9pm CST (1 hr)
mustang-sally-gif.251148

all you wanna do is ride
****************************************************
 
You must log in or register to reply here.